Screw compressors for refrigeration and air-conditioning applications are of two distinct types: single-screw and twin-screw. Both are conventionally used with fluid injection where sufficient fluid cools and seals the compressor. Screw compressors can operate at pressure ratios above 20:1 single stage.
Description. A single-screw compressor consists of a single cylindrical main rotor that works with one or a pair of gate rotors. Both the main rotor and gate rotor(s) can vary widely in terms of form and mutual geometry. Figure 17 shows the design normally encountered in refrigeration.
The main rotor has helical grooves, with a cylindrical periphery and a globoid (or hourglass) root profile. The two identical gate rotors are located on opposite sides of the main rotor. The casing enclosing the main rotor has two slots, which allow the teeth of the gate rotors to pass through them.
The compressor is driven through the main rotor shaft, and the gate rotors follow by direct meshing action with the main rotor. The geometry of the single-screw compressor is such that gas compression power is transferred directly from the main rotor to the gas. No power (other than small frictional losses) is transferred across the meshing points to the gate rotors.
Compression Process. The operation of the single-screw compressor can be divided into three distinct phases: suction, compression, and discharge. The process is shown in Figure 18.
Mechanical Features.
Rotors. The screw rotor is normally made of cast or ductile iron, and the mating gate rotors are made from an engineered plastic. The inherent lubricating quality of the plastic and its compliant nature allow the single-screw compressor to achieve close clearances with conventional manufacturing practice.
The gate rotors are mounted on a metal support designed to carry the differential pressure between discharge pressure and suction pressure. The gate rotor function is equivalent to that of a piston in that it sweeps the groove and causes compression to occur. Furthermore, the gate rotor is in direct contact with the screw groove flanks and thus also acts as a seal. Each gate rotor is attached to its support by a simple spring and dashpot mechanism, allowing the gate rotor, with a low moment of inertia, to have an angular degree of freedom from the larger mass of the support. This method of attachment allows the gate rotor assemblies to pass a significant amount of liquid slug during transient operation without damage or wear.
Bearings. In a typical open or semihermetic single-screw compressor, the main rotor shaft contains one pair of angular contact ball bearings (an additional angular contact or roller bearing is used for some heat pump semihermetic compressors). On the opposite side of the screw, one roller bearing is used.
Note that compression takes place simultaneously on each side of the main rotor of the single-screw compressor. This balanced gas pressure results in virtually no load on the rotor bearing during full load and while symmetrically unloaded as shown in Figure 19. Should the compressor be unloaded asymmetrically (see economizer operation below 50% capacity), the designer is not restricted by the rotor geometry and can easily add bearings with a long design life to handle the load. Axial loads are also low because the grooves terminate on the outer cylindrical surface of the rotor and suction pressure is vented to both ends of the rotor (Figure 19).
The gate rotor bearing must overcome a small moment force caused by the gas acting on the compression surface of the gate rotor. Each gate rotor shaft has at least one bearing for axial positioning (usually a single angular contact ball bearing can perform the axial positioning and carry the small radial load at one end), and one roller or needle bearing at the other end of the support shaft also carries the radial load.
Cooling, Sealing, and Bearing Lubrication. A major function of injecting a fluid into the compression area is removing heat of compression. Also, because a single-screw compressor has fixed leakage areas, the fluid helps seal leakage paths. Fluid is normally injected into a closed groove through ports in the casing or in the moving capacity control slide. Most single-screw compressors can use many different injection fluids, oil being the most common, to suit the nature of the gas being compressed.
Oil-Injected Compressors. Oil is used in single-screw compressors to seal, cool, lubricate, and actuate capacity control. It gives a flat efficiency curve over a wide compression ratio and speed range, thus decreasing discharge temperature and noise.
Oil-injected single-screw compressors operate at high head pressures using common high-pressure refrigerants such as R-22, R-134a, and R-717. They also operate effectively at high pressure ratios because the injected oil cools the compression process.
Oil injection requires an oil separator to remove the oil from the high-pressure refrigerant (Figure 20). For applications with exacting demands for low oil carryover, separation equipment is available to leave less than 5 ppm oil in the circulated refrigerant.
With most compressors, oil can be injected automatically without a pump because of the pressure difference between the oil reservoir (discharge pressure) and the reduced pressure in a flute or bearing assembly during compression. However, this injection should be done after the compression chamber is closed (to avoid capacity loss) but before the pressure is higher than discharge (in case of overcompression), which may be very difficult to design. To avoid this limitation, some compressors use a continuously running oil pump to generate oil pressure 30 to 45 psi over compressor discharge pressure. This pump requires 0.3 to 1.0% of the compressor’s motor power.
External oil cooling between the oil reservoir and the point of injection is possible. Various heat exchangers are available to cool the oil: (1) separate water supply, (2) chiller water on a packaged unit, (3) condenser water on a packaged unit, (4) water from an evaporative condenser sump, (5) forced air-cooled oil cooler, and (6) high-pressure liquid recirculation (thermosiphon). Heat added to the oil during compression is the amount usually removed in the oil cooler.
Oil-Injection-Free Compressors. Although single-screw compressors operate well with oil injection, they also operate with good efficiency in an oil-injection-free (OIF) mode with many common halocarbon refrigerants. This means that fluid injected into the compression chamber is the condensate of the fluid being compressed. For air conditioning and refrigeration, where pressure ratios are in the range of 2 to 8, the oil normally injected into the casing may be replaced by liquid refrigerant. Not much lubrication is required because the only power transmitted from the screw to the gate rotors is that needed to overcome small frictional losses. Thus, the refrigerant need only cool and seal the compressor. The liquid refrigerant may still contain a small amount of oil to lubricate the bearings (0.1 to 1%, or higher, depending on compressor design). A typical OIF circuit is depicted in Figure 21.
This method is used when an oil separator is not available. In this case, the liquid refrigerant carries a significant amount of oil with it. The methods of refrigerant injection include the following:
Direct injection of liquid refrigerant into the compression process. Injection is controlled directly from the compressor discharge temperature, and loss of compressor capacity is minimized as injection takes place in a closed flute just before discharge occurs. This method requires very little power (typically less than 5% of compressor power).
A small refrigerant pump draws liquid from the receiver and injects it directly into the compressor discharge line. The injection rate is controlled by sensing discharge temperature and modulating the pump motor speed. The power penalty in this method is the pump power (about 1 hp for compressors up to 1000 hp), which can result in energy savings over refrigerant injected into the compression chamber.
Oil-injection-free operation has the following advantages:
It requires no discharge oil separator, unless an oil separator is needed to reduce the oil circulation rate in the system.
Compressors require no oil or refrigerant pumps.
External coolers are not required.
Economizers. Screw compressors are available with a secondary suction port between the primary compressor suction and discharge port. This port, when used with an economizer, provides the means to increase compressor capacity efficiency.
In operation, gas is drawn into the rotor grooves in the normal way from the suction line. The grooves are then sealed off in sequence, and compression begins. An additional charge is added to the closed flute through a suitably placed port in the casing by an intermediate gas source at a slightly higher pressure than that reached in the compression process at that time. The original and additional charges are then compressed together to discharge conditions. The compressor’s pumping capacity at suction conditions is not even slightly affected by this additional flow through the economizer port.
When the port is used with an economizer, the effective refrigerating capacity of the economized compressor is increased over the noneconomized compressor by the increased heat absorption capability of the liquid entering the evaporator. Furthermore, the only additional mass flow the compressor must handle is flash gas entering a closed flute, which is above suction pressure. Thus, under most conditions, the capacity improvement also improves efficiency. Economizers become effective when the pressure ratio is 3.5 and above.
Figure 22 shows a pressure-enthalpy diagram for a flash tank economizer. In it, high-pressure liquid passes through an expansion device and enters a tank at an intermediate pressure between suction and discharge. This pressure is maintained by pressure in the compressor’s closed flute (closed from suction). Gas generated from the expansion enters the compressor through the economizer port. When passed to the evaporator, the liquid (which is now saturated at the intermediate pressure) gives a larger refrigeration capacity per pound. In addition, the percentage increase in power input is lower than the percentage capacity increase.
As a screw compressor is unloaded, economizer pressure falls toward suction pressure. As a result, the additional capacity and improved efficiency of the economizer fall to zero at 70 to 80% of full-load capacity.
The single-screw compressor has two compression chambers, each with its own slide valve. Each slide valve can be operated independently, which allows economizer gas to be introduced into one side of the compressor. By operating the slide independently, the chamber without the economizer gas can be unloaded to 0% capacity (50% capacity of the compressor). The other chamber remains at full capacity and retains the full economizer effect, making the economizer effective below 50% compressor capacity.
The secondary suction port may also be used for (1) a system-side load or (2) a second evaporator that operates at a temperature above that of the primary evaporator.
Some single-screw compressor designs use a patented centrifugal economizer that replaces the force of gravity in a flash economizer with centrifugal force to separate flash gas generated at an intermediate pressure from liquid refrigerant before liquid enters the evaporator. The centrifugal economizer thereby uses a much smaller pressure vessel and, in some designs, the economizer fits within the envelope of a standard motor housing without having to increase its size.
Separation is achieved by a centrifugal impeller mounted on the compressor shaft (see Figure 30); a special valve maintains a uniformly thick liquid ring around the circumference of the impeller, ensuring that no gas leaves with the liquid going to the evaporator. Flash gas is then ducted to closed grooves in the compressor screws. Some designs use flash gas with a similar liquid refrigerant to cool the motor before the gas enters the closed compression groove.
Volume (Compression) Ratio. The degree of compression in the rotor grooves is predetermined for a particular port configuration on screw compressors having fixed suction and discharge ports. A characteristic of the compressor is the volume (compression) ratio Vi, which is defined as the ratio of the volume of the groove at the start of compression to the volume of the same groove when it first begins to open to the discharge port. Hence, the volume ratio is determined by the size and shape of the discharge port.
For maximum efficiency, pressure generated within the grooves during compression should exactly equal the pressure in the discharge line at the moment when the groove opens to it. If this is not the case, either over- or undercompression occurs, both resulting in internal losses. Such losses increase power consumption and noise and reduce efficiency.
Volume ratio selection should be made according to operating conditions.
Compressors equipped with slide valves (for capacity modulation) usually locate the discharge port at the discharge end of the slide valve. Alternative port configurations yielding the required volume ratios are then designed into the capacity control components, thus providing easy interchangeability both during construction and after installation (although partial disassembly is required).
Single-screw compressors in refrigeration and process applications are equipped with a simple slide valve to vary compressor volume ratio while the compressor is running. The slide valve advances or delays the discharge port opening (Figure 23). Note that a separate slide has been designed to modulate capacity independently of the volume ratio slide (see Figures 24 to 26). Having independent modulation of volume ratio (through discharge port control) and capacity modulation (through a completely independent slide that only varies the position where compression begins) allows the single-screw compressor to achieve efficient volume ratio control when capacity is less than full load.
Capacity Control. As with all positive-displacement compressors, both speed modulation and suction throttling can be used. Ideal capacity modulation for any compressor includes (1) continuous modulation from 100% to less than 10%, (2) good part-load efficiency, (3) unloaded starting, and (4) unchanged reliability.
Variable compressor displacement, the most common means for meeting these criteria, usually takes the form of two movable slide valves in the compressor casing (the single-screw compressor has two gate rotors forming two compression areas). At part load, each slide valve produces a slot that delays the point at which compression begins. This reduces groove volume, and hence compressor throughput. Because suction volume is displaced before compression takes place, little or no thermodynamic loss occurs. However, if no other steps were taken, this mechanism would result in an undesirable drop in the effective volume ratio, in undercompression, and inefficient part-load operation.
This problem is avoided either by arranging that the capacity modulation valve reduces the discharge port area as the bypass slot is created (Figure 23) or having one valve control capacity only and a second valve independently modulate volume ratio (Figures 24 to 26). A full modulating mechanism is provided in most large single-screw compressors, whereas two-position slide valves are used where requirements allow. The specific part-load performance is affected by a compressor’s built-in volume (compression) ratio, evaporator temperature, and condenser temperature, and whether the slide valves are symmetrically or asymmetrically controlled.
Detailed design of the valve mechanism differs between makes of compressors but usually consists of an axial sliding valve along each side of the rotor casing (Figure 23). This mechanism is usually operated by a hydraulic or gas piston and cylinder assembly in the compressor itself or by a positioning motor. The piston is actuated by oil, discharge gas, or high-pressure liquid refrigerant at discharge pressure driven in either direction according to the operation of a four-way solenoid valve.
Figure 25 shows a capacity slide valve (top) and a variable-volume-ratio slide (bottom). The capacity slide is in the full-load position, and the volume ratio slide is at a moderate volume ratio. Figure 26 depicts the same system as shown in Figure 25, except that the capacity slide is in a partially loaded position, and the volume ratio slide has moved to a position to match the new conditions.
The single-screw compressor’s two compression chambers, each with its own capacity slide valve that can be operated independently, permits one slide valve to be unloaded to 0% capacity (50% compressor capacity) while the other slide valve remains at full capacity. This asymmetrical operation improves part-load efficiency below 50% capacity, and further part-load efficiency gains are realized when the economizer gas is only entered into a closed groove on the side that is unloaded second (see explanation in the section on Economizers). Figure 27 demonstrates the effect of asymmetrical capacity control of a single-screw compressor.
Performance. Figures 28 and 29 show typical efficiencies of all single-screw compressor designs. High isentropic and volumetric efficiencies result from internal compression, the absence of suction or discharge valves and their losses, and extremely small clearance volumes. The curves show the importance of selecting the correct volume ratio in fixed-volume-ratio compressors.
Manufacturers’ data for operating conditions versus speed should not be extrapolated. Screw compressor performance at reduced speed is usually significantly different from that specified at the normally rated point because of the significant effect of leakage. Performance data normally include information about the degree of liquid subcooling and suction superheating assumed in data.
Applications. Single-screw compressors are widely used as refrigeration compressors, using halocarbon refrigerants, ammonia, and hydrocarbon refrigerants. A single-gate-rotor semihermetic version is used in large supermarkets.
Oil-injected and oil-injection-free (OIF) semihermetic compressors are widely used for air-conditioning and heat pump service, with compressor sizes ranging from 40 to 500 tons.
Semihermetic Design. Figure 30 shows a semihermetic single-screw compressor. Figure 31 shows a semihermetic single-screw compressor using only one gate rotor. This design has been used in large supermarket rack systems. The single-gate-rotor compressor exhibits high efficiency and has been designed for long bearing life, which compensates for the unbalanced load on the screw rotor shaft with increasing bearing size.
Noise and Vibration. The inherently low noise and vibration of single-screw compressors are due to small torque fluctuation and no valves required in the compression chamber. In particular, OIF technology eliminates the need for oil separators, which have traditionally created noise.
Twin screw is the common designation for double helical rotary screw compressors. A twin-screw compressor consists of two mating helically grooved rotors: male (lobes) and female (flutes or gullies) in a stationary housing with inlet and outlet gas ports (Figure 32). Gas flow in the rotors is mainly in an axial direction. Frequently used lobe combinations are 4 + 6, 5 + 6, and 5 + 7 (male + female). For instance, with a four-lobe male rotor, the driver rotates at 3600 rpm; the six-lobe female rotor follows at 2400 rpm. The female rotor can be driven through synchronized timing gears or directly driven by the male rotor on a light oil film. In some applications, it is practical to drive the female rotor, which results in a 50% speed and displacement increase over the male-driven compressor, assuming a 4 + 6 lobe combination. Geared speed increasers are also used on some applications to increase the capacity delivered by a particular compressor size.
Twin helical screws find application in many air-conditioning, refrigeration, and heat pump applications, typically in the industrial and commercial market. Machines can be designed to operate at high or low pressure and are sometimes applied below 2:1 and above 20:1 compression ratios single-stage. Commercially available compressors are suitable for application on the majority of refrigerants.
Compression Process. Compression is obtained by direct volume reduction with pure rotary motion. For clarity, the following description of the three basic compression phases is limited to one male rotor lobe and one female rotor interlobe space (Figure 33).
Suction. As the rotors begin to unmesh, a void is created on both the male side (male thread) and the female side (female thread), and gas is drawn in through the inlet port. As the rotors continue to turn, the interlobe space increases, and gas flows continuously into the compressor. Just before the point at which the interlobe space leaves the inlet port, the entire length of the interlobe space is completely filled with gas.
Compression. Further rotation starts meshing another male lobe with another female interlobe space on the suction end and progressively compresses the gas in the direction of the discharge port. Thus, the occupied volume of the trapped gas within the interlobe space decreases and the gas pressure consequently increases.
Discharge. At a point determined by the designed built-in volume ratio, the discharge port is uncovered and the compressed gas is discharged by further meshing of the lobe and interlobe space.
During the remeshing period of compression and discharge, a fresh charge is drawn through the inlet on the opposite side of the meshing point. With four male lobes rotating at 3600 rpm, four interlobe volumes are filled and give 14, 400 discharges per minute. Because the intake and discharge cycles overlap effectively, gas flow is smooth and continuous.
Mechanical Features.
Rotor Profiles. Helical rotor design started with an asymmetrical point-generated rotor profile, which was only used in compressors with timing gears. The later symmetrical, circular rotor profile is easier to manufacture and can be used with or without timing gears.
Current rotor profiles are normally asymmetrical line-generated profiles, giving higher performance because of better rotor dynamics and decreased leakage area. This design allows female rotor drive, as well as conventional male drive. Rotor profile, blowhole, length of sealing line, quality of sealing line, torque transmission between rotors, rotor-housing clearances, interlobe clearances, and lobe combinations are optimized for specific pressure, temperature, speed, and wet or dry operation. Optimal rotor tip speed is 3000 to 8000 fpm for wet operation (oil-flooded) and 12,000 to 24,000 fpm for dry operation.
Rotor Contact and Loading. Contact between the male and female rotors is mainly rolling, primarily at a contact band on each rotor’s pitch circle. Rolling at this contact band means that very little wear occurs. However, even a minor sliding motion can generate significant local heat from friction, and if there is not enough gas or lubricant flow at this area, a local scoring may occur that leads to increased internal leakage, higher friction losses, and sometimes mechanical failure because of locked rotors.
Gas Forces. On the driven rotor, the internal gas force always creates a torque in a direction opposite to the direction of rotation. This is known as positive or braking torque. For the undriven rotor, the design can be such that the torque is positive, negative, or zero, except on female-drive designs, where zero or negative torque does not occur. Negative torque occurs when internal gas force tends to drive the rotor. If the average torque on the undriven rotor is near zero, this rotor is subjected to torque reversal as it goes through its phase angles. Under certain conditions, this can cause instability. Torque transmitted between the rotors does not create problems because the rotors are mainly in rolling contact. The transmitted torque from male rotor to female rotor is normally 5 to 25% of input torque, compared to the transmitted torque from female rotor to male rotor, which is normally 50 to 60% of input torque.
Rotors in an operating compressor are subjected to radial, axial, and tilting loads. Tilting loads are radial loads caused by axial loads outside of the rotor center line. Axial load is normally balanced with a balancing piston for larger high-pressure machines (rotor diameter above 4 in. and discharge pressure above 160 psi). Balancing pistons are typically close-tolerance, labyrinth-type devices with high-pressure oil or gas on one side and low pressure on the other. They are used to produce a thrust load to offset some of the primary gas loading on the rotors, thus reducing the amount of thrust load the bearings support.
Bearings. Twin-screw compressors normally have either four or six bearings, depending on whether one or two bearings are used for the radial and axial loads. Some designs incorporate multiple rows of smaller bearings per shaft to share loads. Sleeve bearings were used historically to support radial loads in machines with male rotor diameters larger than 6 in.; antifriction bearings were generally applied to smaller machines. However, improvements in antifriction designs and materials have led to compressors with up to 14 in. rotor diameter with full antifriction bearing designs. Cylindrical and tapered roller bearings and various types of ball bearings are used in screw compressors for carrying radial loads; this may lead to an increase in the number of bearings. The most common thrust or axial load-carrying bearings are angular-contact ball bearings, although tapered rollers or tilting pad bearings are used in some machines. Use of moldable polymeric materials with higher temperature limits for bearing cages allows high-speed operation of the compressor at higher discharge temperatures.
General Design. Screw compressors are often designed for particular pressure ranges. Low-pressure compressors have long, high displacement rotors and adequate space to accommodate bearings to handle the relatively light loads. They are frequently designed without thrust balance pistons, because the bearings alone can handle the low thrust loads and still maintain good life.
High-pressure compressors have short, strong rotors (shallow grooves) and therefore have space for large bearings. Larger compressors are normally designed with balancing pistons for high thrust bearing life.
Rotor Materials. Rotors are normally made of steel, but aluminum, cast iron, and nodular iron are used in some applications. Special surface treatment or coatings can be used to reduce wear and improve oil adhesion.
Capacity Control. As with all positive-displacement compressors, both speed modulation and suction throttling can reduce the volume of gas drawn into a screw compressor. Ideal capacity modulation for any compressor would be (1) continuous modulation from 100% to less than 10%, (2) good part-load efficiency, (3) unloaded starting, and (4) high reliability throughout the operational range. However, not all applications need ideal capacity modulation. Variable compressor displacement and variable speed are the best means for meeting these criteria. Various mechanisms achieve variable displacement, depending on the requirements of a particular application.
Capacity Slide Valve. A slide valve for capacity control is a valve with sliding action parallel to the rotor bores, within or close to the high-pressure region. It reduces the active length of the housing profile, thus controlling compressor displacement and capacity. There are two types of capacity slide valves:
Capacity slide valves regulating the discharge port are located in the high-pressure cusp region. They control capacity as well as the location of the radial discharge port at part load. The axial discharge port is designed for a volume ratio giving good part-load performance without losing full-load performance. Figure 34 shows a schematic of the most common arrangement.
Capacity slide valves not regulating the discharge port outside the high-pressure cusp region control only capacity.
The first type is most common. It is generally the most efficient capacity reduction method, because of its indirect correction of built-in volume (compression) ratio at part load and its ability to give large volume reductions without large movement of the slide valve.
Capacity Slot Valve. A capacity slot valve consists of a number of slots that follow the rotor helix and face one or both rotor bores. The slots are gradually opened or closed with a plunger or turn valve. These recesses in the casing wall increase the volume of compression space and also create leakage paths over the lobe tips. The result is somewhat lower full-load performance compared to a design without slots.
Capacity Lift Valve. Capacity lift valves or plug valves are movable plugs in one or both rotor bores (with radial or axial lifting action) that regulate the actual start of compression. These valves control capacity in a finite number of steps, rather than by the infinite control of a conventional slide valve (Figure 35).
Neither slot nor lift valves offer quite as good efficiency at part load as a slide valve, because they do not relocate the radial discharge port. Thus, undercompression losses at part load can be expected if machines have the correct volume (compression) ratio for full-load operation and the pressure ratio at part load does not reduce.
Volume (Compression) Ratio. In all positive-displacement rotary compressors with fixed port location, the degree of compression in the rotor thread is determined by the location of suction and discharge ports. The built-in volume (compression) ratio of screw compressors is defined as the ratio of volume of the thread at the start of compression to the volume of the same thread when it begins to open to the discharge port. The suction port must be located to trap the maximum suction charge; hence, the compression ratio is determined by the location of the discharge port.
Only suction pressure and compression volume ratio determine the internal pressure achieved before opening to discharge. However, condensing and evaporating temperatures determine discharge pressure and compression ratio in piping that leads to the compressor. Any mismatch between internal and system discharge pressures results in under- or overcompression loss and lower efficiency.
If the operating conditions of the system seldom change, it is possible to specify a fixed-volume-ratio compressor that will give good efficiency. Compressor manufacturers normally make compressors with three or four possible discharge port sizes that correspond to system conditions encountered frequently. Generally, the designer is responsible for specifying a compressor that most closely matches expected pressure conditions.
The required compression ratio for a particular application can be determined as follows:
where
| CR | = | compression ratio |
| PR | = | pressure ratio = pd /ps |
| pd | = | expected discharge pressure (absolute) |
| ps | = | expected suction pressure (absolute) |
| k | = | isentropic coefficient for refrigerant used, from refrigerant tables (e.g., Lemmon et al. [2002]) |
Usually, in slide-valve-equipped compressors, the radial discharge port is located in the discharge end of the slide valve. For a given ratio L/D of rotor length to rotor diameter and a given stop position, a short slide valve gives a low volume ratio, and a long slide valve gives a higher compression ratio. The difference in length basically locates the discharge port earlier or later in the compression process. Different-length slide valves allow changing the compression ratio of a given compressor, although disassembly is required.
Variable Volume (Compression) Ratio. While operating, some twin-screw compressors adjust the compressor volume ratio to the most efficient ratio for whatever pressures are encountered.
In fixed-volume-ratio compressors, the slide valve motion toward the inlet end of the machine is stopped when it comes in contact with the rotor housing in that area. In most common variable-volume-ratio machines, this portion of the rotor housing has been replaced with a second slide, the movable slide stop, which can be actuated to different locations in the slide valve bore (Figure 36).
By moving the slides back and forth, the radial discharge port can be relocated during operation to match the compressor volume ratio to the optimum. This added flexibility allows operation at different suction and discharge pressure while maintaining maximum efficiency. Comparative efficiencies of fixed- and variable-volume-ratio screw compressors are shown in Figure 37 for full-load operation on ammonia and R-22 refrigerants. The figure shows that a variable-volume-ratio compressor efficiency curve encompasses the peak efficiencies of compressors with fixed volume ratio over a wide range of pressure ratio. Following are other secondary effects of a variable-volume ratio:
Less oil foam in oil separator (no overcompression)
Less oil carried over into the refrigeration system (because of less oil foam in oil separator)
Extended bearing life; minimized load on bearings
Extended efficient operating range with economizer discharge port corrected for flash gas from economizer, as well as gas from suction
Less noise
Lower discharge temperatures and oil cooler heat rejection
The greater the changes in either suction or condensing pressure, the more benefits are possible with a variable-volume ratio. Efficiency improvement as high as 30% is possible, depending on the application, refrigerant, and operating range.
Performance Characteristics. Figure 37 shows the full-load efficiency of a modern twin-screw compressor. Values for both fixed- and variable-volume-ratio compressors without economizers are shown. High isentropic and volumetric efficiencies result from internal compression, the absence of suction or discharge valves, and small clearance volume. The curves show that, although volumetric efficiency depends little on the choice of volume ratio, isentropic efficiency depends strongly on it. Performance data usually note the degree of liquid subcooling and suction superheating assumed. If an economizer is used, the pressure drop and temperature of liquid approaching the economizer should be specified.
Noise. The most significant sources of noise in screw compressors are rotor contact and discharge pulsations. Adequate lubrication and discharge port design can significantly alleviate this issue. If screws are driven by gears, gear noise may become dominant.
Oil Injection. Two primary types of compressor lubrication systems are used in twin-screw compressors: dry and oil-flooded.
Dry Operation (No Rotor Contact). Because the two rotors in twin-screw compressors are parallel, timing gears are a practical means of synchronizing the rotors so that they do not touch each other. Eliminating rotor contact eliminates the need for lubrication in the compression area; however, a small amount of oil may be needed to provide sealing. Initial screw compressor designs were based on this approach, and dry screws are still used in the gas process industry and in some transportation applications.
Synchronized twin-screw compressors once required high rotor tip speed to minimize leakage, and thus were noisy. However, with current profile technology, the synchronized compressor can run at a lower tip speed and higher pressure ratio, giving quieter operation. The added cost of timing gears and internal seals generally make the dry screw more expensive than an oil-flooded screw for normal refrigeration or air conditioning.
Oil-Flooded Operation. The oil-flooded twin-screw compressor is the most common type of screw compressor used in refrigeration and air conditioning. Oil-flooded compressors typically have oil supplied to the compression area at a volume rate of about 0.5% of the displacement volume. Part of this oil is used for lubricating bearings and shaft seal. Different oils are used, as required by the refrigerant or gas application. In the case of oil injection, oil is normally injected into a closed thread through ports in the moving slide valve and/or through stationary ports in the casing.
The oil fulfills three primary purposes: sealing, cooling, and lubrication. It tends to fill any leakage paths between and around the rotors. This keeps volumetric efficiency high, even at high compression ratios. Often, compressor volumetric efficiency exceeds 85%, even at 25:1 single stage (ammonia, 7.6 in. rotor diameter). High internal oil circulation reduces the influence of speed on compressor performance and lessens operational noise. Oil transfers much of the heat of compression from the gas to the oil, keeping the typical discharge temperature below 250°F, which allows high compression ratios without the danger of breaking down the refrigerant or oil. Lubrication by the oil protects bearings, seals, and rotor contact areas.
The ability of a screw compressor to tolerate oil also permits the compressor to handle a certain amount of liquid, as long as the liquid quantity is not large enough to lock the rotors hydraulically.
Oil Separation and Cooling. Oil injection requires an oil separator to remove oil from the high-pressure refrigerant. Coalescing separation equipment routinely gives less than 5 ppm oil in the circulated refrigerant. Compressors used in direct-expansion (DX) systems and/or on packaged units have less-efficient separation capability.
Oil injection is normally achieved by one of two methods: (l) with a continuously running oil pump capable of generating an oil pressure of 30 to 45 psi over compressor discharge pressure, representing 0.3 to 1.0% of compressor motor power; or (2) with some compressors, oil can be injected automatically without a pump because of the pressure difference between the oil reservoir (discharge pressure) and the reduced pressure in an intermediate compression chamber.
Depending on the refrigerant and operating conditions, screw compressors can operate with or without oil cooling. There are performance advantages in maintaining low discharge-gas temperature by oil cooling. One cooling method is by direct injection of liquid refrigerant into the compression process. The amount of liquid injected is normally controlled by sensing the discharge temperature and injecting enough liquid to maintain a constant temperature. Some injected liquid mixes with the oil and leaks to lower-pressure threads, where it tends to raise pressure and reduce the amount of gas the compressor can draw in. Also, any liquid that has time to absorb heat and expand to vapor must be recompressed, which tends to raise absorbed power levels. Compressors are designed with liquid injection ports that inject liquid as late as possible in the compression to minimize capacity and power penalties. Typical penalties for liquid injection are in the 1 to 10% range, depending on the compression ratio. Because of this, and the danger of excessive lubricant dilution, direct liquid injection has more stringent limits than other oil-cooling methods.
Another method of oil cooling draws liquid from the receiver with a small refrigerant pump and injects it directly into the compressor discharge line. The power penalty in this method is the pump power (about 1 hp for compressors up to 1000 hp).
In the third method, oil is cooled outside the compressor between the oil reservoir and the point of injection. Various configurations of heat exchangers are available for this purpose, and oil cooler heat rejection can be accomplished by (1) separate water supply, (2) chiller water on a packaged unit, (3) condenser water on a packaged unit, (4) water from an evaporative condenser sump, (5) forced air-cooled oil cooler, (6) liquid refrigerant, and (7) high-pressure liquid recirculation (thermosiphon).
External oil coolers using water or other means from a source independent of the condenser allow condenser size to be reduced by an amount corresponding to the oil cooler capacity. Where oil is cooled within the refrigerant system by means such as (1) direct injection of liquid refrigerant into the compression process or the discharge line, (2) direct expansion of fluid in an external heat exchanger, (3) using chiller water on a packaged unit, (4) recirculating high-pressure liquid from the condenser, or (5) water from an evaporative condenser sump, the condenser must be sized for the total heat rejection (i.e., evaporator load plus shaft power for open compressors, and input power for hermetic compressors).
With an external oil cooler, the mass flow rate of oil injected into the compressor is usually determined by the desired discharge temperature rather than by the compressor sealing requirements, because oil acts predominantly as a heat transfer medium. Conversely, with direct liquid injection cooling, the oil requirement is dictated by the compressor lubrication and sealing needs.
Economizers. Twin-screw compressors are available with a secondary suction port between the primary compressor suction and discharge ports. This port can accept a second suction load at a pressure above the primary evaporator, or flash gas from a liquid subcooler vessel, known as an economizer.
In operation, gas is drawn into the rotor thread from the suction line. The thread is then sealed in sequence and compression begins. An additional charge may be added to the closed thread through a suitably placed port in the casing or sliding valve. The port is connected to an intermediate gas source at a pressure slightly higher than that reached in the compression process at that time. Both original and additional charges are then compressed to discharge conditions.
When the port is used as an economizer, some high-pressure liquid is vaporized at the side port pressure and subcools the remaining high-pressure liquid nearly to the saturation temperature at operating-side port pressure. Because this has little effect on compressor suction capacity, the effective refrigerating capacity of the compressor is increased by the increased heat absorption capacity of the liquid entering the evaporator. Furthermore, the only additional mass flow the compressor must handle is the flash gas entering a closed thread, which is above suction pressure. Thus, under most conditions, the capacity improvement is accompanied by an efficiency improvement.
Economizers become effective when the pressure ratio is about two and above (depending on volume ratio). Subcooling can be made with a direct-expansion shell-and-tube or plate heat exchanger, flash tank, or shell-and-coil intercooler.
As twin-screw compressors are unloaded, economizer pressure with a fixed port falls toward suction pressure. The additional capacity and improved efficiency of the economizer system is no longer available below a certain percentage of capacity, depending on design. Some compressors have the economizer port in the slide valve. This allows the economizer to be active down to the lowest percentage of capacity.
Hermetic and Semihermetic Compressors. Hermetic and semihermetic screw compressors are commercially available through 200 tons of refrigeration effect using R-22 or equivalent HFCs. Hermetic motors can operate under discharge, suction, or intermediate pressure. Motor cooling can be with gas, oil, and/or liquid refrigerant. Oil separation for these types of compressors may be accomplished with either an integrated oil separator or a separately mounted oil separator in the system. Figures 38 to 41 show four types of fixed-speed twin-screw compressors with slide valve unloading systems. For the lower capacity range (7 to 17 tons), welded-shell horizontal hermetic compressors are also available. Because of their smooth running characteristics, small size, and good capability for frequency inverter drive (1200 to 5220 rpm), they are preferable for railway and other transportation air-conditioning systems.
The increasing application of frequency-inverter drives for highly efficient capacity modulation by speed variation resulted in numerous further developments. Twin-screw technology in general shows very good potential for increasing operational speed above synchronous levels (3000 rpm at 50 Hz, 3600 rpm at 60 Hz), thus providing higher cooling capacity at full-load conditions as well as a wider speed range for capacity modulation. Consequently, the nominal displacement and physical size of the compressor can be reduced, which can reduce cost to partly compensate for the extra cost of the inverter drive.
Besides individually packaging the compressor with an external frequency inverter (air-, water-, or refrigerant-cooled), some recent designs include an integrated, refrigerant-cooled drive. Because of the very intensive inverter cooling, this solution can be very compact. There is also no need for maintenance, and ambient temperature conditions do not influence performance and life span.
For the lowest possible efficiency losses, the evaporated refrigerant leaving the cold plate (also the base frame for the inverter assembly) is sucked into a closed pocket of the rotor profile. Figure 42 shows a sectional drawing of a compressor with an integrated refrigerant-cooled inverter.