CHAPTER 16. VENTILATION AND INFILTRATION

 

Providing a comfortable, productive, safe, and healthy indoor environment for building occupants is the primary concern of HVAC engineers. Comfort and indoor air quality (IAQ) depend on many factors, including thermal regulation; control of internal and external sources of contaminants; supply of acceptable air; removal of unacceptable air; occupants’ activities and preferences; and proper installation, operation, and maintenance of building systems. HVAC designers, occupants, and building owners must be aware of and address these factors. Further information on indoor environmental health may be found in Chapter 10, indoor pollutants in Chapter 11, and odors in Chapter 12. Airflow into buildings and between zones also affects fires, smoke movement, and safe occupant egress. Smoke management is addressed in Chapter 54 of the 2023 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications.

HVAC design engineers and others concerned with building ventilation and IAQ should use a copy of relevant building codes and/or ASHRAE Standard 62.1 or 62.2, or the appropriate standard for specific applications (e.g., Standard 170 for health care), whichever applies to the project. These standards are reviewed regularly and contain ventilation design and evaluation requirements for commercial and institutional (Standard 62.1) and residential (Standard 62.2) buildings, respectively. In multifamily buildings (MFBs), Standard 62.1 applies to common areas and Standard 62.2 applies to dwelling units. When designing a new building or analyzing an existing building, check which version of Standard 62.1 or 62.2, if any, has been adopted by the local code authority. An existing building may be required to meet the current version of the standard, or allowed to comply with an older version. Changing ventilation and infiltration rates to address thermal comfort problems and reduce energy consumption can affect IAQ and may be against building code or other regulations, so any changes should be approached with care and be under the direction of a registered professional engineer with expertise in HVAC analysis and design and IAQ. The last chapter of each year’s ASHRAE Handbook has a list of current industry standards.

The energy required to condition outdoor air used for ventilation can be a significant portion of the total space-conditioning load. The magnitude of outdoor airflow into the building must be estimated to size the HVAC equipment properly, and to evaluate energy consumption (if required). For buildings without mechanical cooling and dehumidification, proper ventilation and infiltration airflows are important for providing acceptable IAQ and better thermal comfort for occupants. Note that ASHRAE Standard 55 defines acceptable conditions as those under which 80% or more of the occupants in a space will find it thermally acceptable. Chapter 9 of this volume also addresses thermal comfort.

This chapter addresses (1) commercial and institutional buildings, where ventilation concerns usually dominate (though infiltration should not be ignored), and (2) single-family homes and MFBs, where infiltration has traditionally been considered most important but the provision of ventilation has received increased attention in recent years, including municipalities adopting codes that require dedicated mechanical ventilation in residences. Basic concepts and terminology for both are presented before more advanced analytical and design techniques are given. Ventilation of industrial buildings is covered in Chapter 32 of the 2023 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications. However, many of the fundamental ideas and terminology presented in this chapter can also be applied to industrial buildings.

1. MOTIVATION

Accumulation of contaminants indoors can be managed by three methods: source control, dilution, and filtration. Source control consists of removal or reduction of contaminant sources from a space and is generally considered the most effective means of managing indoor contaminants. Source control can be accomplished by selecting low-emission building materials, furnishings, or cleaning products as alternatives to high-emission products. However, there are situations where it may not be practical or possible to completely remove an indoor source (e.g., contaminants from cooking activities). In addition, some contaminants enter the building from the outdoors through infiltration and ventilation, including wildfire smoke and radon. Although sealing the building envelope can be considered a method of source control, infiltration of outdoor contaminants into the building is inevitable. As such, dilution and filtration via ventilation and air-cleaning systems and technologies are also key methods for managing the accumulation of contaminants indoors. The dilution process consists of mixing polluted air with ventilation air to reduce the concentration of contaminants within the space, whereas filtration consists of removing contaminants from the air. This chapter focuses on the influence of ventilation and infiltration on indoor contaminants. Chapter 29 of the 2024 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Systems and Equipment covers information related to air cleaning.

The role that ventilation and infiltration play in managing indoor contaminants can often be described using a simplified steady-state model of indoor contaminant concentrations (Equation [1]) provided that (1) ventilation is the only significant contaminant removal process; (2) the indoor contaminant concentration can be characterized by a single value (i.e., the concentration is sufficiently uniform); and (3) the outdoor concentration, contaminant source strength, and ventilation rate have been stable for a sufficient time period.

(1)

where

Ci = steady-state indoor concentration, ppm
Co = outdoor concentration, ppm
S = total contaminant source strength, cfm
Qoa = ventilation rate, cfm

Variation in contaminant source strength, rather than variation in ventilation rate, is considered the largest cause of building-to-building variation in concentrations of contaminants that are not generated by occupants. Turk et al. (1989) found a lack of correlation between average indoor respirable particle concentrations and whole-building outdoor ventilation rate, which indicated that source strength, high outdoor concentrations, building volume, and removal processes are important. Because contaminant source strength is highly variable, maintaining minimum ventilation rates does not ensure acceptable IAQ in all situations. The lack of health-based concentration standards for many indoor air contaminants is primarily due to the lack of health data, which makes the specification of minimum ventilation rates difficult.

 Air Contaminants

A brief description of the different classifications and sources of air contaminants is provided in this chapter. More detailed descriptions of the classifications and sources of air contaminants can be found in Chapter 11.

Classes of Air Contaminants. Air contaminants are generally classified as either particles or gases. Although the motion of particles is described by the same equations used to describe gas movement, even the smallest particles are much larger and more massive than individual gas molecules and have a much lower diffusion rate.

Particulate matter. This class covers a vast range of particle sizes, from dust large enough to be visible to submicroscopic particles that elude most filters. Particles may be liquid, solid, or have a solid core surrounded by liquid. The behavior of particulate matter depends on its size, composition, and state. The following traditional particulate contaminant classifications arise in various situations, and often overlap:

  • Dusts, fumes, and smokes are mostly solid particulate matter, although smoke often contains liquid particles.

  • Mists, fogs, and smog are mostly suspended liquid particles smaller than those in dusts, fumes, and smokes.

  • Bioaerosols include primarily intact and fragmentary viruses, bacteria, fungal spores, and plant and animal allergens; their primary effect is related to their biological origin. Common indoor particulate allergens (dust mite allergen, cat dander, house dust, etc.) and endotoxins are included in the bioaerosol class.

Particulate contaminants may be defined by their size, such as coarse, fine, or ultrafine; visible or invisible; or macroscopic, microscopic, or submicroscopic. In addition, particles may be described using terms that relate to their interaction with the human respiratory system, such as inhalable and respirable.

To control the accumulation of particulate contaminants the ventilation system should be designed such that return air and any outdoor air is well filtered before passing through the thermal conditioning components of the HVAC system. Pressure drops associated with this filtration must be considered in the design and installation of the air-handling system. In addition, using additional ventilation air can help to reduce the concentration of particulate contaminants from within a space via dilution and can play a critical role in retarding fungal growth on surfaces and spores released into the air. However, the class of particulate contaminant must be considered before simply increasing ventilation rates. See ASHRAE Standard 241 for requirements to control infectious aerosols.

Gaseous contaminants. This class covers chemical contaminants that can exist as free molecules or atoms in air. Molecules and atoms are smaller than particles and may behave differently as a result. Gaseous contaminants can be divided into gas and vapor subclasses, but can also be categorized into organic and inorganic types.

Organic gases are compounds that include all chemicals based on a skeleton of carbon atoms. Because carbon atoms easily combine to form chain, branched, and ring structures, there is a wide variety of organic compounds consisting of gases, such as methane, but the majority are often grouped into two categories: volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and semivolatile organic compounds (SVOCs). VOCs and SVOCs are ubiquitous in modern life. They are emitted by manufactured wood products, paints, stains, varnishes, solvents, pesticides, adhesives, wood preservatives, waxes, polishes, cleaners, lubricants, sealants, dyes, air fresheners, fuels, plastics, copy machines, printers, tobacco products, perfumes, cooking by-products, and dry-cleaned clothes. Whenever possible, low-emitting VOC/SVOC products should be used. All VOC/SVOC products should be stored outside the occupied space in loosely constructed or ventilated enclosures such as garden sheds or detached garages, and away from occupied buildings’ ventilation intakes and operable windows. When unusual amounts of such compounds are present, using additional ventilation should be considered (e.g., extra ventilation during and for a while after construction projects).

Inorganic gases include all other gaseous contaminants. Most inorganic air contaminants of interest to ventilation engineers are gases, except for mercury. Several inorganic gases are of concern because of their effects on human health and comfort and on materials. These include carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, oxides of nitrogen, sulfur dioxide, ozone, and ammonia. Most have both outdoor and indoor sources and result from combustion processes (appliances, mechanical equipment, and vehicles). In addition, radon and many other soil gases are considered inorganic gases (though, not all subsoil gases are inorganic). Radon and other soil gases are outdoor sources that enter the building via infiltration through the building’s subslab. Source control methods for radon and other subsoil gases, such as differential pressure control and improving the airtightness of the building’s sub-slab, are far more effective than ventilation mechanisms at controlling exposure to soil gas in buildings. See Chapter 11 for more information.

Air Contaminants by Source. Some air contaminants are commonly encountered and addressed as groups or single components originating from a source or having other common characteristics. This section addresses the commonalities and characteristics of air contaminants as a function of source or their common characteristics.

Outdoor Air. The concentration of outdoor pollutants is important because they may determine indoor concentrations in the absence of indoor sources. Outdoor air may, at times, contain unacceptably high levels of contaminants, including particulate matter, VOCs, ozone, pollen, carbon monoxide, odors, or toxic agents. These periods of high outdoor air contaminants can be a result of vehicle transmission, wildfire smoke events, industrial activities, etc. At such times, it may be impossible to provide acceptable IAQ using solely outdoor air, and increased ventilation rates can decrease IAQ. In locations where this problem may be anticipated it is advised to provide automatic or manual controls to allow a temporary reduction of the ventilation rate. If these events are frequent, consider a means to more effectively clean recirculated air during these times.

Materials and solutions. Materials and solutions are the primary source of many VOCs and SVOCs found indoors due to chemical offgassing. In industrial settings, sources of VOCs and SVOCs include solvents, reagents, and degreasers. In nonindustrial settings, sources of VOCs and SVOCs include furniture, furnishings, wall and floor finishes, cleaning and maintenance products, electronic components, foams, and food containers, and office and hobby activities. In addition, they can also occur in antimicrobials, sealants (e.g., silicones), heat transfer agents, and pesticides (Weschler and Nazaroff, 2008).

Combustion. Water and carbon dioxide are always produced during combustion of hydrocarbons in the air. Harmful compounds are created as well, primarily particulate matter and nitrogen oxides. All these products of combustion must be vented directly outdoors, preferably using sealed combustion or direct vent equipment. Venting must meet or exceed all applicable codes. For buildings with naturally aspirated combustion appliances, excessive depressurization of the building by exhaust systems must be avoided to eliminate backdraft and drawing combustion-related contaminants into occupied spaces. Depressurization safety tests, such as described in ASTM Standard E1998 or CGSB Standard 51.71 can be used to assess the risk of backdrafting. Fireplace combustion products should be isolated from the occupied space using tight-fitting doors and outdoor air intakes, when necessary. Flues and chimneys must be designed and installed to disperse combustion products well away from air intakes and operable windows. Chapter 35 of the 2024 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Systems and Equipment has more information on venting systems. Exhaust hoods and fans for ranges and cooktops must vent outdoors. Combustion related to cooking should also be vented to outdoors using a capture hood or other kitchen exhaust system. ASHRAE Standards 62.1 and 62.2 have specific requirements for exhausting cooking contaminants from kitchens that include minimum air flow rates. Chapter 34 of the 2023 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications has a detailed discussion of contaminants related to cooking (including gas combustion) and the design of kitchen ventilation systems. The required kitchen exhaust air flow rates may require makeup air systems, particularly to accommodate the higher fan airflow rates in commercial kitchens. Some residential applications may require makeup air to limit depressurization in tight homes with naturally aspirated combustion appliances or if required by mechanical codes (typically if the exhaust flow exceeds 400 cfm).

Garages. Garages and storage spaces often contain many sources of contaminants. Doors between them and occupied spaces must be well sealed with gaskets or weatherstripping, including their sills, and possibly be self closing. Depressurized sections of HVAC systems for the regularly occupied portions of residences, such as the systems’ air handlers or return or intake ducts, should not be located in garages. If such sections must pass through garages, they must be well sealed and never have registers or grilles installed in the garages or storage spaces; if such spaces need conditioning, they must use their own isolated systems. Take care to ensure that there is a good pressure barrier between the garage and the occupied space, typically using an air/moisture retarder such as heavy polyethylene as well as excellent sealing of the door between. Carbon monoxide sources may be present in garages, so pressure barriers, fire-rated compartmentalization, and ventilation of attached residences are life-safety measures. Separate ventilation systems that slightly depressurize attached garages and storage spaces and that exhaust directly outdoors should be considered, especially when these support spaces are tightly constructed or are in cold climates. Several studies (Batterman et al. 2006; Emmerich et al. 2003; Fugler 2004) of contaminant sources and transport in garages found that, in some cases, significant fractions of infiltration air enter houses from attached garages, and that modern residential garages are tighter than older garages to reduce energy consumption and to improve comfort; garages were previously assumed to be leaky enough to avoid many related IAQ problems. Merrin et al. (2018) evaluated strategies for reducing transport of contaminants from garages to homes and found mechanical exhaust ventilation was effective to some degree at all sites tested, and was the only reliable method at sites with HVAC equipment in the garage. No interventions completely eliminated transport into the living space.

Clothes dryers and central vacuum systems. Clothes dryer exhaust is heavily laden with moisture and laundry by-products such as flammable lint and various gaseous contaminants. Many moisture problems have been traced to clothes dryers vented indoors or to attics, crawlspaces, garages, or other inappropriate locations. Exhaust from clothes dryers, which is typically about 150 cfm, must be vented directly to the outdoors. Similarly, central vacuum systems must be vented directly outdoors to exhaust the finer particles that pass through their filters.

 Sustainable Building Standards and Rating Systems

Good IAQ is necessary for maintaining health, comfort, and productivity. Consequently, sustainable building standards such as ASHRAE Standard 189.1 and building rating systems, such as the U.S. Green Building Council’s (USGBC) Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design™ (LEED®) program, place great importance on creating and maintaining acceptable IAQ. However, preparers of such rating systems, like others, have struggled with how to characterize complex ventilation and infiltration issues.

These issues are addressed in detail by many portions of this chapter; separate ASHRAE design guides, manuals, books, and standards; and the references cited; these sources also provide methods to demonstrate the effectiveness of various HVAC systems and techniques in providing good IAQ in residential, commercial, and other buildings. In all designs, care is needed to eliminate excessive ventilation (e.g., beyond that needed for IAQ or by an air-side economizer) to avoid inappropriately increasing energy use. Increasing the ventilation rate above that required by Standard 62.1, for example, does not necessarily increase the acceptability of the IAQ, although it does in some cases (Seppanen et al. 1999). There also may be motivations for increasing ventilation rates other than health and thermal comfort, such as increasing worker productivity.

2. BASIC CONCEPTS AND TERMINOLOGY

According to ASHRAE Standard 62.1, ventilation “is the process of supplying air to or removing air from a space for the purpose of controlling air contaminant levels, humidity, or temperature within the space,” and ventilation air is “that portion of supply air that is outdoor air plus any recirculated air that has been treated for the purpose of maintaining acceptable IAQ” It may be composed of mechanical or natural ventilation, infiltration, suitably treated recirculated air, transfer air, or an appropriate combination, although the allowable means of providing ventilation air varies in standards and guidelines. Figure 1 shows a simple air-handling unit (AHU) or air handler that conditions air for a building. Air brought back to the air handler from the conditioned space is return air (RA). The return air is either discharged to the environment (exhaust air [EA]) or reused (recirculated air [CA]). Air brought in intentionally from the environment is outdoor air (OA). Because outdoor air may need treatment to be acceptable for use in a building, it should not be called “fresh air.” Outdoor and recirculated air are combined in an AHU or ductwork to form mixed air (MA), which is then conditioned and delivered to the spaces served as supply air (SA). Any portion of the mixed air that intentionally or unintentionally circumvents conditioning is bypass air (BA). Because of the wide variety of air-handling systems, the airflows shown in Figure 1 may not all be present in a particular system as defined here. Also, more complex systems may have additional airflows. In HVAC design, volumetric airflow rates Q are normally reported in cubic feet per minute (cfm).

Simple All-Air Air-Handling Unit with Associated Airflows

Figure 1. Simple All-Air Air-Handling Unit with Associated Airflows


Modern commercial and institutional buildings are often provided with more SA than EA and RA, based on a goal of pressurizing the building to reduce infiltration, but these intentions are often not realized in practice. Mechanical (or forced) ventilation, shown in Figure 2, is the intentional movement of air into and out of a building using fans, ductwork, intake louvers, and exhaust grilles, for example. Mechanical ventilation has the greatest potential for control of airflow when the system is properly designed, installed, and operated; it should provide acceptable IAQ and thermal comfort when ASHRAE Standards 55 and 62.1’s requirements are followed, although issues (e.g., unusually strong contaminant sources) can still result in unacceptable indoor environment conditions. Mechanical ventilation equipment and systems are described in Chapters 1, 4, 26, 28, and 51 of the 2024 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Systems and Equipment.

Two-Space Building with Mechanical Ventilation

Figure 2. Two-Space Building with Mechanical Ventilation


 Infiltration and Exfiltration

Infiltration is the flow of outdoor air into a building through cracks and other unintentional openings and through the normal use of exterior doors for entrance and egress. Infiltration is also known as air leakage into a building. Exfiltration is leakage of indoor air out of a building through similar types of openings. Like natural ventilation, infiltration and exfiltration are driven by natural and/or artificial pressure differences. These forces are discussed in detail in the section on Driving Mechanisms for Ventilation and Infiltration.

Transfer air (TA) is indoor air that moves from one interior space to another, either intentionally or not. Like infiltration and exfiltration, transfer air is driven by natural and/or artificial pressure differences between interior zones. The magnitude of transfer airflow rates is a function of the driving pressure and the air leakage characteristics of the interior partitions.

Exhaust air is air intentionally removed from the building, zone, or space and then discharged outdoors. In place of or in addition to operable windows, small exhaust fans should be provided for localized venting of residential spaces with high contaminant levels or moisture (e.g., kitchens, bathrooms). If local exhaust is installed, it should be noted that the installed flow rate may be significantly less than the rated flow because of duct losses (Singer et al. 2010). Not all local building codes require that such exhaust be vented to the outdoors, but it is required by ASHRAE Standard 62.2. Instead, a local code may allow the air to be treated and returned to the space or to be discharged to an attic space. Poor maintenance of these recirculating treatment devices can make nonducted vents ineffective for air quality control purposes. If not already required by code, consider venting attached garages and other storage spaces to the outdoors, as well.

Natural ventilation is the flow of air into a building, zone, or space through open windows, doors, grilles, and other planned building envelope penetrations, driven by naturally generated pressure differences caused by wind and air density differences. The air density driving force is usually referred to as stack effect, which is driven by hydrostatic pressure differences caused by gravity acting on the indoor/outdoor air density difference resulting from temperature differentials. This is sometimes referred to as buoyancy-driven natural ventilation, although that is a slight misnomer: the driving force for air movement is actually caused by the hydrostatic pressure difference. Buoyancy is present, but is not driving the air movement. In commercial and institutional buildings, natural ventilation (e.g., through uncontrolled use of manually operated windows or other passive openings) may or may not be desirable from the points of view of energy conservation, comfort, security, or control of airborne pollen or other contaminants in some climates and locations. In commercial and institutional buildings with mechanical cooling and ventilation, an automatically controlled air- or water-side economizer may be preferable to operable windows for taking advantage of cool outdoor conditions when interior cooling is required. When moderate outdoor temperatures occur, an air-side economizer control scheme may not only increase the rate of ventilation but also reduce the need for cooling equipment operation (hybrid or mixed mode).

In contrast to mechanical ventilation, natural ventilation and infiltration are driven by pressure differences across the building envelope caused by wind and air density differences. Mechanical air-moving systems also induce pressure differences across the envelope through operation of appliances, such as combustion devices, leaky forced-air thermal distribution systems, and mechanical ventilation systems. The pressure differences from natural ventilation and mechanical air systems are additive, although not always directly linearly, because there are numerous factors involved in that combination. The indoor/outdoor pressure difference at a location depends on the magnitude of these driving mechanisms as well as on the characteristics of the openings in the building envelope. Ventilation and infiltration differ significantly in how they affect energy consumption, air quality, and thermal comfort, and can each vary with weather conditions, HVAC system operation, and building use. Although one mode may be expected to dominate in a particular building, both must be considered in the proper design and operation of an HVAC system. Seasonal weather and other transient factors must be considered, as well.

In most of the United States, residential buildings have historically relied on infiltration and natural ventilation to provide ventilation air needs. Neither is reliable for ventilation air purposes because they depend on weather conditions, building construction, occupant activities, and maintenance. Natural ventilation, usually through operable windows and screened doors, can allow occupants to control indoor airborne contaminants and interior air temperature, but it can also have a substantial energy cost if used while the residence’s heating or cooling equipment is operating. Opened windows and doors also may lead to security, noise, or other concerns. Further, outdoor air pollutants might mean that naturally ventilating a space will introduce contaminants into a ventilated environment, and they would then need to be removed.

Increasingly, building codes require general mechanical ventilation in residences. Heat recovery ventilators are popular for reducing energy consumption, especially in cold climates. Dedicated dehumidification of ventilation air can also aid in moisture control in residences. Residential buildings with low rates of infiltration and natural ventilation, including most new buildings, require mechanical ventilation at rates given in ASHRAE Standard 62.2.

 Outdoor Air Fraction

The outdoor airflow introduced to a building or zone by an air-handling unit (AHU) can also be described by the outdoor air fraction Xoa, which is the ratio of the volumetric flow rate Q of outdoor air brought in by the air handler to the total supply airflow rate:

(2)

where

Xoa = fraction of outdoor air
Qoa = volumetric flow rate of outdoor air
Qsa = volumetric flow rate of supply air
Qma = volumetric flow rate of mixed air
Qca = volumetric flow of recirculated air

When expressed as a percentage, the outdoor air fraction is called the percent outdoor air. The design outdoor airflow rate Qoa for a building’s or zone’s ventilation system is found by applying the requirements of ASHRAE Standard 62.1 or 62.2 to that specific building, occupancy, and HVAC system. The supply airflow rate Qsa is required to meet the thermal load, which is the same as the mixed airflow rate Qma comprising the outdoor airflow rate Qoa and the recirculated airflow rate Qca. The outdoor air fraction and percent outdoor air then describe the degree of recirculation, where a low value indicates a high rate of recirculation, and a high value shows little recirculation. Conventional all-air air-handling systems for commercial and institutional buildings often have approximately 10 to 40% outdoor air.

One hundred percent outdoor air means no recirculation of return air through the air-handling system. Instead, all the supply air is treated outdoor air, also known as makeup air (KA), and all return air is discharged directly to the outdoors as relief air (LA), via separate or centralized exhaust fans or relief dampers and grilles. An air-handling unit that provides exclusively 100% outdoor air to offset air that is exhausted is typically called a makeup air unit (MAU).

When outdoor air via mechanical ventilation is used to provide ventilation air, as is common in commercial and institutional buildings and increasingly in residences, this outdoor air is usually delivered to spaces as all or part of the supply air. Many residences provide continuous or intermittent ventilation via a parallel system that often includes dedicated dehumidification and/or energy recovery to separate ventilation from intermittent operation of thermal conditioning equipment; this is known as a dedicated outdoor air system (DOAS). Similarly, in some commercial and institutional HVAC systems, DOASs deliver conditioned outdoor air separately from systems serving space conditioning loads (Mumma and Shank 2001). With a variable-air-volume (VAV) system, the outdoor air fraction of the supply air may need to be increased when supply airflow is reduced to meet a particular thermal load.

 Air Change Rate

It is often useful to define ventilation rates in volume-normalized terms. The air change rate I normalizes airflow to the space’s volume and is

(3)

where

I=air change rate, 1/time
Q = volumetric flow rate of air into space, cfm
V = interior volume of space, ft3

The air change rate has units of 1/time, usually h–1. When the time unit is hours, the air change rate is also called air changes per hour (ACH), in units of h–1. The air change rate may be defined for several different situations. For example, the air change rate for an entire building or thermal zone served by an air-handling unit compares the amount of outdoor air brought into the building or zone to the total interior volume. This nominal air change rate IN is

(4)

where Qoa is the outdoor airflow rate including ventilation and infiltration. IN describes the outdoor air ventilation rate entering a building or zone. It does not describe recirculation or the distribution of ventilation air to each space in a building or zone.

For a particular space, the space air change rate IS compares the supply airflow rate Qsa to the volume of that space:

(5)

For a particular space or zone, IS includes recirculated as well as any outdoor air in the supply air, and is used frequently in evaluating supply air outlet performance and space air mixing.

 Time Constants

Time constants τ, which have units of time (usually in hours or seconds), are also used to describe ventilation and infiltration. One time constant is the time required for one air change in a building, zone, or space if ideal displacement flow existed. It is the inverse of the air change rate:

(6)

The nominal time constant τN compares the interior volume of a building or zone to the volumetric outdoor airflow rate:

(7)

Like the nominal air change rate, τN does not describe recirculation of air in a building/zone, or characterize the distribution of the outdoor air to individual spaces in a building/zone.

The space time constant τS compares the interior volume of a particular space to the total supply airflow rate to that space. The space time constant is the inverse of the space air change rate:

(8)

The space time constant includes the effect of recirculated air that is part of the supply air as well as that of outdoor air introduced to the space through the supply air. If infiltration is significant in a space, then the infiltration flow rate should be included when determining both the space air change rate and the space time constant.

 Age of Air

The age of air θage (Sandberg 1981) is the length of time t that some quantity of outdoor air has been in a building, zone, or space. The “youngest” air is at the point where outdoor air enters the building by mechanical or natural ventilation, or through infiltration (Grieve 1989). The “oldest” air may be at some location in the building or in the exhaust air. When the characteristics of the air distribution system are varied, age of air is inversely correlated with quality of outdoor air delivery. Because the age of air is presented in unit of time, usually in seconds or minutes, it is not a true efficiency or effectiveness measure. The age of air concept, however, has gained wide acceptance in Europe.

The age of air can be evaluated for existing buildings using tracer gas methods. Using either the decay (step-down) or growth (step-up) tracer gas method and assuming perfect mixing, the zone average or nominal age of air θage,N can be determined by taking concentration measurements in the exhaust air. The local age of air θage,L is evaluated through tracer gas measurements at any desired point in a space, such as at a worker’s desk. When time-dependent data of tracer gas concentration are available, the age of air can be calculated from

(9)

where Cin is the concentration of tracer gas being injected.

Because evaluation of the age of air requires integration to infinite time, an exponential tail is usually added to the known concentration data (Farrington et al. 1990).

 Air Change Effectiveness

Ventilation effectiveness is a description of an air distribution system’s ability to remove internally generated contaminants from a building, zone, or space. Air change effectiveness is a description of an air distribution system’s ability to deliver ventilation air to a building, zone, or space. The HVAC design engineer usually does not have knowledge or control of actual contaminant sources within buildings, so the minimum prescribed ventilation rates of ASHRAE Standards 62.1 and 62.2 define outdoor air requirements for typical, expected building uses. For most projects, therefore, air change effectiveness is of more relevance to HVAC system design than ventilation effectiveness. However, research is beginning to emerge that demonstrates the need to also consider ventilation effectiveness during the HVAC system design process, because increasing the delivery of clean air does not necessarily lead to an inversely proportional decrease in pollutant removal. Various definitions for air change effectiveness have been proposed. The specific measure that meets local code requirements must be determined, if any is needed at all.

Air change effectiveness measures εI are nondimensional indicators of ventilation air delivery. One common definition of air change effectiveness is the ratio of a time constant to an age of air:

(10)

The nominal air change effectiveness εI,N shows the effectiveness of outdoor air delivery to the entire building, zone, or space:

(11)

where the nominal time constant τN is usually calculated from measured airflow rates.

The local air change effectiveness εI,L shows the effectiveness of outdoor air delivery to one specific point in a space:

(12)

where τN is found either through airflow measurements or from tracer gas concentration data. An εI,L value of 1.0 indicates that the air distribution system delivers air equivalent to that of a system with perfectly mixed air in the spaces. A value less than 1.0 shows less than perfect mixing with some degree of stagnation. A value of εI,L greater than 1.0 suggests that a degree of plug or displacement flow is present at that point (Rock 1992).

An HVAC design engineer often assumes that a properly designed, installed, operated, and maintained air distribution system provides an air change effectiveness of about 1. The zone air distribution effectiveness Ez in Table 6-4 of ASHRAE Standard 62.1-2022 provides some estimates of effectiveness for operating in heating or cooling mode, and with various air distribution techniques. These values are then adjusted for commercial and institutional building design when the ventilation rate procedure (VRP) is used. If the IAQ procedure of Standard 62.1 is used, then actual contaminant sources and the air change effectiveness must be known for the successful design of HVAC systems that have fixed ventilation airflow rates.

ASHRAE Standard 129 describes a method for measuring air change effectiveness of mechanically vented spaces and buildings with limited air infiltration, exfiltration, and air leakage with surrounding indoor spaces.

3. DRIVING MECHANISMS FOR INFILTRATION

 Stack Pressure

Stack pressure is the hydrostatic pressure caused by the weight of a column of air located inside or outside a building. It can also occur within a flow element, such as a duct or chimney that has vertical separation between its inlet and outlet. The hydrostatic pressure in the air depends on density and the height of interest above or below a reference level.

Air density is a function of local barometric pressure, temperature, and humidity ratio, as described in Chapter 1. As a result, standard conditions should not be used to calculate the density. For example, a building site at 5000 ft has air density that is approximately 15% less than if the building were at sea level. An air temperature increase from –20°F to 70°F causes a similar air density difference. Combined, these elevation and temperature effects can reduce air density about 45%. Moisture effects on density are generally much less but can be significant if the change in elevation is great (e.g., in a natural draft cooling tower). Saturated air at 105°F has a density of about 7% less than that of dry air at the same pressure.

Assuming the air temperature and humidity ratio are constant over the height of interest, the stack pressure decreases linearly as the distance above the reference point increases. For a single column of air, the stack pressure can be calculated as

(13)

where

ps = stack pressure, in. of water
pr = stack pressure at reference height, in. of water
g = gravitational acceleration, 32.2 ft/s2
ρ = relevant air density (e.g., indoor or outdoor air density), lbm/ft3
H = height above reference level, ft
0.00598 = unit conversion factor, in. of water·ft·s2/lbm

For tall buildings or when significant temperature stratification occurs indoors, Equation (13) should be modified to include the density gradient over the height of the building.

A difference in temperature, which results in air density differences between indoors and outdoors, causes stack pressure differences that drive airflows across the building envelope and is referred to as the stack effect in a building. The stack effect driving force is the indoor/outdoor stack pressure difference at any particular height with the same reference level. Sherman (1991) showed that any single-zone building can be treated as an equivalent box from the point of view of stack effect; if there is air leakage, follow the power law as described in the section on Residential Infiltration. The building is then characterized by an effective stack height and neutral pressure level (NPL) and leakage distribution, as described in the section on Neutral Pressure Level. Once calculated, these parameters can be used in physical, single- or multizone models to estimate infiltration.

Neglecting vertical density gradients, the stack pressure difference (Δps = pinside – poutside) across a horizontal leak at any vertical location is represented by Equation (14):

(14)

To = absolute outdoor temperature, °R
Ti = absolute indoor temperature, °R
ρo = outdoor air density, lb/ft3
ρi = indoor air density, lb/ft3
HNPL = height of NPL above reference plane without any other driving forces, ft
H = height of point of interest above reference plane, ft

Here the sign convention is negative pressure differences (Δp = pin – pout) push into the building, driving infiltration, and positive pressures push outward and drive exfiltration. Note that this is the opposite of the sign convention related to wind pressures. Chastain and Colliver (1989) showed that, when there is stratification, the average of the vertical distribution of temperature differences is more appropriate to use in Equation (13) than the localized temperature difference near the opening of interest.

By convention, stack pressure differences are positive when the building is pressurized relative to outdoors, which causes flow out of the building. Therefore, absent other driving forces and assuming no stack effect within the flow elements themselves, when indoor air is warmer than outdoors, the base of the building is depressurized and the top is pressurized relative to outdoors; when indoor air is cooler than outdoors, the reverse is true. At some elevation in the building, with such conditions, the pressure indoors is equal to the outdoors: this height is the NPL.

Absent other driving forces, the location of the NPL is influenced by the distribution of leakage openings over the building exterior and by interior compartmentalization. As a result, the NPL is not necessarily at the mid-height of the building; with effective horizontal barriers in tall buildings, it is also possible to have more than one NPL. NPL location and leakage distribution are described in the Combining Driving Forces and Neutral Pressure Level sections.

For a penetration through the building envelope for which (1) there is vertical separation between its inlet and outlet and (2) air inside the flow region is not at the indoor or outdoor temperature (e.g., in a chimney or an unoccupied atrium space in a building), more complex analyses than Equation (14) are required to determine the stack effect at any location on the building envelope. Tools such as CONTAM (Dols and Polidoro 2020) can assist in this analysis.

 Wind Pressure

When wind impinges on and flows around and over a building, it creates a distribution of static pressures on the building’s exterior surfaces that depends on the wind direction, wind speed, air density, surface orientation, and surrounding obstructions. Unfortunately, the convention for wind pressures is different from those of internal flows: inward pressures are positive and outward pressures are negative. Wind pressures are generally positive with respect to the static pressure in the undisturbed airstream on the windward side of a building and negative on the leeward sides and roof. However, these pressures depend highly on wind speed, angle, turbulence, the surroundings, and building shape. Static pressures over building surfaces are almost proportional to the velocity head of the undisturbed airstream. The wind pressure is given by the Bernoulli equation. Assuming no height change or pressure losses, the wind pressure can be calculated using Equation (15):

(15)

where

pw = wind surface pressure relative to outdoor static pressure in undisturbed flow, in. of water}
ρ = outdoor air density, lbm/ft3} (about 0.075} at or near sea level)
U = wind speed, mph}
Cp = wind surface pressure coefficient, dimensionless
0.0129 = unit conversion factor, in. of water·ft3/lbm·mph2

Cp is a function of location on the building envelope and wind direction. Internal wind pressure coefficients Cpi also exist and will affect the net pressure that acts on the building envelope, driving infiltration or exfiltration. Cpi are generally lower in magnitude than Cp (Stathopoulos et al. 1979). Cp and Cpi are both accounted for in structural calculations, with Cp and Cpi defined based on the size and number of openings in the building envelope (ASCE 2022; NRCC 2020). Cpi are typically not accounted for in infiltration calculations. Chapter 24 provides additional information on values of Cp and Cpi.

The wind speed most commonly available for infiltration calculations is that measured at the local weather station, typically the nearest airport. This wind speed needs to be corrected for reductions caused by the difference between the height where the wind speed is measured and the height of the building, and reductions caused by shelter effects. Note that these adjustments do not consider local wind accelerations due to building form and configuration (e.g., a “wind tunnel” created between two closely spaced structures).

The reference wind speed used to determine pressure coefficients is usually the wind speed at the eave height for a low-rise building and the building height for a high-rise building. However, meteorological wind speed measurements are made at a different height, typically 33 ft for official weather stations, and at a different location than for the buildings of interest. The difference in terrain between the measurement station and the building under study must also be addressed. Equation (4) in Chapter 24 shows how to calculate the effective wind speed UH from the reference wind speed Umet using boundary layer theory and estimates of terrain effects.

In addition to the reduction in wind pressures caused by reduced wind speed, the effects of local shelter also act to reduce wind pressures. The shielding effects of trees, shrubbery, and other buildings within several building heights, horizontally, of a particular building produce large-scale turbulence eddies that not only reduce effective wind speed but also alter wind direction. Local geological features or gaps between neighboring large buildings can, at times, greatly increase wind velocity. Thus, meteorological wind speed data must be adjusted carefully when applied to specific buildings and their locations. Wind pressures (and hence Cp values) that are measured in wind tunnel tests or predicted in computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations (for building configurations suitable for CFD) include these aspects and the Cp values returned typically are referenced to a wind speed at a gradient height that acknowledges all of the complications described above. See Table 5 for typical shelter factors s. The wind speed used in Equation (15) is then given by Equation (16):

(16)

where

U = wind speed, mph
s = shelter factor, dimensionless
UH = effective wind speed, mph

The magnitude of pressure differences found on the surfaces of buildings varies rapidly with time because of turbulent fluctuations in the wind (Etheridge and Nolan 1979; Grimsrud et al. 1979). However, using average wind pressures to calculate pressure differences is usually sufficient to calculate average infiltration values over the time scales of interest in ventilation. If a more complex analysis is desired, CFD or wind tunnel measurements can be used in conjunction with time series of façade pressures to get more accurate predictions, as might be desired in natural ventilation calculations (Lo, Banks and Novoselac 2010). Note that CFD analysis requires significant expertise and experience to do well. Before embarking on a CFD analysis, be aware of the potential for problems and inaccuracies, and how to address them. For further details related to modeling indoor environments, see Chapter 59 of the 2023 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications.

 Interaction of Mechanical Systems with Infiltration

Operation of mechanical equipment, such as supply or exhaust systems and vented combustion devices, affects pressure differences across the building envelope and thus air change rates. Interior static pressure adjusts such that the sum of all airflows through openings in the building envelope plus equipment-induced airflows balances to zero. To predict these changes in pressure differences and airflow rates caused by mechanical equipment, the location of each opening in the envelope and relationship between pressure difference and airflow rate for each opening must be known. The interaction between mechanical ventilation system operation and envelope airtightness has been discussed for low-rise buildings (Nylund 1980), for office buildings (Persily and Grot 1985a; Tamura and Wilson 1966, 1967a), and most recently for high-rise MFBs (Lozinsky et al. 2023).

Air exhausted from a building by a whole-building exhaust system must be balanced by increasing airflow into the building through other openings or the air-handling systems. As pressures vary, air leakage at some locations changes from exfiltration to infiltration. When using makeup air and no dedicated exhaust, the situation is reversed and envelope infiltration may become exfiltration. Thus, the effects of a mechanical system on a building must be considered. Depressurization caused by an improperly designed exhaust system may increase the rate of radon entry into a building and can interfere with proper operation of combustion device venting or other exhaust systems. In addition, contaminant entry can be increased from garages and other attached storage spaces. Depressurization can also force moist outdoor air through the building envelope; for example, during the cooling season in hot, humid climates, moisture may condense in the building envelope and cause rust, rot, or mold. A similar phenomenon, but in reverse, can occur during the heating, and potentially humidifying, season in cold climates if the building is pressurized. Active pressure control is often recommended, as is proper use of vapor retarders, drainage, and drying of in-situ building materials.

The interaction between mechanical systems and the building envelope also pertains to systems serving zones of buildings. Performance of zone-specific exhaust or pressurization systems is affected by interzonal leakage between zones as well as through exterior walls.

Mechanical systems can also create infiltration-driving forces in single-zone buildings. Specifically, some single-family houses with central forced-air duct systems have many distributed supply registers, yet only one central return grille. When insufficiently undercut internal doors are closed in these houses, large positive indoor-to outdoor pressure differentials are created for rooms with only supply registers, whereas the room or hallway with the return grille tends to depressurize relative to the outdoors. This is caused by the resistance of the internal door undercuts, often partially blocked by carpeting, to flow from the supply register to the return; the magnitudes of the indoor/outdoor pressure differentials created can be in the range of 0.012 to 0.024 in. of water (Modera et al. 1991). Balanced airflow systems with ducted air return and distributed grilles or adequately sized transfer grilles (where still allowed by fire code) reduce this effect significantly.

Building envelope airtightness and interzonal airflow resistance can also affect performance of mechanical systems. The actual airflow rate delivered by these systems, particularly ventilation systems, depends on the pressure differences they work against. This effect is the same as the interaction of a fan with its associated ductwork, which is discussed in Chapter 21 of this volume and Chapter 21 of the 2024 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Systems and Equipment.

Duct leakage can cause similar problems. Supply leaks to the outdoors tend to depressurize the building; return leaks from the outdoors tend to pressurize it. Keeping these ducts within the conditioned part of the building and sealing all ducts well with durable materials and high-quality construction methods, significantly reduces this problem.

 Combining Driving Forces

Pressure differences caused by wind, stack effect, and mechanical systems are considered in combination by adding them together and then determining the resulting airflow rate through each building envelope component. The airflows must be derived from the resultant pressures, as opposed to adding the airflow rates caused by the separate driving forces, because the airflow rate through each opening is not linearly related to pressure difference, but the individual pressure components can be added.

For uniform indoor air temperatures, the total pressure difference across each leakage area can be calculated as the sum of the individual components (e.g., stack effect pressures from Equation [14] and wind pressures from Equation [15]) at any particular height. Sometimes this is written in terms of a reference wind dynamic pressure parameter and stack effect parameter, but this can cause challenges in bookkeeping the reference heights and wind speeds at different elevations.

Equations (14) and (15) can be combined to form Equation (17), to calculate the pressure difference across each leak:

(17)

where Δp1 is the pressure that acts to balance inflows and outflows, including mechanical system flows. Note that for Equation (17), positive pressures indicate flows into the building, and negative pressures indicate flows out of the building. Equation (17) can then be applied to every leak for the building with appropriate values of Cp, s, and ΔH, where ΔH is defined as (HNPL – H). Thus, each leak is defined by its pressure coefficient, shelter, and height. Where indoor pressures are not uniform, more complex and often numerical analyses are required.

 Neutral Pressure Level (NPL)

The NPL varies and is that height or heights in the building envelope where, at that particular instant, there is no indoor-to-outdoor pressure difference. Internal partitions, stairwells, elevator shafts, utility ducts, chimneys, vents, operable windows, and mechanical supply and exhaust systems complicate the prediction of NPL location. An opening with a large area relative to the total building leakage causes the NPL to shift toward the opening. In particular, chimneys and openings at or above roof height raise the NPL in small buildings. When it is colder outdoors than indoors, exhaust systems increase the height of the NPL; outdoor air supply systems that positively pressurize a building lower it (the reverse is true when it is warmer outdoors than indoors).

Available data on the NPL in various kinds of buildings are limited. In tall buildings studied by Tamura and Wilson (1966, 1967b), the NPL varied from 0.3 to 0.7 of total building height. More recently, short-term measurements in high-rise MFBs yielded similar results, with the NPL ranging from 0.2 to 0.6 of the building height (Jo et al. 2007, 2009). Longer-term measurements in two high-rise MFBs showed seasonal differences in the NPL, varying from 0.7 to 0.9 in the winter and from 0 to 1 in the summer and shoulder seasons (Proskiw and Phillips 2008).

For houses, especially those with chimneys, the NPL is usually above mid-height. Operating a combustion heat source that vents to the outdoors raises the NPL further, sometimes above the ceiling (Shaw and Brown 1982).

Figure 3 qualitatively shows the addition of driving forces for a building with uniform openings above and below mid-height and without significant internal resistance to airflow. The slopes of the pressure lines are a function of the densities of the indoor and outdoor air. In Figure 3A, with indoor air warmer than outdoors and pressure differences caused solely by thermal forces, the NPL is assumed to be at the mid-height, with inflow through lower openings and outflow through higher openings. For the low air velocities typical in and around buildings, the direction of flow is always from the higher to the lower-pressure region.

Distribution of Indoor and Outdoor Pressures over Height of Building during Cold Outdoor Conditions

Figure 3. Distribution of Indoor and Outdoor Pressures over Height of Building during Cold Outdoor Conditions


Figure 3B presents qualitative uniform pressure differences caused by wind alone, with opposing effects on the windward and leeward sides. When temperature difference and wind effects both exist, the pressures caused by each are added together to determine the total pressure difference across the building envelope. In Figure 3B, there is no NPL because no locations on the building envelope have zero pressure difference. Figure 3C shows the combination, where the wind force of Figure 3B has just balanced the thermal force of Figure 3C, causing no pressure difference at the top windward or bottom leeward side.

The relative importance of wind and stack pressures in a building depends on building height, internal resistance to vertical airflow, location and flow resistance characteristics of envelope openings, local terrain, and the immediate shielding of the building. The taller the building and the smaller its internal resistances to airflow, the stronger the stack effect. The stack effect can be reduced by effectively sealing the building internally between floors, typically by gasketing elevator and stairway doors, and sealing pipe, duct, and electrical penetrations; these measures, when done by code-approved means, also typically reduce undesired smoke migration during fire events. Gasketing interior doors, especially those from exterior spaces or to elevator lobbies, in tall buildings can also help restrict air leakage paths. That said, the elevator doors are usually the weakest in terms of pressure control, and focusing on sealing the stairwell doors alone can lead to increased pressures on the elevator doors and has a diminishing return on value.

The effect of mechanical ventilation on envelope pressure differences is more complex and depends on both the direction of ventilation flow (exhaust or supply) and the differences in these ventilation flows among the zones of the building. If mechanically supplied outdoor air is provided uniformly to each story, the change in the exterior wall pressure difference pattern is uniform. With a nonuniform supply of outdoor air (e.g., to one story only), the extent of pressurization varies from story to story and depends on internal airflow resistance. Pressurizing all levels uniformly has little effect on pressure differences across floors and vertical shaft enclosures, but pressurizing individual stories increases the pressure drop across these internal separations. Pressurizing the ground level is often used in tall buildings in winter to reduce negative air pressures across entries (reducing the driving force for infiltrating air through doors); vestibules and revolving doors are used to limit air leakage. Vestibules may also be used for elevator lobbies and stair towers to reduce air and smoke movement vertically through tall buildings. However, the consequence of pressurizing the ground floor is that the pressure on elevator doors and other internal partitions is increased by approximately the same amount, which can cause other issues.

 Thermal Draft Coefficient

Compartmentalization of a building also affects the NPL location. Equation (14) provides a maximum stack pressure difference, given no internal airflow resistance. The sum of pressure differences across the exterior wall at the bottom and top of the building, as calculated by these equations, equals the total theoretical draft for the building. The sum of actual top and bottom pressure differences, divided by the total theoretical draft pressure difference, equals the thermal draft coefficient. The value of the thermal draft coefficient depends on the airflow resistance of exterior walls relative to the airflow resistance between floors. For a building without internal partitions, the total theoretical draft is achieved across the exterior walls (Figure 4A), and the thermal draft coefficient equals 1. In a building with airtight separations between each floor, each story acts independently, its own stack effect being unaffected by that of any other floor (Figure 4B). The theoretical draft is minimized in this case, and each story has its own NPL.

Compartmentation Effect in Buildings (Hutcheon and Handegord 1995)

Figure 4. Compartmentation Effect in Buildings (Hutcheon and Handegord 1995)


Real multistory buildings are neither open inside, nor airtight between stories. Vertical air passages, stairwells, elevators, and other service shafts allow airflow between floors. Figure 4C represents a heated building with uniform openings in the exterior wall, through each floor, and into the vertical shaft at each story. Between floors, the slope of the line representing the indoor pressure is the same as that shown in Figure 4A, and the discontinuity at each floor (Figure 4B) represents the pressure difference across it. Some of the pressure difference maintains flow through openings in the floors and vertical shafts. As a result, the pressure difference across the exterior wall at any level is less than it would be with no internal flow resistance.

Maintaining airtightness between floors and from floors to vertical shafts is a way to control indoor/outdoor pressure differences because of the stack effect and, therefore, infiltration and exfiltration. Good separation is also conducive to proper operation of mechanical ventilation and smoke management systems. However, care is needed to avoid creating pressure differences that could prevent egress doors from opening in an emergency. Tamura and Wilson (1967a) showed that when vertical shaft leakage is at least two times envelope leakage, the thermal draft coefficient is almost one and the effect of compartmentalization is negligible. The number of vertical connections for plumbing, HVAC, fire life safety and electrical, the stairs, and elevators means that achieving good separation is difficult. Short-term differential pressure measurements in commercial buildings have yielded thermal draft coefficients ranging from 0.63 to 0.82. Thermal draft coefficients in MFBs have typically been lower than in commercial buildings, ranging from 0.09 to 0.59, indicating a higher level of compartmentalization. This could be a function of building type, or of building vintage, as most of the multifamily studies were conducted within the last 20 years, in newer buildings. Like NPLs, thermal draft coefficients exhibit daily and seasonable variability (Proskiw and Phillips 2008).

Table 1 summarizes thermal draft coefficients reported in previous studies for commercial buildings and MFBs.

4. MEASUREMENT OF VENTILATION AND INFILTRATION PARAMETERS

There are two main methods commonly used to measure the ventilation and/or infiltration rates in buildings: tracer gas and fan pressurization tests. Tracer gas testing is a method used for directly measuring the air change rate within an enclosed zone by monitoring the concentration of a tracer gas over time, whereas fan pressurization tests allow for the characteristics of the building envelope to be quantified using blowers or fans to induce a set of standard envelope pressurization or depressurization conditions and regressing pressure differential and flow measurements to a power law function. These two methods for directly measuring air change rates and characterizing the building envelope air leakage are described in more detail in this section.

 Tracer Gas Methods

As mentioned above, tracer gas testing is a method used for directly measuring the air change rate within an enclosed zone by monitoring the change in concentration of a tracer gas over time. Several tracer gas measurement procedures exist (e.g., ASTM Standard E741 test method), and all involve an inert or nonreactive gas used to label the indoor air (Charlesworth 1988; Dietz et al. 1986; Fisk et al. 1989; Fortmann et al. 1990; Harrje et al. 1981, 1990; Hunt 1980; Lagus 1989; Lagus and Persily 1985; Persily 1988; Persily and Axley 1990; Sherman 1989a, 1989b, 1990; Sherman et al. 1980; Won et al. 2021). The tracer is released into the building in a specified manner, and the concentration of the tracer in the building is measured through time and related to the building’s air change rate. Various tracer gases and associated concentration detection devices have been used. Desirable qualities of a tracer gas are detectability, nonreactivity, nontoxicity, neutral buoyancy, relatively low concentration in ambient air, and low cost (Hunt 1980). All tracer gas measurement techniques are based on a mass balance of the tracer gas in the building and, depending on the number of tracer gases released, either a single-zone (single tracer gas released) or multizone (multiple tracer gases released) air change rate measurement is possible.

 Single-Zone Air Change Measurement

The single-zone contaminant mass balance (Equation [18]) represents a simple method for understanding the behavior of contaminants in a particular area or zone:

Table 1 Summary of Thermal Draft Coefficients Measured in Previous Studies*

Source/Location

Building Description

Thermal Draft Coefficient

Seoul, South Korea (Jo et al. 2007)

40-story MFB with single-height elevator shaft

0.20 to 0.34a

69-story MFB with three separate elevator shaft zones

0.42 to 0.47b

South Korea (Jo et al. 2009)

296 ft high MFB with single-height elevator shaft

0.22 to 0.34a

378 ft high MFB with two separate elevator shaft zones

0.36 to 0.49a

476 ft high MFB with two separate elevator shaft zones

0.33 to 0.38a

411 ft high MFB with two separate elevator shaft zones

0.39 to 0.59a

509 ft high MFB with two separate elevator shaft zones

0.10 to 0.26a

607 ft high MFB with two separate elevator shaft zones

0.33 to 0.36a

Winnipeg, Canada (Proskiw and Phillips 2008)

Two high-rise MFBs

0.40 to 1.0c(winter months)

0 to 1.0c (summer and shoulder months)

Ottawa, Canada (Tamura and Wilson 1966)

9-story commercial building

0.74d

Eastern Canada (Tamura and Wilson 1967a)

Three commercial high-rise buildings

0.63 to 0.82d

South Korea (Shin et al. 2015)

65-story MFB

0.38 to 0.44a

Vancouver, Canada (Ricketts 2014)

13-story MFB

0.09 (exterior envelope pressure boundary)a

0.69 (unit-to-corridor pressure boundary)a

* Adapted from Lozinsky and Touchie (2020).

a Floor-level thermal draft coefficient

b Thermal draft coefficient for each elevator shaft height

c Building-level thermal draft coefficient (calculated using hourly measurements taken over the course of several weeks during each season)

d Building-level thermal draft coefficient


(18)

where

V = volume of space being tested, ft3
C(t) = tracer gas concentration indoors at time t (mass/volume)
Cout(t) = tracer gas concentration outdoors at time t (mass/volume)
dC/dt = time rate of change of concentration, min
F(t) = tracer gas injection rate at time t, cfm
Q(t) = airflow rate out of building at time t, cfm
P = dimensionless coefficient that accounts for loss of contaminant entering building due to particle filtration, gaseous air cleaning and losses on surfaces
L(t) = rate at which contaminant is removed within building by deposition, filtration, air cleaning, and chemical reaction
t = time, min

Assuming the outdoor concentration is zero and the tracer gas concentration can be characterized by a single value (i.e., the concentration is sufficiently mixed), this total balance takes the form of Equation (19):

(19)

In Equation (19), density differences between indoor and outdoor air are generally ignored for moderate climates; therefore, Q also refers to the airflow rate into the building. Although Q is often referred to as the infiltration rate, tracer gas measurements include both mechanical and natural ventilation in addition to infiltration. The ratio of Q to the volume V being tested has units of 1/time, often converted to air changes per hour (h–1), and is the air change rate I described previously in this chapter.

Equation (19) is based on the assumptions that (1) no unknown tracer gas sources exist (i.e., F(t) = 0), (2) airflow out of the building is the dominant means of removing the tracer gas from the space so the tracer gas does not react chemically in the space and/or is not adsorbed onto or absorbed by interior surfaces or air cleaners (i.e., L(t) = 0), and (3) the tracer gas concentration in the building can be represented by a single value (i.e., the tracer gas is uniformly mixed within the space). In such tracer gas experiments, box-type fans are often operated in rooms to enhance mixing.

Three different tracer gas procedures can be used to measure single-zone air change rates: (1) decay or growth, (2) constant concentration, and (3) constant injection.

 Decay or Growth

The simplest tracer gas measurement technique is the decay method, followed by the growth method.

Decay. In the tracer gas decay method, also known as the step-down method, a small amount of tracer gas is injected into the zone and mixed with the interior air until a peak concentration that is appropriate for the given instrumentation is reached. At this point, the tracer gas injection system is shut off and the gas is allowed to decay naturally. by shutting the injection system off, the term F goes to 0, allowing Equation (19) to be simplified to Equation (20):

(20)

where Co is the concentration of the tracer in the space at t = 0.

Equation (20) is generally used to solve for I by measuring the tracer gas concentration periodically during the decay and then fitting the data to the logarithmic form of Equation (20):

(21)

The tracer gas decay method is the most widely used type of tracer gas measurement (Sherman 1990). It has been used in numerous field studies (Kelnhofer et al. 1976) and laboratory studies (Berquist et al. 2020; Grimsrud et al. 1979). In addition, the decay of occupant-generated CO2 has seen increased use by researchers (Batterman 2017; Claude-Alain and Foradini 2002) because it removes the need for mechanically injecting a tracer gas, and more recently, researchers have begun to combine this with CO2 sensors from the building automation system (BAS) to continuously monitor infiltration rates (Xiong et al. 2021). However, users of this method should ensure they consider the sensor accuracy (i.e., sensor drift) when trying to apply data from BAS-grade CO2 sensors in this manner (Berquist et al. 2023).

Like all tracer gas techniques, the decay method has advantages and disadvantages. One advantage is that, because logarithms of concentration are taken, only relative concentrations are needed, which can simplify calibration of concentration-measuring equipment. Also, the tracer gas injection rate need not be measured, although it must be controlled so that the tracer gas concentrations are within the range of the concentration-measuring device. The concentration-measuring equipment can be located on site, or building samples can be collected in suitable containers (e.g., grab bags) and analyzed elsewhere.

The most serious problem with the decay technique is imperfect mixing of tracer gas with interior air, both at initial injection and during decay. Equations (20) and (21) assume that the tracer gas concentration within the building is uniform at any time. If the tracer is not well mixed, this assumption is not appropriate and the determination of I is subject to errors. It is difficult to estimate the magnitude of errors caused by poor mixing, and there has been little analysis of this problem. Sometimes a two-zone model is applied to a room, and a mixing coefficient is selected, to estimate the effect of poor mixing [e.g., Rock (1992)].

Growth. The tracer gas growth method is also known as the step-up method and is similar to the decay method except that the initial tracer gas concentration is low and the injected tracer gas is increased suddenly during the test. The growth method is slightly more complex than the decay method because the rate the tracer gas is injected into the space must be considered. This method must also account for any sources of the tracer gas during the decay period; however, decay periods where no source is present are often used for simplicity/improved measurement accuracy.

 Constant Concentration

In a tracer gas test using the constant concentration technique, the tracer gas injection rate is adjusted to maintain a constant concentration within the building. If the concentration is truly constant, then Equation (19) reduces to Equation (22):

(22)

There is less experience with this technique than with the decay procedure, but an increasing number of applications for it exist (Bohac et al. 1985; Collet 1981; Fortmann et al. 1990; Kumar et al. 1979; Walker and Forest 1995; Walker and Wilson 1998; Wilson and Walker 1993).

Because tracer gas injection is continuous, no initial mixing period is required. Another advantage is that tracer gas injection into each zone of the building can be separately controlled; thus, the amount of outdoor air flowing into each zone can be determined. This procedure is best suited for longer-term continuous monitoring of fluctuating infiltration rates. One disadvantage is that it requires measurement of absolute tracer concentrations and injection rates. Also, imperfect mixing of the tracer and interior air causes a delay in the response of the concentration to changes in the injection rate.

 Constant Injection

In a tracer gas test using the constant-injection method, the tracer gas is constantly injected at a nonzero rate. During this time, the concentration response in space is monitored, allowing for Equation (19) to be simplified to Equation (23) (assuming the atmospheric concentration of the tracer gas is zero).

(23)

After sufficient time, the transient term reduces to zero, the concentration attains equilibrium, and Equation (23) reduces to

(24)

Equation (24) is valid only when air change rate I and airflow rate Q are constant; thus, this technique is only appropriate for systems at or near equilibrium. It is particularly useful in spaces with mechanical ventilation or with high air change rates. Constant injection requires measurement of absolute concentrations and injection rates.

Dietz et al. (1986) used a special case of the constant-injection technique, using permeation tubes as a tracer gas source. The tubes release the tracer at an ideally constant rate into the building being tested, and a sampling tube packed with an adsorbent collects the tracer from the interior air at a constant rate by diffusion. After a sampling period of one week or more, the sampler is removed and analyzed to determine the average tracer gas concentration in the building during the sampling period. Solving Equation (19) for C and taking the time average gives

(25)

where <. . .> denotes time average. Note that the time average of dC/dt is assumed to equal zero.

Equation (25) shows that the average tracer concentration <C> and injection rate F can be used to calculate the average of the inverse airflow rate. The average of the inverse is less than the inverse of the actual average, with the magnitude of this difference depending on the distribution of airflow rates during the measurement period. Sherman and Wilson (1986) calculated these differences to be about 20% for one-month averaging periods. Differences greater than 30% have been measured when occupant airing of houses caused large changes in air change rate; errors from 5 to 30% were measured when the variation was caused by weather effects (Bohac et al. 1987). Longer averaging periods and large changes in air change rates during the measurement periods generally lead to larger differences between the average inverse change rate and the inverse of the actual average rate.

 Multizone Air Change Measurement

Equation (19) assumes a single, well-mixed enclosure, and the techniques described are for single-zone measurements. Multizone measurement techniques address airflow between internal zones and between the exterior and individual internal zones (Fortmann et al. 1990; Harrje et al. 1985, 1990; Sherman and Dickerhoff 1989). These techniques are important when considering the transport of contaminants from one room of a building to another. A theoretical development is provided by Sinden (1978).

Multizone measurements typically use multiple tracer gases for the different zones. The contaminant mass balance between two zones is described by the following equations (Enai et al. 1990). If two tracer gases g and s are injected into rooms 1 and 2, respectively, and their concentrations are monitored, the six unknown airflow rates can be calculated as follows (assuming the tracer gas concentrations outside the rooms are negligible):

Room 1

(26)

(27)

Room 2

(28)

(29)

The mass flow balance equations for the two rooms are

Room 1

(30)

Room 2

(31)

where

V = volume of space being tested, ft3
C(t) = tracer gas concentration indoors at time t (mass/volume)
Cout(t) = tracer gas concentration outdoors at time t (mass/volume)
dC/dt = time rate of change of concentration, min–1
F(t) = tracer gas injection rate at time t, cfm
Q(t) = airflow rate between spaces at time t, cfm
t = time, min

Subscripts 0, 1, and 2 indicate the outdoors, room 1, and room 2, respectively (e.g., F10 indicates that airflow is from room 1 to the outdoors).

The main limitation of the multitracer technique is that of measurement uncertainty. As a result, a proper uncertainty analysis is essential in all multizone flow determination (Charlesworth 1988; D’Ottavio et al. 1988).

 Fan Pressurization Tests

A building’s envelope leakage can be measured with pressurization testing, commonly called a blower-door test. Unlike tracer gas methods, which characterize effective, in-service air change rates and are highly weather dependent, fan pressurization tests characterize building envelope airtightness independent of weather conditions; some jurisdictions now mandate that residential and/or commercial buildings be tested and rated.

In this procedure, a large, variable-flow fan or blower is mounted in a door or window and induces a large, roughly uniform pressure difference across the building shell (e.g., ANSI/RESNET/ICC Standard 380; ASTM Standards E779, E1827, and E3158; CGSB Standard 149.10; ISO Standard 9972; U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE] 2013). Note that while all of these standards follow the same general procedure, each standard has been developed for use in a specific type of building and thus these standards are not interchangeable.

The airflow required to maintain this roughly uniform pressure difference is measured simultaneously. The leakier the building is, the more airflow is required to induce a specific indoor/outdoor pressure difference. The airflow rate is generally measured at a series of pressure differences ranging from about 0.04 to 0.30 in. of water, though some test standards require test pressures greater than 0.50 in. of water. The test pressures induced by the fan must be greater than baseline differential pressures from wind and/or stack effect. Lower test pressure ranges are generally acceptable for low-rise buildings or single-family homes, where baseline differential pressures are low. Large buildings, or dwelling units in high-rise MFBs, typically experience larger baseline pressures, necessitating larger test pressures. Fan pressurization tests can be completed under pressurization, depressurization, or both (where the resulting air leakage rate is an average of the pressurization and depressurization tests). The use of pressurization versus depressurization will depend on the referenced test standard and the purpose of the test. Averaging pressurization and depressurization tests is considered best practice, as buildings will experience both pressurization and depressurization in-service; however, this is not always feasible. Pressurization tests tend to yield higher air leakage rates, compared to depressurization tests, as the large, positive test pressures can force open dampers or other flexible air seals during testing. Depressurization-only tests are typically used when measuring the operational air leakage rate of a building (i.e., the air leakage rate with all HVAC openings left unsealed). Depressurization tests may not be appropriate in buildings with unabated hazardous materials, such as asbestos or mold, which may be dislodged by the large test pressures. These factors should be considered when selecting an appropriate test method.

The resulting data from a fan pressurization test consists of several pairs of pressure difference and airflow rate measurements. An example of typical data is shown in Figure 5. These data points characterize the air leakage of a building and are generally converted to a single value, reported at a standard test pressure, which is taken as the building’s airtightness. There are several different measures of airtightness, most of which involve fitting the data to a curve describing the relationship between the airflow Q through an opening in the building envelope and the pressure difference Δp across it. This relationship is called the leakage function of the opening. The form of the leakage function depends on the geometry of the opening. Background theoretical material relevant to leakage functions may be found in Chastain et al. (1987), Etheridge (1977), Hopkins and Hansford (1974), Kronvall (1980), and Walker et al. (1997).

Airflow Rate Versus Pressure Difference Data from Whole-House Pressurization Test

Figure 5. Airflow Rate Versus Pressure Difference Data from Whole-House Pressurization Test


Openings in a building envelope are usually not uniform in geometry, and wind varies, so generally flow never becomes fully developed. Each opening in the building envelope, however, is often described by Equation (32), commonly called the power law equation:

(32)

where

Q = airflow through opening, cfm
c = flow coefficient, cfm/(in. of water)n
p = pressure differential, in. of water
n = pressure exponent, dimensionless

Sherman (1992a) showed how the power law can be developed analytically by looking at developing laminar flow in short pipes. Equation (32) only approximates the relationship between Q and Δp. Measurements of single cracks (Honma 1975; Kreith and Eisenstadt 1957) show that n can vary if Δp changes over a wide range. Additional investigation of pressure and flow data for simple cracks by Chastain et al. (1987) indicated the importance of adequately characterizing the three-dimensional geometry of openings and the entrance and exit effects. Walker et al. (1997) showed that, for the arrays of cracks in a building envelope over the range of pressures acting during infiltration, n is constant. The pressure exponent is theoretically bounded between 0.50 (representing pure orifice flow) and 1.0 (representing crack-dominated airflow pathways). A typical value for n is about 0.65. Values for c and n can be determined for a building by using fan pressurization testing.

 Fan Pressurization Testing in Multi-Zone Buildings

In addition to measuring building-level airtightness, fan pressurization test procedures can be modified to measure airtightness for a single zone (or group of zones) in multizone buildings. Zone-level testing can be unguarded or guarded. Unguarded fan pressurization testing assumes that all adjacent interior zones surrounding the test zone(s) are at ambient conditions. The resulting air leakage rate accounts for air leakage through all interior and exterior zone boundaries. Guarded test methods use “guarding” fans to isolate air leakage associated with an individual partition(s). In a guarded test, adjacent zone(s) are pressurized in tandem with the test zone(s), effectively neutralizing air leakage across the guarded partition. The difference between the guarded and unguarded tests is equal to the air leakage rate of the guarded partition. Depending on the placement of the guarding fans, zone-level air leakage rates can be subdivided in different ways (e.g., building envelope versus interior, walls versus floors/ceilings, individual partitions).

Unguarded dwelling unit fan pressurization testing is specified in ASHRAE Standard 62.2, LEED, ENERGYSTAR, and the International Energy Conservation Code® (IECC®), to assess dwelling unit compartmentalization (ENERGYSTAR 2015; ICC 2021). Regional building codes also sometimes use dwelling unit fan pressurization testing as a proxy for whole-building airtightness testing, to estimate building envelope air leakage rates. Guarded floor-level testing, which isolates building envelope and interior air leakage for a single floor, has been used as an alternative to whole-building fan pressurization tests for high-rise buildings, where whole-building tests are not practical or feasible. Guarded, dwelling-unit testing in MFBs has been used primarily in research applications (Bohac et al. 2007, 2011, 2020; Finch 2007; Gulay et al. 1993; Kaschuba-Holtgrave et al. 2018; Love 1990; Lozinsky and Touchie 2023a; Ricketts 2014; Shaw 1980; Shaw et al. 1991; Shin et al. 2013; Urquhart et al. 2015). Guarded dwelling-unit testing is more labor intensive and time consuming to complete compared to unguarded testing. In addition, there are no test standards for guarded testing procedures. For guarded applications, most practitioners modify existing building envelope fan pressurization test standards.

 Component Air Leakage

Fan pressurization methods can also be used to measure air leakage rates of individual building envelope components, such as windows, doors, or other penetrations. Component air leakage testing is sometimes required in a laboratory setting for windows and doors, as a quality control measure to verify product specifications. Component air leakage testing can also be used during building construction, to confirm that installed components meet project-specific air leakage targets. ASTM Standards E283 and E783 outline laboratory and field tests, respectively, for component air leakage testing.

 Airtightness Ratings

Several metrics exist for comparing the airtightness of buildings, which can be derived from blower door tests. Two such metrics are equivalent leakage area (reported at a standard test pressure of 0.04 in. of water; CGSB Standard 149.10) and effective air leakage area (reported at a standard test pressure of 0.016 in. of water; Sherman and Grimsrud 1980). Effective leakage area is the cross-sectional area of a hole with smooth edges (orifice coefficient of 1, similar to the blower door orifice) that would result in similar airflow as the building at similar driving forces. Equivalent leakage area is the same as effective leakage area except that the equivalent hole is assumed to have realistic edges and thus an orifice coefficient (CD) of 0.6. All openings in the building shell are combined into an overall opening area and discharge coefficient for the building when the equivalent or effective air leakage area is calculated.

(33)

where

AL = equivalent or effective air leakage area, in2
Qr = predicted airflow rate at pr (from curve fit to pressurization test data), cfm
ρ = air density, lbm/ft3
Δpr = reference pressure difference, in. of water (typically 0.04 in. for equivalent leakage area and 0.016 in. for effective leakage area)
CD = discharge coefficient = 1 for effective leakage area, = 0.6 for equivalent leakage area
0.186 = unit conversion factor

Another standard metric uses the predicted airflow rate, reported at a standard test pressure of either 0.2 or 0.3 in. of water. This metric may or may not be normalized by some factor to account for building size. Normalization factors include floor area, exterior envelope area, and building volume. Most North American building codes and standards specifying performance-based airtightness targets use surface area or building volume normalization.

Reference pressure differences of 0.016 and 0.04 in. of water are advocated by researchers because they are closer to the pressure differences that actually induce airflow and, therefore, better model the opening’s flow characteristics. Although this may be true, they are below the typical range of measured values in the test; therefore, predicted airflow rates at 0.016 and 0.04 in. of water are subject to significant uncertainty. This uncertainty and its implications for quantifying airtightness are discussed in Chastain (1987), Modera and Wilson (1990), and Persily and Grot (1985b). Round-robin tests by Murphy et al. (1991) to determine the repeatability and reproducibility of fan pressurization devices found that subtle errors in fan calibration or operator technique are greatly exaggerated when extrapolating the pressure versus flow curve down to 0.016 in. of water, with errors as great as ±40%, mainly because of fan and meter calibration errors at low flow.

 Conversion Between Ratings

Air leakage areas at one reference pressure difference can be converted to air leakage areas at another reference pressure difference by using Equation (34):

(34)

where

Ar,1 = air leakage area at reference pressure difference Δpr,1, in.2
Ar,2 = air leakage area at reference pressure difference Δpr,2, in.2
CD,1 = discharge coefficient used to calculate Ar,1
CD,2 = discharge coefficient used to calculate Ar,2
n = pressure exponent, dimensionless

Air leakage area at one reference pressure difference can be converted to airflow rate at some other reference pressure difference by

(35)

where

Qr,2 = airflow rate at reference pressure difference Δpr,2, cfm
5.39 = unit conversion factor

Flow coefficient c in Equation (32) may be converted to air leakage area by

(36)

Finally, air leakage area may be converted to flow coefficient c in Equation (32) with

(37)

Equations (34) to (37) require assumption of a value for n, unless n is reported with the measurement results. When whole-building pressurization test data are fitted to Equation (32), the value of n generally is between 0.6 and 0.7. Therefore, using a value of n in this range is often reasonable.

ASHRAE Standard 62.2 establishes air leakage performance levels for residential buildings. These levels are in terms of effective annual average infiltration rate Qinf, which is based on normalized leakage area NL:

(38)

where

NL = normalized leakage, dimensionless
Hr = reference height, 8.2 ft
H = vertical distance from lowest above-grade floor to highest ceiling, ft
ELA = effective leakage area, ft2, using 0.016 in. of water reference pressure

(39)

where

Lpress = leakage area from pressurization, ft2
Ldepress = leakage area from depressurization, ft2

5. RESIDENTIAL INFILTRATION

Historically, residential building envelopes were considered sufficiently leaky such that infiltration alone would provide adequate ventilation air flow rates, supplemented by occupant use of windows and exhaust fans when needed. Possible difficulties with this approach included variability in occupant use of windows and exhaust fans, low infiltration when natural forces (stack and wind) are weak; unnecessary energy consumption when these forces are strong; drafts in cold climates; lack of control of ventilation rates to meet changing needs; poor humidity control; potential for interstitial condensation from exfiltration in cold climates or infiltration in hot humid climates; and lack of opportunity to recover energy used to condition ventilation air. The solution to these concerns was to have a tight building envelope and a properly designed and operated mechanical ventilation system with automatic control. To that end, ASHRAE Standard 62.2, U.S. building codes, and the National Building Code of Canada (NRCC 2020) encourage tighter envelope construction, coupled with increased requirements for mechanical ventilation for newly constructed residential buildings.

This section summarizes typical infiltration rates from recent measurement studies in single-family homes and MFBs, common leakage pathways, and strategies for controlling air leakage in new and existing residential buildings. It also describes several calculation procedures, ranging from simple estimation techniques to more physical models, for estimating residential building infiltration rates. Orme (1999) provides a more thorough review of simplified models.

For energy modeling or code compliance, a particular building’s air change rate cannot be reliably deduced from the building’s construction or age or from a simple visual inspection. Some measurements are necessary, such as a fan pressurization test of envelope airtightness or a detailed quantification of the leakage sites and their magnitude. The air change rate of a building may be calculated given (1) the location and leakage function for every opening in the building envelope and between major building zones, (2) the wind pressure coefficients over the building envelope, and (3) any mechanical ventilation airflow rates. These data are generally unavailable for all except very simple structures or extremely well studied buildings. Therefore, their values must be assumed. The appropriateness of these assumptions influences the accuracy of predictions of air change rates.

 Controlling Air Leakage

It is much easier and more cost effective to build a tight building than to tighten an existing building. Elmroth and Levin (1983), Eyre and Jennings (1983), Marbek Resource Consultants (1984), and Nelson et al. (1985) provide information and construction details on airtight building design for houses. BC Housing (2017) and RDH (2013) have both published an airtightness design guide for MFBs.

 New Buildings

Most building codes require a continuous air barrier (CAB) for new residential buildings. Table 2 lists prescriptive and performance-based air leakage targets from Canadian and American building codes and standards, for both single-family and multi-family dwellings. Prescriptive requirements are typically assigned to air barrier materials and assemblies. Performance-based targets apply to the whole building, or whole dwelling unit in the case of MFBs. Performance-based targets typically require field verification via fan pressurization testing. Several building codes and standards also specify maximum allowable air leakage rates for window and door assemblies. Depending on the authority having jurisdiction, additional prescriptive and/or performance-based airtightness targets may apply. Always check local building codes and standards for region-specific airtightness requirements.

Air barrier continuity is critical for performance. Take particular care to ensure continuity at all wall, floor, and ceiling joints; at window and door frames; and at all penetrations of the air barrier such as electrical boxes, plumbing connections, and utility service penetrations. If using a sheet air barrier, joints must be lapped and sealed. In cold climates, the barrier can be installed either on the inside of the wall framing, in which case it usually functions as a vapor retarder as well, or on the outside of the wall framing, in which case it should have a permeance rating high enough to allow diffusion of water vapor from the wall. For a discussion of moisture transfer in building envelopes, see Chapters 25 and 26.

Table 2 Summary of Residential Airtightness Requirements

Building Type

Standard or Code

Air Leakage Requirement

Material

Assembly

Whole Building

Single-family dwellings

ASHRAE 90.2a

   

CZ 0 – 2: 5.0 h–1 at 0.20 in. of water

CZ 3 – 8: 3.0 h–1 at 0.20 in. of water

National Building Code of Canada

—

0.02 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water

-

Multifamily dwellings

ASHRAE 62.2b

 

—

0.20 cfm/ft2 at 0.20 in. of water

ASHRAE 90.1c

0.004 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water

0.04 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water

0.34 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water

IECCd

   

CZ 0 – 2: 5.0 h–1 at 0.20 in. of water

CZ 3 – 8: 3.0 h–1 at 0.20 in. of water

0.30 cfm/ft2 at 0.20 in. of waterd

National Building Code of Canada

—

0.01 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water

-

Notes:

a ASHRAE 90.2 also applies to MFBs of three stories or fewer.

b ASHRAE 62.2 “whole-building” target applies to individual dwelling units in MFBs.

c Buildings with a gross floor area of less than 10,000 ft2 must comply with the “whole building” performance target. Buildings with a gross floor area greater than 10,000 ft2 can either comply with the “whole building” performance target, or follow the prescriptive path, specifying air barrier materials and assemblies with the prescribed air leakage requirements.

d Applicable for attached single-family or multi-family dwelling units (all climate zones).


In MFBs, maintaining continuous air barriers (CABs) between interior zones is important for controlling interzonal airflow and contaminant transport. The gypsum wall board (or other wall finishing material) typically acts as the plane of airtightness between zones, with fire stopping and/or acoustic sealant installed around penetrations and assembly interfaces, to meet fire and acoustic separation requirements. The EnergyStar Multi-Family High Rise Program explicitly requires that the bid documents clearly illustrate the continuous plane of airtightness for the building envelope and all dwelling units, with air barrier materials and accessories identified in section, plan, and detail form (EnergyStar 2015). Controlling air leakage around interior doors is also important. The use of weatherstripping and/or door sweeps at interior doors can greatly reduce door assembly air leakage rates (Tian et al. 2020).

 Existing Buildings

Air leakage paths must first be located before the envelope of an existing building can be tightened. Air leakage into and out of buildings is caused by not only windows and doors but also a wide range of unexpected and unobvious construction defects (refer to Leakage Distributions for more detail). Many important leakage routes can be very difficult to find. A variety of techniques developed to locate leakage paths are described in ASTM Standard E1186-2022a and Charlesworth (1988).

Once leakages are located (and assuming they are accessible), they can be repaired with materials and techniques appropriate to the size and location of the leak. Diamond et al. (1982), Energy Resource Center (1982), Harrje et al. (1979), and many websites and online videos include information on airtightening or “weatherization” in existing residential buildings with caulking, sealing, weatherstripping, and use of door sweeps, for example. With these procedures, air leakage of residential buildings can be reduced dramatically: anywhere from 5% to more than 50%, depending on the extent of the tightening effort and the experience of those doing the work (Blomsterberg and Harrje 1979; Giesbrecht and Proskiw 1986; Harrje and Mills 1980; Jacobson et al. 1986; Verschoor and Collins 1986). Much less information is available for airtightening MFBs, but the same general principles apply. The few studies that have documented unit-level air-tightening efforts in existing MFBs reported reductions in dwelling unit air leakage rates between 10 and 70% (Bohac et al. 2007), and 39 and 89% (Bohac et al. 2016). Both studies noted that airtightening efficacy was greatly dependent on the accessibility of the leakage pathways and the air sealing materials.

 Single-Family Home Building Air Leakage Data

Typical air leakage rates in single-family housing can vary widely. Chan et al. (2005) analyzed over 70,000 air leakage measurements from single-family homes in the United States, with building air leakage characterized using NL. The geometric mean for the entire sample was 0.54, with a geometric standard deviation of 2.0. More recently, Khemet and Richman (2018) and Mélois et al. (2019) leveraged national airtightness databases, in Canada and France respectively, to characterize national airtightness trends in single-family homes. Based on a sample of 916,600 fan pressurization tests in existing single-family homes, Khemet and Richman (2018) reported a geometric mean of 5.7 h–1 at 0.20 in. of water (0.67 NL), with measurements ranging from 0.5 to 30 h–1 at 0.20 in. of water (0.1 to 5.0 NL). Mélois et al. (2019) reported a median air leakage rate of 0.02 cfm/ft2 at a test pressure of 0.016 in. of water (range = 0.002 to 0.02 cfm/ft2), based on 170,028 measurements in single-family homes constructed between 2010 and 2016. Assuming n = 0.65, these results roughly translate to a median of 0.11 cfm/ft2 at a test pressure of 0.20 in. of water (range = 0.008 to 0.26 cfm/ft2). Smaller studies of newly-constructed single-family homes in Europe have reported mean air leakage rates of 0.40 cfm/ft2 (Pan 2010) and 0.09 to 0.32 cfm/ft2 (Vinha et al., 2015) at test pressures of 0.20 in. of water.

Khemet and Richman (2018) and Chan et al. (2005) both found that residential building air leakage rates tended to increase with building age. Construction type has also been shown to affect building airtightness, with wood-frame structures generally being less airtight than concrete or masonry structures (Mélois et al. 2019; Pan 2010; Vinha et al. 2015). Although building airtightness is generally improving, in part due to increased awareness about the role of airtightness in building energy efficiency, as well as increasingly stringent code requirements, there is still a large range in measured air leakage rates.

 Air Leakage Pathways

Dickerhoff et al. (1982) and Harrje and Born (1982) studied air leakage of individual building components and systems. The following points summarize the percentages of whole-building air leakage area that they found associated with various components and systems. Values in parentheses include the range determined for each component and the mean of the range. Colliver et al. (1994) also compiled a list of effective leakage areas for typical building envelope components.

Note that most building codes and standards have moved towards whole-building fan pressurization testing to characterize the effective building envelope airtightness, in lieu of component air leakage measurements. Except for window and door assemblies, recent measurement studies have typically not measured component air leakage rates. The following percentages do not necessarily represent current construction and air sealing practices; however, these findings are still useful in identifying typical leakage pathways, which will require diligent air sealing during construction.

Walls (18 to 50%; 35%). Both interior and exterior walls contribute to the leakage of the structure. Leakage can occur between the sill plate and the floor or foundation; through cracks below the bottom of the gypsum wallboard, around and through electrical boxes, and through plumbing penetrations; and into the attic at the top plates of walls. Holes drilled through the top plates into the attic for passage of wiring are often unsealed.

Ceiling Details (3 to 30%; 18%). Leakage across the top ceiling of the heated space is particularly insidious because it reduces the effectiveness of insulation on the attic floor and contributes to infiltration heat loss. Ceiling leakage also reduces the effectiveness of ceiling insulation in buildings without attics. Recessed lighting, plumbing, and other penetrations leading to the attic are some particular areas of concern, as are intentional openings such as access hatches or for whole-house fans.

Forced-Air Heating and/or Cooling Systems (3 to 28%; 18%). The location of the heating or cooling equipment, air handler, or ductwork in conditioned or unconditioned spaces; the venting arrangement of a fuel-burning device; and the existence and location of a combustion air supply all affect air leakage. Modera et al. (1991) and Robison and Lambert (1989), among others, found that the variability of leakage in ducts passing through unconditioned spaces is high, the coefficient of variation being about 50%. Field studies also showed that in situ repairs can eliminate one-quarter to two-thirds of the observed leakage (Cummings and Tooley 1989; Cummings et al. 1990; Jump et al. 1996; Robison and Lambert 1989). The 18% contribution of ducts to total leakage significantly underestimates their effect because, during system operation, pressure differentials across duct leaks are approximately ten times higher than typical pressure differences across envelope leaks (Modera 1989; Modera et al. 1991) and result in large (factors of two to three), changes in ventilation rate (Cummings et al. 1990; Walker 1999; Walker et al. 1999).

Windows and Doors (6 to 22%; 15%). More variation in window leakage is seen among window types (e.g., casement versus double-hung) than among new windows of the same type from different manufacturers (Weidt et al. 1979). Windows that seal by compressing the weather strip (casements, awnings) often show significantly lower leakage than windows with sliding seals. Leakage around the frames of windows also can be significant if not properly sealed, typically with controlled-expansion foam, during their installation. The door between a residence and an attached garage, or an enclosed hallway in MFBs, also needs gasketing to reduce air leakage as well as smoke and other contaminants’ movement.

Fireplaces (0 to 30%; 12%). When a fireplace is not in use, poorly fitting dampers allow indoor air to escape. Glass doors may not seal the fireplace structure more tightly than a closed damper does. Chimney caps or fireplace plugs (with signs that warn they are in place) effectively reduce leakage through a cold fireplace but may not be allowed by fire code. The gap between a metal fireplace insert and the surrounding wall, tiles, or brick is often another leakage path if not properly sealed.

Exhaust Vents from Conditioned Spaces (2 to 12%; 5%). Exhaust ducts going from conditioned spaces to the outdoors frequently have either no dampers or dampers that do not close properly. The gap between the duct and the wall or roof penetration often needs sealing, as well.

Diffusion Through Walls and Ceilings (<1%). Compared to infiltration through holes and other openings in the structure, diffusion through well-constructed walls and ceilings is not an important flow mechanism. Proper installation of an air barrier can help minimize this air leakage path. The National Building Code of Canada requires the installation of a continuous air barrier with a maximum air permeance of 0.01 to 0.10 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water, depending on the performance class (NRCC 2020). At 0.02 in. of water, the permeability of building materials produces an air change rate of less than 0.01 h–1 by wall diffusion in a typical house.

 Multi-Family Building (MFB) Air Leakage Data

Air leakage rates in MFBs are measured at either the dwelling level or at the building level, depending on the jurisdiction and the applicable codes and standards. As mentioned previously, LEED, ASHRAE Standard 62.2, IECC, and EnergyStar include requirements for dwelling unit air leakage testing, to assess unit-level compartmentalization. Depending on the standard, these targets range from 0.20 to 0.30 cfm/ft2 or 3.0 to 5.0 h–1, at a test pressure of 0.20 in. of water. Most measurement studies reporting air leakage rates in MFBs report dwelling unit air leakage.

Table 3 summarizes results from several recent studies measuring dwelling unit air leakage rates in newly constructed buildings. Consistent with single-family homes, there is a wide range in reported values, even in new construction. Dwelling unit air leakage rates are generally higher in wood-frame MFBs (Bohac et al. 2020; Mélois et al. 2019; Pan 2010; Vinha et al. 2015) compared to concrete and masonry buildings (Lozinsky and Touchie 2021; Mélois et al. 2019; Pan 2010; Shin and Jo 2013). There are a few studies that have published whole building test data for MFBs. In general, whole building air leakage rates are in the same order of magnitude as dwelling units. Bohac et al. (2020) measured whole-building air leakage rates between 0.05 and 0.47 cfm/ft2, at a test pressure of 0.20 in. of water, in low-rise wood-framed MFBs. Other studies have reported whole-building values ranging from 0.14 to 0.50 cfm/ft2 (Jones et al., 2014) and 0.05 to 0.55 cfm/ft2 (Jones, 2022), at a test pressure of 0.30 in. of water.

Table 3 Summary of Air Leakage Rates in Newly Constructed Multifamily Dwellings

   

Area-Normalized Air Leakage Rate, cfm/ft2 at 0.20 in. of water

Air Change Rate, h−1 at 0.20 in. of water

Source

Number of Dwellings in Sample

Sample Mean

Sample Range

Sample Mean

Sample Range

Pan (2010)a

177

0.29

0.27 to 0.31

—

—

Shin and Jo (2013)

350

—

—

—

1.4 to 5.2

Mélois et al. (2019)b

57,224

0.16

0.01 to 0.43

—

—

Bohac et al. (2020)

274

0.24

0.07 to 0.52

4.35

1.45 to 10.71

Lozinsky and Touchie (2021)

175

0.10

0.03 to 0.49

2.22

0.56 to 5.80

Notes:

a Range limits represent the 5th and 95th percentiles.

b Air leakage rates were originally reported at a test pressure of 0.016 in. of water. Air leakage rates were extrapolated to a test pressure of 0.20 in. of water, assuming n = 0.65.


 Air Leakage Pathways

Several studies have measured partition-level air leakage rates in MFBs using guarded fan pressurization methods. All studies have noted considerable variation in air leakage rates at the partition level (Bohac et al. 2020; Finch 2007; Lozinsky and Touchie 2023a; Ricketts 2014; Shin and Jo 2013). Floor/ceiling assemblies and unit-to-unit interior walls were typically the most airtight. In studies that separated unit-to-corridor wall air leakage, unit-to-corridor walls were on average two to nine times leakier than unit-to-unit interior walls, when normalized by surface area. Studies in older buildings have estimated that interior air leakage accounted for 12 to 68% of total dwelling unit air leakage (Diamond et al. 1986; Finch 2007; Gulay et al. 1993; Levin 1988; Modera et al. 1986; Ricketts 2014). As building envelope airtightness construction practices have improved, the contribution of interior air leakage to total dwelling unit air leakage has generally increased, with recent studies reporting interior air leakage fractions of 50 to 95% (Lozinsky and Touchie 2023a; Shin and Jo 2013).

Many of the air leakage pathways described in the previous section also apply to MFBs and dwelling units. Mélois et al. (2019) also summarized typical air leakage pathways identified as part of compliance testing in over 54,000 newly constructed multifamily dwellings in France. The two most common leakage pathways identified in multifamily dwellings were gaps around mechanical ventilation ductwork and air terminals, and through-wall/through-floor penetrations, including but not limited to plumbing pipes and electrical conduits, occurring in 57% and 47% of tests, respectively. Other interior leakage pathways included junctions between walls, or between wall and floor assemblies, and electrical and/or lighting penetrations.

Interfloor air leakage via stairwell, elevator, and/or garbage chute shafts can negatively impact building performance, particularly in tall buildings where stack-induced pressure differentials can be large. Simulation studies have shown that tightening vertical shafts, by installing fully-weather stripped doors at stairwell access points and implementing elevator vestibules, can reduce inter-zonal air flow and contaminant transport, and potentially reduce space conditioning loads, depending on the building’s mechanical ventilation system (Fine et al. 2022; Lozinsky and Touchie 2024). The benefits of shaft airtightening interventions only work when all shafts are tightened simultaneously.

 Modeling Residential Infiltration

The following sections describe several modelling techniques for estimating infiltration in single-family residential buildings. While these techniques are typically used for research and remediation purposes, most small residential buildings are designed and constructed without direct involvement of ventilation engineers. Contractors, who typically prepare these buildings’ designs, are required to follow mandates in various codes and standards, and they apply experience-based rules of thumb when determining, for example, exhaust needs. Often, leaky buildings or air quality problems result. Research and experience have shown that tightening building envelopes and using mechanical ventilation with heat recovery can improve IAQ and reduce energy consumption. Retaining the services of a ventilation engineer before construction begins is advisable in some situations.

Empirical Models. These models of residential infiltration are based on statistical fits of infiltration rate data for specific houses. They use fan pressurization test results to account for house airtightness and take the form of simple relations between infiltration rate, an airtightness rating, and, in most cases, weather conditions. Empirical models account for envelope infiltration only and do not include intentional ventilation. In one approach, the calculated air change rate at 0.20 in. of water based on a pressurization test is simply divided by a constant approximately equal to 20 (Sherman 1987). This technique does not account for the effect of infiltration-driving mechanisms on air flow. Empirical models that do account for weather effects have been developed by Kronvall (1980), Reeves et al. (1979), and Shaw (1981).

The latter two models account for building air leakage using the values of c and n from Equation (32). The only other data required are wind speed and temperature difference. These empirical models predict long-term (one-week) infiltration rates very well in the houses from which they were developed; they do not, however, work as well in other houses because of the building-specific nature of leakage distribution, wind pressure, and internal partitioning. Persily (1986) and Persily and Linteris (1983) compared measured and predicted house infiltration rates for these and other models. The average long-term differences between measurements and predictions are generally about 40%, although individual predictions can be inaccurate by 100% or more (Persily, 1986; Walker and Wilson, 1998).

 Single-Zone Models

Several procedures have been developed to calculate building air change rates that are based on physical models of the building interior as a single zone. These single-zone models are only appropriate for buildings with minimal internal resistance to airflow, and are therefore inappropriate for large, multizone residential buildings. Some models of this type have been developed by Cole et al. (1980), Sherman and Grimsrud (1980), Walker and Wilson (1998), and Warren and Webb (1980). The section on Residential Calculation Examples uses both basic and enhanced models (Bradley 1993; CHBA 1994; Hamlin and Pushka 1994; Palmiter and Bond 1994; Walker and Wilson 1998).

The basic model uses effective air leakage area AL at 0.016 in. of water, which can be obtained from a whole-building fan pressurization test. The enhanced model uses pressurization test results to characterize house air leakage through the leakage coefficient c and pressure exponent n. The enhanced model improves on the basic model by using a power law to represent envelope leakage, including a flue as a separate leakage path, and having separate wind effects for houses with crawlspaces or basements instead of slab-on-grade foundations.

For both models, the user must provide the wind speed, the temperature difference, information on the distribution of leakage over the building envelope, a wind shelter parameter or local shielding for the basic model, and a terrain coefficient. The predictive accuracy of the enhanced model can be very good, typically ±10% when parameters are well known for the building in question (Palmiter and Bond 1994; Sherman and Modera 1986; Walker and Wilson 1998). All models’ results are sensitive to the user-provided data, and some of these parameters are often quite difficult to determine.

 Superposition of Wind and Stack Effects

Simplified physical models of infiltration solve the problem of two natural driving forces (wind and stack) separately and then combine them in a process called superposition. Superposition is necessary because each physical process can affect internal and external air pressures on the building’s envelope, and can cause interactions between physical processes that are otherwise independent. An exact solution is impossible, because (1) detailed properties of all the building leaks are unknown and (2) leakage is a nonlinear process. Therefore, most modelers have developed a simplified superposition process to combine stack and wind effects. Sherman (1992b) compared various superposition procedures and derived a generalized superposition equation involving simple leakage distribution parameters, and showed that the result is always subadditive. Typically, only 35% of infiltration from the smaller effect can be added to the larger effect. Depending on the specific building and conditions, that percentage could go as high as 85% or as low as zero. Walker and Wilson (1993) compared several superposition techniques to measured data. Sherman, as well as Walker and Wilson, found quadrature, shown in Equation (40), to be a robust superposition technique:

(40)

The following sections discuss how superposition is combined with calculation of wind and stack flows to determine total flow.

 Residential Calculation Examples

Basic Model. The following calculations are based on the Sherman and Grimsrud (1980) model, which uses the effective air leakage area at 0.016 in. of water. This leakage area can be obtained from a whole-building pressurization test. Using effective air leakage area, the airflow rate from infiltration is

(41)

where

Q = airflow rate, cfm
AL = effective air leakage area, in2
Cs = stack coefficient, cfm2/in4 · °F
ΔT = average indoor-outdoor temperature difference for time interval of calculation, °F
Cw = wind coefficient, cfm2/in4 · mph2
U = average wind speed measured at local weather station for time interval of calculation, mph
1000 = unit conversion factor

Table 4 shows values of Cs for one-, two-, and three-story houses. The value of wind coefficient Cw depends on the local shelter class of the building (Table 5) and the building height. Table 6 shows values of Cw for one-, two-, and three-story houses in shelter classes 1 to 5. In calculating values in Tables 4 and 6, the following assumptions were made:

  • Terrain used for converting meteorological to local wind speeds is that of a rural area with scattered obstacles

  • R = 0.5 (half the building leakage in the walls)

  • X = 0 (equal amounts of leakage in the floor and ceiling)

  • Heights of one-, two-, and three-story buildings = 8, 16, and 24 ft, respectively

Example 1.

Estimate the infiltration at winter design conditions for a two-story house in Lincoln, Nebraska. The house has effective air leakage area of 77 in2 and volume of 12,000 ft3, and the predominant wind is perpendicular to the street (shelter class 3). The indoor air temperature is 68°F.

Solution: The 99% design temperature for Lincoln is –2°F. Assume a design wind speed of 15 mph. From Equation (34), with Cs = 0.0299 from Table 4 and Cw = 0.0086 from Table 6, the airflow rate caused by infiltration is

From Equation (3), air change rate I is equal to Q divided by the building volume:


Example 2.

Predict the average infiltration during a one-week period in January for a one-story house in Portland, Oregon. During this period, the average indoor/outdoor temperature difference is 30°F, and average wind speed is 6 mph. The house has volume of 9000 ft3 and effective air leakage area of 107 in2, and it is in an area with buildings and trees within 30 ft in most directions (shelter class 4).

Solution: From Equation (41), the airflow rate caused by infiltration is

The air change rate is therefore


Table 4 Basic Model Stack Coefficient Cs

 

House Height (Stories)

One

Two

Three

Stack coefficient

0.0150

0.0299

0.0449


Table 5 Local Shelter Classes

Shelter Class

 

Description

1

 

No obstructions or local shielding

2

 

Typical shelter for an isolated rural house

3

 

Typical shelter caused by other buildings across street from building under study

4

 

Typical shelter for urban buildings on larger lots where sheltering obstacles are more than one building height away

5

 

Typical shelter produced by buildings or other structures immediately adjacent (closer than one house height: e.g., neighboring houses on same side of street, trees, bushes)


Table 6 Basic Model Wind Coefficient Cw

Shelter Class

 

House Height (Stories)

One

Two

Three

1

 

0.0119

0.0157

0.0184

2

 

0.0092

0.0121

0.0143

3

 

0.0065

0.0086

0.0101

4

 

0.0039

0.0051

0.0060

5

 

0.0012

0.0016

0.0018


Example 3.

Estimate the average infiltration over the heating season in a two-story house with volume of 11,000 ft3 and leakage area of 131 in2. The house is located on a lot with several large trees but no other close buildings (shelter class 3). Average wind speed during the heating season is 7 mph, and the average indoor/outdoor temperature difference is 36°F.

Solution: From Equation (41), the airflow rate from infiltration is

The average air change rate is therefore


Enhanced Model. This section presents a simple, single-zone approach to calculating air infiltration rates in houses based on the Walker and Wilson (1998) model. The airflow rate from stack and wind infiltration is

(42)

(43)

where

Qs = stack airflow rate, cfm
Qw = wind airflow rate, cfm
c = flow coefficient, cfm/(in. of water)n
Cs = stack coefficient, (in. of water/°F)n
Cw = wind coefficient, (in. of water/mph2)n
s = shelter factor
ΔT = indoor – outdoor temperature difference, °F
n = pressure exponent, dimensionless

Table 7 Enhanced Model Wind Speed Multiplier G

 

House Height (Stories)

One

Two

Three

Wind speed multiplier G

0.48

0.59

0.67


Table 8 Enhanced Model Stack and Wind Coefficients

 

One-Story

 

Two-Story

 

Three-Story

No Flue

With Flue

 

No Flue

With Flue

 

No Flue

With Flue

Cs

0.000891

0.001144

 

0.001308

0.001478

 

0.001641

0.001791

Cw for slab-on-grade

0.001313

0.001194

 

0.001432

0.001313

 

0.001432

0.001402

Cw for crawl-space

0.001074

0.001074

 

0.001194

0.001194

 

0.001271

0.001295


In calculating tabulated values of Cs, Cw, and s, the assumptions were

  • Each story is 8 ft high.

  • The flue is 6 in. in diameter and reaches 6 ft above the upper ceiling.

  • The flue is unsheltered.

  • Half of envelope leakage (not including the flue) is in the walls and one-quarter each is at the floor and ceiling, respectively.

  • n = 0.67

Table 9 Enhanced Model Shelter Factor s

Shelter Class

 

No Flue

One-Story with Flue

Two-Story with Flue

Three-Story with Flue

1

 

1.00

1.10

1.07

1.06

2

 

0.90

1.02

0.98

0.97

3

 

0.70

0.86

0.81

0.79

4

 

0.50

0.70

0.64

0.61

5

 

0.30

0.54

0.47

0.43


The following examples use typical values for terrain factors, house height, and wind speed measurement height, wind speed multiplier G given in Table 7, and use a relationship based on equations found in Chapter 24.

Example 4.

Estimate the infiltration at winter design conditions for a two-story slab-on-grade house with a flue in Lincoln, Nebraska. The house has a flow coefficient of c = 4370 cfm/(in. of water)n and a pressure exponent of n = 0.67 (corresponding to effective leakage area of 77 in2 at 0.016 in. of water). The building volume is 12,000 ft3. The 97.5% design temperature is –2°F, and design wind speed is 15 mph.

Solution: For a slab-on-grade two-story house with a flue, Table 8 gives Cs = 0.001478 (in. of water/°F)n and Cw = 0.001313 (in. of water/mph2)n. The house is maintained at 68°F indoors. The building wind speed is determined by taking the design wind speed Umet and applying by the wind speed multiplier G from Table 7:

From Table 5, the shelter class for a typical urban house is 4. Table 9 gives the shelter factor for a two-story house with a flue and shelter class 4 as s = 0.64. The stack flow is calculated using Equation (42):

The wind flow is calculated using Equation (43):

Substituting Qs and Qw into Equation (40) gives Q = 126 cfm = 7560 ft3/h. From Equation (3), air change rate I is equal to Q divided by the building volume:


Example 5.

Estimate the average infiltration over a one-week cold-weather period for a single-story house with a crawlspace in Redmond, Washington. The house has a flow coefficient of c = 6890 cfm/(in. of water)n and a pressure exponent of n = 0.6 (corresponding to effective leakage area of 107 in2 at 0.016 in. of water). The building volume is 9000 ft3. During this period, the average indoor-to-outdoor temperature difference is 29°F, and wind speed is 6 mph. The house is electrically heated and has no flue.

Solution: For a single-story house with no flue, Cs = 0.000891 (in. of water/°F)n. For a crawlspace, Cw = 0.001074 (in. of water/mph2)n. From Table 7, for a one-story house, G = 0.48.

Table 9 gives shelter factor s = 0.50 for a house with no flue and shelter class 4. Stack flow is calculated using Equation (36):

Wind flow is calculated using Equation (37):

Substituting Qs and Qw into Equation (34) gives Q = 48 cfm = 2880 ft3/h. From Equation (3), air change rate I is equal to Q divided by the building volume:


Example 6.

Estimate the infiltration for a three-story house in San Francisco, California. The house has a flow coefficient of c = 8740 cfm/(in. of water)n and a pressure exponent of n = 0.67 (corresponding to effective leakage area of 155 in2 at 0.016 in. of water). The building volume is 14,200 ft3. The indoor/outdoor temperature difference is 9°F and wind speed is 10 mph. The house has a flue and a crawlspace.

Solution: For a three-story house with a flue, Cs = 0.001791 (in. of water/°F)n. For a crawlspace, Cw = 0.001295 (in. of water/mph2)n. From Table 7, for a three-story house, G = 0.67.

The prevailing wind blows along the row of houses parallel to the street, so the house has a shelter class of 5. Table 7 gives the shelter factor for a three-story house with a flue and shelter class 5 as s = 0.43.

Substituting Qs and Qw in Equation (34) gives Q = 83 cfm = 4960 ft3/h. The air changes per hour are


 Combining Residential Infiltration and Mechanical Ventilation

Significant infiltration and mechanical ventilation often occur simultaneously in residences. The pressure difference from Equation (17) can be used for each building leak, and the flow network (including mechanical ventilation) for the building can be solved to find the airflow through all the leaks while accounting for the effect of the mechanical ventilation. However, for simplified models, natural infiltration and mechanical ventilation are usually determined separately and require a superposition method to combine the flow rates.

Sherman (1992b) compared various procedures and derived a generalized superposition equation that involves simple leakage distribution parameters. The result is always sub-additive. For small, unbalanced fans, typically only half the mechanically introduced outdoor airflow contributes to the total, but this fraction can be anywhere between 0 and 100%, depending on leakage distribution. When the makeup air fan’s flow rate is large, infiltration may be ignored, because the building becomes either neutrally or positively pressurized.

In special cases when the leakage distribution is known and highly skewed, it may be necessary to work through the superposition method in more detail. For example, in a wind-dominated situation, a makeup air fan has a much bigger effect than an exhaust fan on changing the total ventilation rate; the same is true for houses with high NPLs in cold climates. For the general case, when details are not known or can be assumed to be broad and typical, the following superposition gives good results:

(44)

 Multizone Models

Multicell models of airflow in buildings treat buildings as a series of interconnected zones and assume that air within each zone can be characterized by a single temperature and contaminant concentration, with the pressure only dependent on air density. Several such models have been developed by Allard and Herrlin (1989), Dols and Polidoro (2020), Etheridge and Alexander (1980), Feustel and Raynor-Hoosen (1990), Herrlin (1985), Liddament and Allen (1983), and Walton (1984, 1989). They are all based on a mass balance for each zone of the building. These mass balances are used to solve for interior static pressures in the building by requiring that inflows and outflows for each zone balance to zero. The user must provide information describing building envelope leakage, values to account for wind pressure on the building envelope, temperatures for each zone, and any mechanical ventilation airflow rates. Wind pressure coefficient data in the literature, air leakage measurement results from the building or its components, and air leakage data from research can be used as estimates. These models not only solve for whole-building and individual zone air change rates, but also determine airflow rates and pressure differences between zones. These interzone airflow rates are useful for predicting contaminant transport within buildings with well mixed zones. Chapter 13 has more details on multizone airflow and IAQ modeling.

6. RESIDENTIAL VENTILATION

Traditionally, ventilation air for residences has been provided by natural ventilation controlled by occupants, and mechanically by increasing infiltration using exhaust fans vented outdoors. Sherman and Matson (1997) showed that many older residential buildings are leaky enough that infiltration alone can meet the minimum requirements of ASHRAE Standard 62.2. However, houses built or retrofitted to new standards can have substantially tighter envelopes and insufficient infiltration under most weather conditions to meet ventilation standards. Studies have shown that concerns over safety, noise, comfort, air quality, and energy minimize occupants’ use of operable windows (Johnson and Long 2005; Price and Sherman 2006). As a result, new homes or homes retrofitted to new airtightness standards require mechanical ventilation to satisfy current standards.

Mechanical ventilation systems in residential buildings can be categorized as centralized or decentralized systems (Berquist et al. 2022). Depending on their control or design (either alone or combined with another system), they can be categorized into one of three approaches: (1) exhaust-only, (2) supply-only, or (3) balanced (CMHC 2021). It is important to note that exhaust- and supply-only systems can be paired together; however, unless there is a supervisory control system that simultaneously controls the equipment in each system, the combined ventilation system will typically remain unbalanced (Berquist et al. 2022). This section describes the various mechanical ventilation and air distribution systems that are frequently used in single-family homes and MFBs.

 Single-Family Home Ventilation

Mechanical ventilation systems for single-family homes can be categorized as either exhaust-only or balanced systems (Reardon and Shaw 1997; Sherman and Matson 1997).

Exhaust-Only Systems. Exhaust-only systems use leakage paths and, in some cases, intentional, controllable, and filtered openings in the building envelope for admitting makeup air. Such systems may be suitable for retrofit in existing houses. Energy can be recovered from the exhaust airstream to precondition makeup air or to warm potable water using a heat pump, for example.

Noise, installed capacity, durability under high or continuous operation, air movement from all rooms (especially bedrooms), envelope moisture, combustion safety, and energy efficiency issues need to be addressed. Many present bathroom and kitchen fans are ineffective ventilators because of poor installation and design, and many fail to exhaust outdoors. However, properly specified and installed exhaust fans can form part of good whole-house ventilation systems and so are specified in many building codes.

After source elimination, the single most important source control mechanism in dwellings is local exhaust. Kitchens, utility rooms, bathrooms, and other spaces designed to allow specific contaminant releases should be provided with local exhaust that is vented to the outdoors. Workshops, recreation rooms, smoking areas, art studios, greenhouses, and hobby rooms may also require local ventilation and/or air cleaning to remove contaminants generated by the activities involved. Contaminants of concern should be evaluated to determine how much additional ventilation is required. Many of these rooms can be adequately ventilated by following the requirements for kitchens or bathrooms. If unvented combustion appliances must be used, rooms with these appliances should also meet general ventilation requirements for kitchens, because such appliances generate significant amounts of moisture and, often, ultrafine particles, even when operating properly.

Mechanical exhaust (i.e., a fan with ducting to the outdoors) with adequate makeup air is the preferred method for providing local ventilation. Normally, such an exhaust system is designed to operate intermittently under manual control to send contaminated air outdoors when occupants recognize the need for ventilation. However, in many circumstances, a continuous, lower-flow-rate exhaust can work as well. Specific provisions for intermittent versus continuous exhaust rates are typically included in ventilation standards such as ASHRAE Standard 62.2; some example information is provided here.

Continuous Exhaust. A continuously operating mechanical exhaust system is intended to operate without occupant intervention. This exhaust may be part of a balanced whole-building mechanical ventilation system. The system should be designed to operate during all hours in which the dwelling is occupied. Override control, to provide higher exhaust rates when needed, should be provided. The minimum delivered ventilation rate should be at least that given in Table 10.

Intermittent Exhaust. An intermittently operating local mechanical exhaust is intended to be operated as needed by the occupant. Shutoff timers, occupancy controls, multiple-speed fans, and switching integral with room lighting are helpful, provided they do not impede occupant control. The minimum airflow rate should be at least that given in Table 11.

Several factors should be considered when selecting kitchen exhaust equipment. Cooking is one of the most important sources of airborne pollutants in the indoor environments of residential building, including NO2, fine particles, carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, acrolein, and other VOCs. Cooking can also produce significant amounts of water vapor, which can eventually lead to moisture-related problems. It is generally agreed that kitchen range hoods can reduce concentrations of these contaminants. However, even within individual studies measured performance varies widely: up to almost 100% (Li et al. 1997; Li and Delsante 1996; Lim and Lee 2008; Madsen et al. 1994; Rim et al. 2012). This is at least partially attributable to differences in installation, burner position, fan speed, fan design, hood design, and location of makeup air (Fritz 1989; Singer et al. 2010, 2011, 2012) and particle size when quantifying particulate removal (Rim et al. 2012).

Table 10 Continuous Exhaust Airflow Rates

Application

Airflow Rate

Notes

Enclosed kitchen

5 ach

Based on kitchen volume

Restroom

20 cfm

Not less than 2 ach


Table 11 Intermittent Exhaust Airflow Rates

Application

Airflow Rate

Notes

Kitchen

100 cfm

With a vented range hood

300 cfm

With other exhaust fans, including downdraft

Restroom

50 cfm

Not less than 2 ach


Most recommendations for range hood specification give only minimum airflow rates and noise. ASHRAE Standard 62.2 specifies minimum flow rates of 100 cfm and a maximum sound level of 3 sones. While flow rate is correlated to efficacy of removal of contaminants, as much as a factor of three variation in contaminant removal at the same flow rate has been measured (Delp and Singer 2012). Another study found that for one particular hood, the increase in performance with flow rate fell off markedly above 250 cfm (Delp and Singer 2012; Singer et al. 2011). Other variables may also contribute strongly to hood performance, including power input into the range (Li and Delsante 1996, Clark et al. 2018a), emitter temperature (Walker et al. 2016), face velocity (Kuehn et al. 1989), and emitter height (Kuehn et al. 1989, Clark et al. 2018a).

Furthermore, Singer et al. (2012) showed that the rated flow rate is often not achieved in real homes, and that 10 devices they tested had maximum airflows 70% or more below rated values. In tight, energy-efficient homes, fans may work against restricted makeup air flow, and therefore, may be substantially less effective (Fritz 1989). High-resistance exhaust ducts with no auxiliary fan included can make the rated flow rate nearly meaningless (Stratton and Singer 2014).

For these reasons, ASTM-F1704-12 (2022b) gives procedures for measuring capture efficiency of wall-mounted kitchen exhaust devices (Walker et al. 2016), which moves the quantification of kitchen range hood performance from solely a rated flow rate to a metric that more fully captures the ability of the hood to improve air quality. Clark et al. (2018a) and Clark et al (2018b) extend this method to downdraft and island range hoods. Capture efficiency is measured by injecting a tracer gas directly into the plume formed above a cooking surface and measuring gas at representative locations in order to derive the capture efficiency. Li and Delsante (1996), Li et al. (2001), and Wolbrink and Sarnosky (1992) have given slightly different versions of a similar means of estimating capture efficiency, which involves measurement of a tracer gas at multiple points and derivation of capture efficiency from these measurements.

Wolbrink and Sarnosky (1992) started with the assumption of two well-mixed zones: one that encompasses the range and range hood in which the contaminants are emitted; and one that includes the rest of the room in question. Using conservation of mass, they showed that the fraction of contaminants being exhausted by the hood relative to the total emission can be estimated as

(45)

where

εc = capture efficiency or portion of emitted contaminant capture by the exhaust
cr = concentration of the tracer gas in a location representative of the bulk room zone
co = concentration of the tracer in the make-up air
ce = concentration of the tracer in the exhaust

Li and Delsante (1996) argued that conceptual inconsistencies in Wolbrink and Sarnosky’s (1992) formulation necessitated inclusion of a general ventilation term. The resulting equation included three concentrations that needed to be measured as well as two distinct flow rates, and reduced to the Wolbrink and Sarnosky equation when the background ventilation term was zero. Li et al. (1997) suggested another formulation that not only accounted for a background ventilation process, but also attempted to account for any gradients in tracer concentration within the room that might exist. To do this, they suggested defining an “entrainment boundary” at which the plume from the range ended and the relatively quiescent room air began, measuring the concentration along this boundary, and then averaging these concentrations to get a slightly more accurate estimate of capture efficiency. This method lends itself more readily to numerical analyses (such as CFD) because it requires the concentration to be known at many points.

Alternatives. Cleaning recirculated air can sometimes be substituted for local exhaust if it can be shown to be effective and reliable in removing contaminants of concern. Natural ventilation is not generally a suitable method for local exhaust and ventilation air needs in many climates and spaces. Using natural ventilation can cause reentrainment problems when contaminated exhaust or exfiltrating air reenters the building. In milder climates, natural ventilation may be acceptable when the contaminant of concern is related to odor rather than health or safety. Purpose-designed passive exhaust systems have shown acceptable ventilation in some European settings, and may be considered in lieu of mechanical systems. Axley (2001b) discusses evaluation and design of passive residential ventilation systems further.

 Balanced Ventilation System

Although exhaust-only systems are very prevalent in existing homes, the increased desire to build and retrofit homes as airtight as possible necessitates outdoor air to be delivered through mechanical ventilation, as opposed to forced infiltration via depressurization. Each dwelling should be provided with outdoor air according to the code adopted by the local jurisdiction. General guidance according to ASHRAE Standard 62.2 is given in Table 12 of this chapter. The rate is the sum of the Area- and Occupancy-Based columns. Design occupancy expectations in the United States can be based on the number of bedrooms as follows: two people are assumed for the first bedroom, and one person is assumed for each additional bedroom. Additional ventilation should be considered when occupant densities exceed one person per 250 ft2.

 Natural Ventilation

Natural ventilation that relies on occupant window operation should only be used to make up any portion of the minimum total ventilation air requirement if the authority having jurisdiction determines it to be a permissible method as per ASHRAE Standard 62.2. However, because occupancy and sources vary significantly, the capacity to ventilate above minimum rates can be provided by operable exterior openings such as windows and doors.

Some systems use their central air-handling unit blower to induce air from the outdoors and distribute it. However, the blower operates intermittently if thermostatically controlled and thus provides little ventilation in mild weather. Continuous blower operation increases energy consumption. If the blower operates continuously when the heat source is off, the combination of lower mixed-air temperature and high air speed can cause cold air drafts when in heating mode. To offset these problems, some systems use variable-speed blowers, which allow operation at lower speeds during mild weather. Others use a timer to cycle the blower when thermostatic demands are inadequate for ventilation purposes (Rudd 1998).

Table 12 Total Ventilation Air Requirements

Area Based

 

Occupancy Based

3 cfm/100 ft2 of floor space

 

7.5 cfm per person, based on normal occupancy


Schematic Representation of Six Mechanical Ventilation Systems Used in MFBs (Berquist et al. 2022)

Figure 6. Schematic Representation of Six Mechanical Ventilation Systems Used in MFBs (Berquist et al. 2022)


For new houses with tightly constructed envelopes, balanced ventilation with passive heat recovery (e.g., air-to-air heat exchangers, heat recovery ventilators) can be appropriate in some climates. Fan-induced, filtered outdoor and exhaust airflow at nearly equal rates through a heat exchanger, where heat and sometimes moisture is transferred between the airstreams. This typically reduces the energy required to condition ventilation air by 60 to 80% (Cutter 1987). Concerns associated with these systems include airflow balance, leakage between streams, biological contamination of wet surfaces, frosting, and initial and maintenance costs.

Air-side economizers, which allow outdoor air to be up to 100% of the supply air at appropriate times, are not typically used in small buildings with low internal heat gains relative to the building envelope. Because of heat transfer through building envelopes, these small buildings quickly require heating or cooling as the outdoor air temperature falls or rises. Consequently, from an energy conservation point of view, small envelope-load-dominated buildings do not benefit as much as internal-load-dominated buildings in cool climates from daytime use of air-side economizers; night ventilation of residences during the cooling season may be very attractive, though, when the outdoor humidity ratio is low. Ventilation rates increase dramatically when air-side economizers are in operation, so the extra moisture introduced or removed must be considered.

 Air Distribution

In houses without central air handlers, special provisions to distribute outdoor air may be required. Rooms in which occupants spend many continuous hours, such as bedrooms, may require special consideration. Ventilation equipment should be chosen to be energy efficient, easy to maintain, reliable, durable, and quiet. Designers should consider using heat recovery, especially in cold climates; however, frost control should be considered in climates that frequently encounter temperatures below 23°F when considering a heat recovery ventilator, and below 5°F when considering an energy recovery ventilator.

 Multi-Family Building (MFB) Ventilation

System Types. As mentioned above, mechanical ventilation systems can be categorized into centralized or decentralized systems. When it comes to MFBs, these systems can be classified further into six ventilation system types. Figure 6 shows a schematic representation of the six mechanical ventilation systems used in high-rise MFBs, which is reproduced here from Berquist et al. (2022) with permission of the authors.

Centralized ventilation systems have the flexibility to either serve an entire building using a single make-up air unit (MAU) or employ separate MAUs for each floor or vertical riser, although the latter is less common. The centralized pressurized corridor ventilation systems are designed with the objective of positively pressurizing each corridor. This approach is intended to direct outdoor air into each dwelling unit through the gap beneath the dwelling unit entrance door (Figure 6A). In contrast, centralized direct-to-dwelling unit ducted supply systems directly channel outdoor air into corridors and dwelling units (Figure 6B). Additionally, centralized kitchen and/or bathroom exhaust systems depend on one or a few centralized exhaust fans (EFs) to remove indoor air from each dwelling unit through a vertical shaft leading to rooftop exhaust (Figure 6C). It is worth noting that centralized ventilation systems can incorporate HRV/ERV equipment to enhance energy efficiency, but designers must carefully consider the system’s static pressure when integrating it into an existing setup to avoid unintended consequences like reduced or insufficient ventilation delivery to the dwelling units.

Decentralized ventilation systems operate with fans and duct networks in each dwelling unit, providing a more localized approach to supplying and exhausting air from individual units. In the case of decentralized supply systems, supply fans (SFs) directly deliver outdoor air to a specific dwelling unit (Figure 6D). Decentralized kitchen and/or bathroom exhaust systems rely on exhaust fans to directly remove indoor air from individual dwelling units and can be combined with centralized supply systems (Figure 6E). Decentralized HRV/ERV systems are commonly used to directly supply outdoor air to and remove indoor air from a particular dwelling unit while simultaneously recovering sensible and latent heat (Figure 6F). Buildings equipped with outdoor air supply and exhaust in each dwelling unit typically incorporate a centralized supply system to ensure outdoor air supply to corridors and for pressurization purposes. However, it is important to note that this centrally supplied air is not intended to provide outdoor air to individual dwelling units, thus requiring a lower central MAU capacity.

 Ventilation Air Distribution

Ventilation air should be provided to each habitable room through mechanical and natural air distribution. If a room does not have a balance between air supply and return or exhaust, pathways for transfer air should be provided. These pathways may be door undercuts, transfer ducts with grilles, or simply grilles where ducts are not necessary; however, building codes must be checked, because compartmentation requirements for limiting fire and smoke movement may restrict transfer air means or require rated fire and smoke dampers, for example.

 Relevant Standards and Codes

Mechanical ventilation for residential buildings is required by ASHRAE Standard 62.2 and by building codes in some U.S. states. ASHRAE Standard 62.2 presents minimum ventilation requirements for residential dwellings and acceptable IAQ, and its user’s manual (ASHRAE 2019a) has detailed information for designing and constructing residential buildings in compliance with the standard. In addition, MFBs include common spaces and corridors which must be designed in accordance with ASHRAE Standard 62.1. The National Building Code of Canada references ASHRAE Standard 62.1 for common areas in MFBs and contains prescriptive requirements for single-family homes and MF dwellings in Part 9. It is important to note that best or good practice may require going beyond the standard and code minimums. Section 6 describes good practice; however, it presumes that the minimum requirements of 62.2 are met as well. The minimum residential ventilation rate is not always sufficient to adequately dilute all contaminants (e.g., radon), and can introduce undesired substances (e.g., pollen). In these cases, source control, local exhaust, extra ventilation, or more effective air treatment is required to manage contaminant levels. Therefore, occupants must be responsible for monitoring and controlling contaminant sources in and around their indoor environments, as well as for operating their dwelling units to meet their individual needs. Increasingly, residences are also used for business or hobby purposes, which may introduce air contaminants not addressed in ASHRAE Standard 62.2; portions of these residences may require ventilation air as required by ASHRAE Standard 62.1 or industrial guidelines. Canadian Standards Association (CSA) Standard F326 expands the requirements for residential mechanical ventilation systems to include air distribution within the house, thermal comfort, minimum temperatures for equipment and ductwork, system controls, pressurization and depressurization of the dwelling, installation requirements, and verification of compliance. Verification can be by design or by test, but the total rate of outdoor air delivery must be measured.

 Selection Principles for Residential Ventilation Systems

Occupant comfort, energy efficiency, ease of use, service life, initial and life-cycle costs, value-added features, and indoor environmental quality should be considered when selecting a strategy and system. Poorly designed, installed, or maintained HVAC and related systems can be potential contributors to poor IAQ. For example, occupants may not use the ventilation systems as intended if operation results in thermal or acoustical discomfort or excessive energy use. The resulting lack of ventilation might produce poor IAQ. Therefore, careful design, construction, commissioning, operation, and maintenance is necessary to provide optimum effectiveness.

The type of ventilation system can be selected based on house leakage class as defined in ASHRAE Standard 119. Balanced air-to-air systems with heat recovery are optimal for tight houses (leakage classes A to C in the standard). The leakier the house, the larger the contribution from infiltration and the less effective heat recovery ventilation will be. Tightening the envelope beyond the level of ASHRAE Standard 62.2 may be warranted in extremely cold climates to better use the heat recovery effect (Sherman and Matson 1997). In mild climates, these systems can also effectively be used in leakage classes D to F. Central exhaust systems should not be used for leakage classes A to C unless special air intakes are provided; otherwise, their operation may depressurize the house enough to cause back drafting through fossil-fueled appliances without closed-combustion systems. Unbalanced systems (either supply- or exhaust-only) are optimal for leakage classes D to F. Ventilation systems are normally not needed for leakage classes G to J, but when they are needed, an unbalanced system is usually the best choice. More discussion of mechanical systems for single-family homes is available in Russell et al. (2005) and some information on practices outside North America can be found in McWilliams and Sherman (2005). More discussion of mechanical systems and their performance in MFBs in cold climates is available in Berquist et al. (2022).

All exhaust, supply, or air handler fans have the potential to change the pressure of an indoor space relative to the outdoors. High-flow fans, such as in the air handler and with some cooking exhausts, can cause significant depressurization, particularly in tightly constructed homes. Considering these effects is essential in design. Excessive depressurization of the living space relative to outdoors may cause back drafting of combustion appliances and increased migration of contaminants such as radon or other soil gases, car exhaust, or insulation particles into the living space. Depressurization can also result in increased moisture intrusion into building cavities in warm, moist climates and may cause more structural damage and fungal growth. Pressurization of the living space can cause condensation in building cavities in cold climates, also resulting in structural damage. Excess pressure can be best prevented by balancing ventilation and exhaust systems and tightly sealing duct systems. In addition, adequate pathways must be available for all return air to the air-handling devices.

Occupant activities, operation of exhaust fans, and leaky ducts may depressurize the structure. Options to address backdrafting concerns include

  • Locating combustion appliances in a ventilated room isolated from depressurized zones by well-sealed partitions

  • Providing supply or makeup air to balance exhaust from the zone

  • Testing to ensure that depressurization is not excessive

The system must also be designed, built, operated, and maintained in a way that discourages growth of biological contaminants. Typical precautions include sloping condensate drain pans toward the drain, keeping condensate drains free of obstructions, keeping cooling coils free of dirt and other obstructions, maintaining humidifiers, and checking for and eliminating any cause of moisture inside ducts. Additional information on residential ventilation system design and IAQ control may be found in ASHRAE Guideline 24.

7. COMMERCIAL AND INSTITUTIONAL INFILTRATION

 Envelope Leakage

ASTM Standard E779-2019a and CGSB Standard 149.10-2019 include methods to measure the airtightness of building envelopes of single-zone buildings. Although many multizone buildings can be treated as single-zone buildings for testing by opening interior doors or by inducing equal pressures in adjacent zones, these standards provide no guidelines for dealing with problems arising in tall buildings, such as stack and wind effects. Tall buildings require refinement and extensions of established procedures because they have obstacles to accurate measurement not present in small buildings, including large envelope leakage area, interfloor leakage, vertical shafts, and large wind and stack pressures. ASTM Standard E3158 was developed for application in tall, multizone buildings. Chapter 4 in the 2023 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications discusses tall buildings and their challenges in detail.

For conducting a pressurization test in a large building, the building’s own air-handling equipment sometimes can be used to induce test pressures, as described in CGSB Standard 149.15-1996 and USACE (2013) protocols. In other cases, large fans are brought to the building to perform the test, as described by the Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers’ (CIBSE) Standard TM23-2000. ASHRAE RP-1478’s final report (Anis and Brennan 2014) discusses how to test the envelope leakage of large commercial buildings.

In the past, building envelopes of large commercial buildings were often assumed to be quite airtight. Tamura and Shaw (1976a) found that, assuming a flow exponent n of 0.65 in Equation (32), air leakage measurements in eight Canadian office buildings with sealed windows ranged from 0.12 to 0.48 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water. Persily and Grot (1986) performed whole-building pressurization tests in large office buildings that showed that pressurization airflow rate divided by building volume was relatively low compared to that of houses. However, if these airflow rates are normalized by building envelope area instead of by volume, the results indicate similar envelope airtightness levels to those in typical North American houses. The same study also looked at eight U.S. office buildings and found air leakage ranging from 0.21 to 1.03 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water. This means that the office buildings’ envelopes were leakier than expected. Typical air leakage values per unit wall area at 0.30 in. of water were 0.10, 0.30, and 0.60 cfm/ft2 for tight, average, and leaky walls, respectively (Tamura and Shaw 1976a).

Emmerich and Persily (2014) summarized available measured airtightness data for almost 400 buildings, including about 70 constructed between 2000 and 2010. The average air leakage rate for the buildings was 20% tighter than the average for the 228 buildings included in a similar 2011 analysis. The data were analyzed to determine factors that affect airtightness (e.g., building type, height). Recent additions to the database, previously reported by Emmerich and Persily (2005), include numerous buildings constructed to meet the specifications of sustainable building programs such as LEED®, as well as buildings designed and constructed with air barriers. The overall average airtightness reported was 0.72 cfm/ft2 for six-sided (i.e., including slabs and basement surfaces) envelope surface areas at 0.30 in. of water. The data show only weak trends related to year of construction, height, floor area, wall construction, or building type, but do demonstrate that buildings designed and constructed with attention to airtightness are much tighter than typical commercial buildings. The analysis found that the 79 buildings with air barriers had an average air leakage rate almost 70% less than the average for the 290 buildings not specified as having air barriers, thus demonstrating the critical need to design and construct commercial buildings with dedicated air barriers to support sustainable building design. This finding is supported by recent data from Washington State, which has had performance-based airtightness requirements in their building codes since 2009. A sample of 113 commercial and institutional buildings had a mean air leakage rate of 0.24 cfm/ft2 at 0.3 in. of water (Jones 2022). Studies have generally found weak relationships between air leakage rate and air barrier type for liquid-applied membranes, self-adhered membranes, sealed sheathing, and glazed assemblies (Jones 2022; Jones et al. 2014). Slightly higher air leakage rates were associated with mechanically attached sheet air barriers; however, the authors noted that mechanically attached air barriers were more common in MFBs, compared to commercial/institutional buildings.

In the United States, commercial building construction practices are addressed by various standards, codes, and green building program requirements, and Table 13 summarizes some of the relevant air leakage limits from these requirements. Both ASHRAE Standards 90.1 and 189.1 require continuous air barriers (CABs) for most commercial buildings. The 2022 edition of Standard 90.1 provides two compliance paths for buildings with a floor area greater than 10,011 ft2: the prescriptive path, which specifies air barrier material and assembly airtightness limits, or the performance-based path, which specifies a maximum whole-building air leakage rate of 0.34 cfm/ft2 at 0.3 in. of water. The building commissioning requirements of Standard 189.1 include a whole-building test demonstrating the building meets a tightness limit of 0.25 cfm/ft2 under a pressure differential of 0.30 in. of water or the implementation of a rigorous envelope commissioning program.

Table 13 Summary of Building Airtightness Data

Standard or Code

Air Leakage, cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water

Material

Assembly

Whole Building*

ASHRAE 90.1

0.004

0.04

0.39

ASHRAE/ICC/USGBC/IES 189.1-2023

0.004*

0.04*

0.20

IECC

0.004

0.04

0.39

IgCC

Same as ASHRAE 189.1

Same as ASHRAE 189.1

0.25

USACE ECB 2009-29

0.004

—

0.25

GSA P100-2021

0.004

0.04

2.25

Notes: IECC= International Energy Conservation Code

IgCC = International Green Construction Code

USACE = U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

GSA = U.S. General Services Administration

* Whole-building limits are based on six-sided enclosure, including slab and below-grade walls.


The 2021 International Energy Conservation Code® (IECC®) has requirements with options for a CAB with material or assembly tightness or a whole-building test. The 2015 ICC/ASHRAE Standard 700 National Green Building Standard® (IgCC®) (ICC 2015) includes the same requirements as the 2021 IECC. Many U.S. state building codes currently or will include requirements for CABs either through reference to IECC, IgCC, ASHRAE Standard 90.1 or 189.1, or their own independent requirements; a current list of requirements is available at www.airbarrier.org.

Since 2009, the USACE has required that conditioned buildings be built or retrofitted to include a CAB to control air leakage through the building envelope (USACE 2013). The specification requires whole-building testing with a maximum leakage of 0.25 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water based on the six-sided building enclosure area (including slab and subgrade walls). The average tightness for a set of 285 new and retrofitted USACE buildings was reported to be 0.18 cfm/ft2 (Zhivov 2013). Also, the U.S. General Services Administration (GSA 2021) since 2010 requires all new U.S. federal buildings for the Public Buildings Service to include an air barrier with the whole building having an air leakage rate of not more than 0.39 cfm/ft2 at 0.30 in. of water.

Grot and Persily (1986) also found that eight recently constructed office buildings had infiltration rates ranging from 0.1 to 0.6 ach when outdoor air intakes were deactivated. Infiltration rates exhibited varying degrees of weather dependence, generally much lower than that measured in houses. Infiltration in commercial buildings can have many negative consequences, including reduced thermal comfort, interference with proper operation of mechanical ventilation systems, degraded IAQ, moisture damage of building envelope components, and increased energy consumption. These results suggest strongly that commercial buildings’ envelopes require tighter construction, and that CAB systems should be used in the enclosures of all conditioned buildings. Since 1997, the Building Environment and Thermal Envelope Council of the National Institute of Building Sciences has sponsored several symposia on air barriers for buildings in North American climates. Others have also published articles on the importance of limiting air leakage in commercial buildings (Anis 2001; Ask 2003; Fennell and Haehnel 2005).

Envelope leakage in commercial buildings also depends on HVAC system operation. Often, commercial buildings and their HVAC systems are in operation during normal daytime business hours but switch into “unoccupied” operation at nights and on weekends and holidays. If pressurized while their HVAC systems operate, infiltration is often very low or even eliminated in buildings with tight envelopes. However, in unoccupied mode, this pressurization is often lost, so infiltration and potentially moisture intrusion may be significant at times.

 Air Leakage Through Internal Partitions

In large buildings, air leakage associated with internal partitions becomes very important. Walls, doors, floors, ceilings, plenums, chases, transfer ducts and grilles, and elevator and stairway enclosures are the major separations of concern in these buildings. Their leakage characteristics are needed in multizone models to predict infiltration through exterior walls and airflow patterns in a building. These internal resistances are also important in the event of a fire to predict smoke movement patterns and evaluate smoke management systems.

Table 14 gives air leakage areas calculated at 0.30 in. of water with CD = 0.65 for different internal partitions of commercial buildings (Klote et al. 2012). Figure 7 presents examples of measured air leakage rates of elevator shaft walls (Tamura and Shaw 1976b), the type of data used to derive the values in Table 14. Consult Chapter 54 of the 2023 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications for performance models and applications of smoke control systems. As with the exterior shell, making significant effort to seal unintentional openings in internal partitions in large buildings can improve thermal comfort and energy efficiency, as well as improve the building’s performance in a fire.

Table 14 Air Leakage Areas for Internal Partitions in Commercial Buildings (at 0.30 in. of water and CD = 0.65)

Construction Element

Wall Tightness

 

Area Ratio

     

AL/Aw

Stairwell walls

Tight

 

0.14 × 10–4

 

Average

 

0.11 × 10–3

 

Loose

 

0.35 × 10–3

Elevator shaft walls

Tight

 

0.18 × 10–3

 

Average

 

0.84 × 10–3

 

Loose

 

0.18 × 10–2

     

AL/Af

Floors

Average

 

0.52 × 10–4

AL = air leakage area

Aw = wall area

Af = floor area


Air Leakage Rates of Elevator Shaft Walls

Figure 7. Air Leakage Rates of Elevator Shaft Walls


Leakage paths, intentional or otherwise, at the top of elevator shafts are often equivalent to orifice areas of 620 to 1550 in2. Air leakage rates through stair tower and elevator doors are shown in Figure 8 as a function of average crack width around the door. Sealing elevator and stair doors well, and possibly using indoor vestibules for them, can reduce air as well as smoke flow rates significantly. Air leakage areas associated with other openings in commercial buildings are also important for air movement calculations. These include interior doors and partitions, suspended ceilings in buildings where space above the ceiling is used for air supply or return, and other components of the air distribution system.

 Air Leakage Through Exterior Doors

Door infiltration depends on the type and use of door, room, and building, and on air speed and pressure differentials. In residences and small buildings where doors are used infrequently, a closed door is assumed, and airflow can be estimated based on air leakage through cracks between door, frame, and sill. Where exterior doors are used frequently, airflow through them increases significantly as door-opening frequency increases. Consider using vestibules or revolving doors for high-frequency applications.

Air Leakage Rate of Door Versus Average Crack Width

Figure 8. Air Leakage Rate of Door Versus Average Crack Width


 Air Leakage Through Automatic Doors

Automatically swinging, sliding, rotating, or overhead doors are a major source of air leakage. They are normally installed where large numbers of people use the doors or where bulk goods or vehicles are transported through the doorways. These doors stay open longer with each use than manually operated doors. Air leakage through an automatic door can be reduced by installing a vestibule. However, pairs of automatic doors on the inside and outside of a vestibule normally have overlapping open periods, even when used by only one person. Therefore, it is important that designers include airflow through automatic doors when calculating heating and cooling loads in adjacent spaces.

To calculate the average airflow rate through an automatic door, the designer must consider the area of the door, the pressure difference across it, the discharge coefficient of the door when it is open, and the fraction of time that it is open. Obtaining the discharge coefficient is complicated by the fact that it changes as the door opens and closes.

To simplify this calculation, ASHRAE research project RP-763 (Yuill 1996) developed Figure 11 to combine the discharge coefficients of doors as they open and close with the fraction of time that doors are open at a particular level of use. This figure presents an overall airflow coefficient as a function of the number of people using a door per hour. To obtain the average infiltration rate through an automatic door, multiply this coefficient by the door’s opening area and by the square root of the pressure difference between the outdoor and indoor air at the door’s location. The pressure difference across a door in a building is difficult to predict accurately and depends on wind pressure on the building, stack effect caused by the indoor/outdoor temperature difference, and effects of air-handling system operation. It also depends on leakage characteristics of the building’s exterior walls and of internal partitions.

Airflow Coefficient for Automatic Doors

Figure 9. Airflow Coefficient for Automatic Doors


Pressure Factor for Automatic Doors

Figure 10. Pressure Factor for Automatic Doors


A simplified design method is presented here. It requires explicit calculation of envelope pressures. This process can be automated and streamlined with computational programs that calculate driving forces at each time step.

History of ASHRAE Standard 62.1 Minimum Ventilation Rates for Offices, Based on Default Occupant Densities Note the significant reduction to 5 cfm/person from 1981 to 1989. Although calculation methods changed in later editions (and expanded to two procedure options in 2019), effective ventilation rates have remained roughly the same since 1989. Source: Kono et al. 2922.

Figure 11. History of ASHRAE Standard 62.1 Minimum Ventilation Rates for Offices, Based on Default Occupant Densities
Note the significant reduction to 5 cfm/person from 1981 to 1989. Although calculation methods changed in later editions (and expanded to two procedure options in 2019), effective ventilation rates have remained roughly the same since 1989.
Source: Kono et al. 2922.


Airflow Q is

(46)

where

Q = airflow rate, cfm
CA = airflow coefficient from Figure 9, cfm/ft2 · in. of water0.5
A = area of the door opening, ft2
Δp = pressure difference across door, in. of water

To find Δp, it is necessary to find the pressure differential created by both wind and stack effect. To give the largest possible pressure difference across the door, there are no interactions between the two natural pressures:

(47)

where

pw = wind-induced surface pressure relative to static pressure, in. of water
Δps = pressure difference caused by stack effect, in. of water

Example Calculations.

Find the maximum possible winter infiltration through an automatic door on the ground floor of a 20-story building.

Solution: The area of the door is 36 × 84 in. = 3024 in2 = 21 ft2. Each floor is 13 ft high. Approximately 300 people per hour pass through the door. The design wind conditions are 15 mph, indoor temperature is 70°F, and outdoor temperature is 20°F. The airflow coefficient from Figure 9, using the line for doors without vestibules, is approximately 920 cfm/[ft2 · (in. of water)0.5].

The worst possible case for wind surface pressure coefficient Cp at any point and in any position on the ground floor of the building is inferred from the figures in Chapter 24 to be about 0.75. Using this in Equation (15), together with the specified wind speed, results in pw = 0.082 in. of water. Assume that H is one-half the door height (42 in.). To have maximum pressure across the door, assume the neutral pressure plane is located halfway up the building such that

Substituting these values into Equation (25) gives Δps = –0.19 in. of water. This is the maximum stack pressure difference given no internal resistance to airflow. To find the actual stack pressure difference, it is necessary to multiply this by a draft coefficient. For this example, the coefficient is assumed to be 0.9, which is the highest value that has been found for tall buildings. Therefore, Δps = 0.9(–0.19 in. of water) = –0.17 in. of water. The total pressure is then Δp = 0.082 – (–0.17) = 0.252 in. of water. Substituting into Equation (46),

If the building has a vestibule, the airflow coefficient is read from Figure 9 using the line for doors with vestibules, and it is approximately 626 cfm/ft2 · in. of water0.5, reducing airflow to 6600 cfm into the building.


Standard-sized revolving doors are often used where there is high use, but typically not where people would often be carrying large bags or pushing carts. Dols et al. (2014) applied a coupled building energy and airflow simulation tool to simulate airflow through entry doors in a prototype medium office building created by Ng et al. (2012) and found that using a vestibule reduced infiltration through the building entrance by 23%. More information on predicting infiltration rates through standard and extra-large revolving doors is still needed.

 Airflow Through Air Curtains

Air curtains are jets of air projected across envelope openings with the intention of reducing airflow and the entrance of dust and insects, for example. They are commonly applied to loading dock doorways and high-use building entrances. Performance of air curtains strongly depends on factors such as jet characteristics, wind, and building pressurization. More discussion on air curtain performance is available in the research literature and in section 3.9 of Chapter 20 of the 2024 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Systems and Equipment.

8. COMMERCIAL AND INSTITUTIONAL VENTILATION

ASHRAE Standard 62.1 contains requirements on ventilation and IAQ for commercial, institutional, and high-rise residential buildings. These requirements address system and equipment issues, design ventilation rates, commissioning and systems start-up, and operation and maintenance. The user’s manual for Standard 62.1-2022 provides details to help design, install, and operate building systems to meet requirements. The design requirements include three alternative procedures:

  • The prescriptive ventilation rate procedure (VRP) contains a table of outdoor air ventilation requirements for a variety of space types, with adjustments for air distribution in rooms and systems serving multiple spaces. These requirements consist of both a per-person rate and a per-floor-area rate. Minimum outdoor air ventilation rates are based, in part, on research by Berg-Munch et al. (1986), Cain et al. (1983), Iwashita et al. (1989), and Yaglou et al. (1936), as well as years of experience of designers and building operators.

  • The performance IAQ (IAQP) seeks acceptable IAQ by controlling indoor contaminant concentrations through source control, air cleaning, and ventilation. Chapter 29 of the 2024 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Systems and Equipment has information on air cleaning.

  • The natural ventilation procedure (NVP) provides for simplified requirements for naturally ventilated buildings that define window and space geometry intended to ensure adequate ventilation and distribution in naturally ventilated spaces.

The ventilation rate procedure is by far the more commonly used because of its prescriptive nature.

Combining source control and local exhaust, as opposed to dilution with ventilation air, is the method of choice in many industrial environments. Industrial ventilation is discussed in Chapters 31 and 32 of the 2023 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications and in Industrial Ventilation: A Manual of Recommended Practice (ACGIH 2016). Ventilation of health care facilities, where high IAQ is expected, is discussed in ASHRAE Standard 62.1, Chapter 8 of the 2023 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications, and other publications (e.g., FGI 2014).

Commercial and institutional building ventilation systems are typically designed to provide slight pressurization to reduce infiltration. This pressurization is achieved by having the outdoor or makeup airflow rate higher than the exhaust or relief airflow rate. In these buildings, infiltration is therefore usually neglected in HVAC design except in areas such as lobbies and loading docks, where infiltration can be important because of doors. However, this minimal infiltration may only be achieved in practice with very tight envelope construction (e.g., including a continuous air barrier). As discussed in the section on Driving Mechanisms for Ventilation and Infiltration, wind and stack effect can also cause significant infiltration and exfiltration. Ventilation airflow rates for commercial and institutional buildings are typically determined using procedures in ASHRAE Standard 62.1. In these procedures for designing mechanical ventilation systems, no credit is given for infiltration. However, weather-driven pressure differentials may be significant and need to be considered when designing the ventilation system.

 Ventilation Rate Procedure

Per ASHRAE Standard 62.1, the design ventilation rate is determined starting with a table of minimum ventilation requirements for different space types. These requirements are expressed as an outdoor airflow rate per occupant or per unit floor area, or often both, depending on space type. These ventilation rates are based on air contaminants generated by people, activities, and building materials and furnishings. The rates are then adjusted for various parameters (e.g., multiple zones, type of room air distribution).

The HVAC designer faces several challenges in designing an air distribution system to deliver outdoor air to building occupants. The first is to determine whether the outdoor air is acceptable for use, and to design a system for cleaning the air if it is not acceptable. A second is to design an air intake and distribution system that will deliver the required level of outdoor air to the occupied portions of the building, and not just admit it to an air handler. This outdoor air must be delivered not only at design conditions, but throughout the year. The task is complicated by weather-related variations in indoor/outdoor pressure difference. Other complications include pressure variations caused by building components such as intermittent exhaust fans or dirty filters, and probably most significantly by supply flow variations associated with variable-air-volume (VAV) systems (Janu et al. 1995; Mumma and Wong 1990). This delivery issue is related to the discussion in the section on Air Change Effectiveness.

 Multiple Spaces

Many commercial and institutional buildings have multiple-zone, recirculating ventilation systems wherein one or more conventional air handlers condition a mixture of outdoor and recirculated air (supply air) to more than one ventilation zone. Each zone may have a different outdoor air fraction required by ASHRAE Standard 62.1, but each air handler can typically only provide one outdoor air fraction. Therefore, the zone that requires the greatest outdoor air fraction (the critical zone) defines the outdoor air intake rate of the air handler. Consequently, all other zones receive more outdoor air than their minimum requirement. These zones can be considered to have unused ventilation air, which could be returned to the air handler and recirculated; thus, the outdoor air fraction at the air handler could be reduced while still meeting the needs of the critical zone. Two methods to address multiple-zone recirculating systems are provided in the ventilation rate procedure (VRP) of Standard 62.1: a simplified procedure (section 6.2.4.3, added in the 2019 edition) and the alternative procedure (Appendix A), multiple-zone system ventilation efficiency. ASHRAE-sponsored research experimentally tested the validity of Appendix A’s approach and confirmed that the system ventilation efficiency equation (SVEE) is a valid predictor of ventilation distribution in a building (Yuill et al. 2012).

Secondary Recirculating Systems. Some systems circulate unused ventilation air through paths other than through the central air handler. Common examples include transfer fans and fan-powered boxes. An equation for zone ventilation efficiency for secondary recirculation systems is Equation (A-4) of ASHRAE Standard 62.1.

Equation (A-4) depends on the ventilating ability of the secondary recirculation fraction Er. The standard previously described Er in terms of the proportion of average system return air directly recirculated from the critical zone. Yuill et al. (2008) argued that the formulation of Equation (A-4) implicitly defines Er as a descriptor of the vitiation of the secondary air, and presented a formal definition of Er, a version of which was adopted for Standard 62.1. Under this definition, if secondary air is drawn from an area that is less contaminated than the building average, values of Er greater than 1 are possible. Yuill et al. (2012) measured Er in several locations in an office building and found results ranging from 0.74 to 1.01. Results in the same building could have ranged from 0.14 to 1.13 if the fan-powered boxes had been located differently.

 Survey of Ventilation Rates in Office Buildings

Relatively few measurements of as-built office building ventilation performance have been conducted, and those data generally have not used consistent measurement methods or involved representative collections of buildings. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Building Assessment Survey and Evaluation (BASE) study involved indoor environmental measurements, including ventilation, in 100 randomly selected office buildings using a standardized protocol (EPA 2003). Persily et al. (2005) analyzed the BASE data and found that outdoor air ventilation rates measured using duct traverses at air handler intakes were higher than might be expected, with a mean of about 117 cfm per person. However, these elevated values are partially explained by low occupant density (mean of about four persons per 1000 ft2) and high outdoor air fractions (mean of about 35%). Considering only values that correspond to minimum outdoor air intake, the mean ventilation rate was 23 cfm per workstation. About one-half the ventilation rates under minimum outdoor air intake were below 20 cfm per person, which was the required minimum ventilation rate for Standard 62.1 at the time. (Figure 11 shows the history of ASHRAE Standard 62.1 minimum ventilation rates for offices.) Another key outcome of this study is documentation of measured airflow rates that are quite different from their design values. A more recent survey of 95 office buildings found that 44% provided minimum ventilation rates, and 33% could make minor adjustments to do so (McNulty et al. 2022). These findings highlight the need for good system commissioning and maintenance to achieve design intent. Designing and configuring systems to encourage regular maintenance by providing easy access to key system components is also important. The more recent survey also found that 23% of buildings were significantly underventilated and would require major retrofit or replacement to meet current standards; these buildings were designed in the 1980s, when 62.1 rates were much lower, and had yet to be renovated (Kono et al. 2022).

9. OFFICE BUILDING EXAMPLE

Ventilation and infiltration principles from this chapter, Standard 62.1-2022, and elsewhere are applied to a conventional office building in Atlanta, Georgia. The infiltration, local exhaust, or ventilation airflow rates determined can be used later in the design process (1) as input for the heating and cooling load calculations; (2) for sizing fans, ducts, and dampers; and (3) for inclusion in the construction documents’ air-handling units (AHUs) schedules and specifications.

This example relies on the 2022 edition of ASHRAE Standard 62.1; because this and other standards are updated frequently, users should check for the latest edition.

 Location

The example building is about 8 mi northeast of downtown Atlanta, and is close to a major highway and its access roads. Atlanta’s climate is hot and humid in the summer, and has relatively mild winters. The average annual outdoor air temperature is about 60.6°F and the heating degree-days per year, base 65°F (HDD65), are about 3265 (Rock 2005). From Chapter 14, the winter 99% design outdoor air (OA) temperature is 23°F, whereas the 1% cooling dry-bulb temperature is 91°F, with a mean coincident wet-bulb temperature of 74°F. The 99.6 and 0.4% design wind speeds are 12 mph in the winter and 9 mph in the summer, both from the northwest. Warm and humid winds also travel north from the Gulf of Mexico, and occasionally the wind is from the Atlantic Ocean from the southeast.

 Building

The approximately 30,500 ft2 building is a two-story, flat-roofed, slab-on-grade commercial office building with a substantial roof overhang in each direction. Materials and construction quality are average commercial grade. Double-paned windows, and similar spandrel glass, are fixed in their metal curtain wall frames; all windows are nonoperable. The remaining portions of the exterior walls are brick. There are relatively few exterior doors, as described later in this example. The building is surrounded by black asphalt driveways, a parking lot, and some vegetation. The nearby highway is across a parallel two-lane access road, to the northwest.

 Occupancy

The building is occupied during normal weekday business hours, and occasionally for special weekend events. Night and weekend thermostat setbacks are used. On the perimeter of the building are mostly single-person offices and conference rooms. The core of the building is mainly open plan with cubicle workspaces, as well as various support rooms, restrooms, two stair towers, and an elevator. There is a large mailroom on the first floor and a lunchroom on the second. Occupant density is high during workdays. The overhead fluorescent lighting is typical of such office buildings, and there are significant computing, printing, and copying equipment loads. Smoking is not allowed in the building.

The building is owner occupied. Owners generally have long-term interests in minimizing costs, and in maximizing IAQ and thermal comfort so that workers’ productivity is high.

 Infiltration

For this example, assume a conventional all-air overhead HVAC system, and that the building is well sealed. Consequently, a slightly positive overall building pressurization is assumed during occupied hours. Because water condensation in the exterior envelope of the building is possible, air pressurization should be as low as is practical, and continuous air and moisture retarders should be installed. As a more expensive alternative to slight pressurization, the automatic control system could actively manage the dampers’ positions and fans’ operation to maintain an average neutral pressurization, relative to the outdoors. In either case, a good assumption is that infiltration is minimized, the windows and spandrel glass are fixed and well sealed, and the exterior doors are normally kept closed. During high-wind conditions beyond design, windward perimeter spaces may have some infiltration loads, but under nonpeak outdoor temperatures, a well-zoned HVAC system should have enough capacity to handle these extra loads. If both the OA temperature and wind are extreme, then these upwind perimeter spaces may become slightly uncomfortable. These extreme conditions are expected to occur only a few hours in a typical year.

Spaces with exterior doors can experience significant infiltration loads when people enter and leave. First-floor vestibules on the north and south sides of the building help limit this infiltration through the two main entrances. The double doors from stair tower #2 have infrequent use, and a high level of thermal comfort in stair towers is not typically expected. Thus, brief infiltration surges in stair tower #2 are deemed acceptable. However, the doors from the parking lot to the mailroom are frequently used by staff for shipping, receiving, entrance, and egress, and infiltration loads on the vestibules and mailroom are of concern. Many designers choose to ignore these extra loads in pressurized buildings, because they are transient and not easily characterized; the systems’ capacities are likely sufficient to minimize uncomfortable conditions in these spaces. In this example, however, the HVAC designer is concerned about summertime airborne moisture, especially in the mailroom where books and other publications are stored, because strong, humid, southerly winds easily overcome a slight indoor pressurization when the large doors to the parking lot are open.

This chapter and many of its supporting references describe detailed methods for estimating infiltration or air leakage. Typically, pressure differences, openings’ coefficients, and hour-by-hour weather data are required to perform these transient calculations, usually using a computer program separate from that used for thermal load calculations. For HVAC design purposes for a building similar to the example, an air change rate of unconditioned outdoor air through infiltration, per space, expressed in air changes per hour or airflow rate (in cfm) is of more immediate use. Either value is then entered into the load calculation program. Although traditional simplified methods of estimating infiltration in commercial buildings are not considered highly accurate, Ng et al. (2015, 2018) review and describe improved methods to estimate infiltration rates in commercial buildings.

North Vestibule

  • Gross floor area ≈ 11 ft × 13 ft = 143 ft2

  • Room volume ≈ 143 ft2 × 9 ft = 1287 ft3

  • ACHinf ≈ 1.0, so

  • Qinf ≈ (1287 ft3 × 1.0)/60 min/h ≈ 22 cfmoa

Either 1.0 ach or 22 cfm of infiltration is then used as input for the load calculation program for this space. The 1.0 ach assumption was made by the designer during on-site observation that these particular manually operated exterior doors have low usage. If passage rates were known, Yuill’s (1996) flow rate estimation method would have been used instead.

South Vestibule

  • Gross floor area ≈ 8 ft × 10 ft = 80 ft2

  • Room volume ≈ 80 ft2 × 9 ft = 720 ft3

  • ACHinf ≈ 2.0, so

  • Qinf ≈ (720 ft3 × 2.0)/60 min/h ≈ 24 cfmoa

In practice, this back entrance from the parking lot on the southeast side of the building is the primary means of entrance and egress, and as such, the estimated infiltration for it is increased to 2.0 ach, compared to the north vestibule’s 1.0 ach.

In colder U.S. climates, it is common practice for low-cost commercial buildings to have only space heating, and not cooling, in stair towers and vestibules. However, for this building in the Southeast, the designer decided to provide cooling for these vestibules. Thus, the estimated infiltration rates are applied to both the heating and cooling load calculations for these spaces. The building’s mailroom, which also has exterior doors, is to be heated and cooled, too.

Mailroom

  • Gross floor area ≈ (51 ft × 22 ft) + (33 ft × 10 ft) = 1452 ft2

  • Room volume ≈ 1452 ft2 × 9 ft = 13,068 ft3

  • ACHinf ≈ 0.5, so

  • Qinf ≈ (13,068 ft3 × 0.5)/60 min/h ≈ 109 cfmoa

Even though the mailroom has only a single layer of doors to the outdoors, and not a vestibule, the designer estimated the infiltration at a lower rate (0.5 ach) than those for the vestibules. This is because of the mailroom’s large interior volume relative to its exterior doorway’s area.

Note that no estimate of air changes will be accurate at all times; this portion of HVAC design is still largely an art because of the many unknowns and variability of weather and building use. For improved energy conservation, all exterior doors must be extremely well weatherstripped and have automatic closers. A sign indicating that the doors should be kept closed when not in use should be placed on the mailroom’s exterior doors. High-quality gaskets and sealants for the windows and spandrel glass are also required to minimize infiltration.

 Local Exhausts

(This section assumes that ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 62.1-2022 has been adopted into the local building code without modification.) At least 10 rooms require direct, powered air exhaust: two restrooms per floor, a darkroom, three designated photocopy spaces, and two janitors’ closets. The restrooms have three flushable fixtures each, so from Table 6-4 of Standard 62.1-2022, with intermittent use, each restroom requires

Also from Table 6-4, the darkroom on the second floor needs

Similarly, the designated photocopy areas need 0.50 cfmea/ft2, so

The two small janitors’ closets, one on each floor, also require exhaust:

These local exhaust airflow rates are then entered into the load calculation program. They are room loads, attached to each particular space, and are not combined and entered as systems-level loads. The load calculation program evaluates the room loads, appropriately combines them, and then finds the systems-level loads for various peak hours.

Some local code authorities amend the requirements of Standard 62.1, or have not yet adopted the most current version, so significant deviations from these examples are possible. For example, in much of the United States, janitorial closets and photocopy rooms have not been required to have local exhausts. Standard 62.1 recognized that these spaces can be significant sources of airborne contaminants, and some direct exhaust from each of them can be very beneficial for improving IAQ.

 Ventilation

(This section also assumes that ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 62.1-2022 has been adopted into local code without changes.) Ventilation air is needed to maintain acceptable indoor air quality. The example building is well sealed, natural ventilation is not used, and no credit for any infiltration is taken toward ventilation air requirements, as is typical for conventional commercial buildings. Thus, minimum ventilation air required by Standard 62.1 is provided mechanically through the building’s AHUs. Outdoor air pollution from the major highway nearby as well as metropolitan Atlanta’s smog may require some outdoor air pretreatment to ensure outdoor air quality is acceptable.

Standard 62.1 has two methods for determining needed ventilation airflow rates: the performance IAQ procedure (IAQP), and the prescriptive ventilation rate procedure (VRP). Most HVAC designers of conventional buildings with normal occupancies and outdoor air conditions use the VRP, which is appropriate for this example building.

Required ventilation air, which is solely conditioned outdoor air, is admitted to this building through two air-handling units; each AHU serves one floor. Flow rates of outdoor air are input values for, and carried through to the results of, the load calculation simulation. Energy needed to condition the outdoor air ultimately is a systems-level load, because all of this ventilation air is conditioned by the AHUs before its introduction to the building.

Commercial load calculation programs often provide suggested values of ventilation airflow rates and occupancy schedules, but may not have been updated to reflect the latest VRP requirements and procedures of Standard 62.1. As such, it is difficult to present an example here; instead, a sample check using some assumed values for the first-floor executive director’s office is given. It is assumed that this room is a separate thermal zone because of its use and its location on the southwest corner of the building and thus two afternoon solar exposures.

Executive Director’s Office

  • Gross floor area ≈ 12 ft × 21 ft = 252 ft2

  • Room volume ≈ 252 ft2 × 9 ft = 2268 ft3

  • Assumed supply air Qsa = 412 cfm

The supply airflow rate was estimated using 300 ft2/ton, a sensible heat factor of 0.9, a cooling supply (55°F) to room (75°F) air temperature difference of 20°F, 12,000 Btu/h per ton of cooling, and the sensible heat equation 1.1 × cfmsa × ΔT. From Table 6-1 of Standard 62.1-2022, the office’s population P can be estimated as

In this case, however, there is only one regular occupant of the space. The needed ventilation airflow rate to the breathing zone Vbz is then found from the table as follows:

where

Rp = outdoor airflow rate required per person, from Standard 62.1’s Table 6-1, cfm
Pz = zone population (largest number of people expected to occupy the zone during typical use)
Ra = outdoor airflow rate required per unit area, from Standard 62.1’s Table 6-1, cfm
Az = occupiable floor area of zone, ft2

Because this is a conventional office building, with ceiling plenums and no raised floors, overhead air supply and return is assumed. The cooling mode, not heating, is dominant in this and most other U.S. office buildings that have high internal heat gains and well-sealed and insulated envelopes. From the standard’s Table 6-4, with ceiling supply of cool air, the zone air distribution effectiveness Ez is estimated as 1.0. From Equation (6-2) of the standard, the design zone outdoor airflow rate Voz is then

But this is still not the amount of outdoor air that must be conditioned by the air handler: the rate must be adjusted for inefficiencies and recirculation in the air distribution system.

Because single-duct VAV with terminal reheat air distribution systems were initially planned by the designer, Standard 62.1’s multiple-zone recirculating systems adjustment is needed. This adjustment, system ventilation efficiency Ez, can be determined by either the simplified procedure (section 6.2.4.3) or the alternative procedure (Appendix A) of 62.1. The following calculations use an older method that was replaced by the simplified procedure, which may still be referenced by some jurisictions. This thermal zone, the primary outdoor air fraction Zp for its VAV terminal unit and downstream is

However, for VAV systems, the minimum expected primary airflow rate should be used. In this case, 412 cfm is the peak design airflow rate Vpz. Designers often assume about 30% of this peak flow as the minimum in VAV systems, so for this space, 412 × 0.3 = 124 cfm. The adjusted primary outdoor air fraction is then

The preceding calculations need to be performed for every thermal zone on each air handler. Then, for each system, the highest primary outdoor air fraction is used to estimate the air distribution systems’ ventilation effectiveness; the Standard 62.1 User’s Manual (ASHRAE 2019b) includes a spreadsheet for doing these calculations. Increasingly, load calculation programs include the necessary routines and data.

For the purposes of this example, 0.16 is assumed to be the maximum Zp, so, from Table 6-4 of Standard 62.1, the system ventilation efficiency Evz is 0.9. If, instead, the standard’s Appendix A method for determining Evz were used, a value closer to 1.0 for perfect mixing would likely result for this example’s conventional overhead all-air cooling system. Table 6-4’s value of 0.9 is likely somewhat conservative, but is obtained quickly for design purposes. The newer simplified procedure determines Evz based on system diversity, with a maximum conservative value of 0.75.

Next, the uncorrected outdoor air intake flow rate Vou is needed; Standard 62.1’s Equation (6-5) includes diversity factor D to adjust the people component of the flow rate. All zones’ flow rates are needed to perform this calculation. For this example, the uncorrected outdoor air intake flow rate for the first floor’s AHU was estimated from floor area, an occupancy of 5 people per 1000 ft2, and 20 cfm per person, and is assumed to be 1525 cfm. The adjusted outdoor air intake flow rate Vot for this AHU is then

After load calculations are complete, these assumed airflow rates can be replaced with actual values for each zone, and the outdoor airflow rate can be updated. Repeating the load calculations may be necessary. The final value of the adjusted outdoor air intake flow rate is then reported on the AHU’s equipment schedule so that testing, adjusting, and balancing (TAB) personnel and others can use this information to ensure that the system admits the desired flow rate of ventilation air. The information is also used to select air cleaners, dampers, coils, ducts, and fans.

For more examples on determining ventilation air rates for commercial buildings, see the user’s manual for Standard 62.1 (ASHRAE 2019b). For low-rise residential buildings, consult ASHRAE Standard 62.2-2022 and its user’s manual (ASHRAE 2019a).

10. NATURAL VENTILATION

Natural ventilation is the flow of outdoor air caused by wind and thermal pressures through intentional openings in a building’s shell. Under some circumstances, it can effectively control temperature, contaminants, and possibly airborne moisture in mild climates, but it is not considered practical in hot and humid climates in the summer or in cold climates during the winter. Special consideration of the intended conditions is needed before natural ventilation is implemented in these circumstances. Temperature control by natural ventilation is often the only means of providing some cooling when mechanical air conditioning is not available. Analysis of natural ventilation can be reduced to the balancing of the driving forces (wind and stack) to the resistance forces (pressure losses through openings). The arrangement, location, and control of ventilation openings should combine the driving forces of wind and temperature to achieve a desired ventilation rate and good distribution of ventilation air through the building. However, intentional openings cannot always guarantee adequate temperature and humidity control or IAQ because of the dependence on natural wind and stack effects to drive the flow (Wilson and Walker 1992). A natural ventilation system should be designed to work so that stack-driven ventilation alone is adequate and that wind either is benign or enhances airflow. Using nighttime ventilation and the building’s thermal mass effect may be effective for reducing conventional cooling energy consumption in some buildings and climates if moisture condensation can be controlled. Axley (2001a) and CIBSE (2005) reviewed natural ventilation in commercial buildings, including potential advantages and problems, natural ventilation components and system designs, and recommended design and analysis approaches.

 Natural Ventilation Openings

Natural ventilation openings include (1) operable windows, clerestories, doors, trickle vents, and skylights; (2) roof ventilators; (3) stacks; and (4) specially designed inlet or outlet openings such as OA louvers and EA grilles, ventilation penthouses or shafts, chimneys, windcatchers, and roof monitors.

Operable windows transmit light, and provide ventilation when opened. They may open by sliding vertically or horizontally; by tilting on horizontal pivots at or near the center; or by swinging on pivots at the top, bottom, or side. The type of pivoting used is important for weather protection and can significantly alter the means by which wind influences the opening. A casement window hinged on the side can cause both a positive and negative pressure from wind, depending on which direction the wind is passing along the façade. This clearly would affect the airflow rate. Exterior doors, often with insect screens, can also provide a path for natural ventilation; as with operable windows, security concerns must be considered. The presence of insect screens and the pressure losses they impose ought to be included in the analysis of natural ventilation flows.

Roof ventilators provide a weather-resistant air outlet. Capacity is determined by the ventilator’s location on the roof; the resistance to airflow of the ventilator and its ductwork; the ventilator’s ability to use kinetic wind energy to induce flow by centrifugal or ejector action; and the height of the draft.

Natural-draft or gravity roof ventilators can be stationary, pivoting, oscillating, or rotating. Selection criteria include appearance, ruggedness, corrosion resistance, stormproofing features, dampers and operating mechanisms, noise, cost, and maintenance. Natural ventilators can be supplemented with power-driven supply or exhaust fans; their motors need only be energized when the natural exhaust capacity is too low. Gravity ventilator dampers can be manual or controlled by thermostat or wind velocity.

A natural-draft roof ventilator should be positioned so that it receives full, unrestricted wind. Turbulence created by surrounding obstructions, including higher adjacent buildings, impairs a ventilator’s ejector action. Inlets can be conical or bell-mouthed to increase their flow coefficients. The opening area at any inlet should be increased if screens, grilles, or other structural members cause flow resistance. Building air inlets, most effectively installed at the lowest levels, should be larger than the combined throat areas of all roof ventilators.

Stacks or vertical flues should be located where wind can act on them from any direction. Without wind, stack effect alone removes some air from the rooms with inlets. Much practical experience with natural ventilation from before the adoption of modern air-conditioning appears in publications by ASHVE (a predecessor society to ASHRAE).

 Ceiling Heights

In buildings that use natural ventilation, floor-to-ceiling heights are often increased well beyond the normal 8 to 10 ft. Higher ceilings, as seen in buildings constructed before air conditioning was available, allow warm air and contaminants to rise above the occupied portions of rooms. Air is then exhausted from the ceiling zones, and outdoor air is introduced near the floors; a degree of floor-to-ceiling displacement airflow is thus desirable when using natural ventilation during the cooling season.

 Airflow Through Large Intentional Openings

The relationship describing the airflow through a large intentional opening is based on the Bernoulli equation with steady, incompressible flow. The general form that includes stack, wind, and mechanical ventilation pressures across the opening is

(48)

where

Q = airflow rate, cfm
CD = discharge coefficient for opening, dimensionless
A = cross-sectional area of opening, ft2
ρ = air density, lbm/ft3
Δp = pressure difference across opening, in. of water
776 = unit conversion factor

The discharge coefficient CD is a dimensionless number that depends on the geometry of the opening and the Reynolds number of the flow.

 Flow Caused by Wind Only

Aspects of wind that affect the ventilation rate include average speed, prevailing direction, seasonal and daily variation in speed and direction, terrain, and local obstructions such as nearby buildings, hills, trees, and shrubbery. Liddament (1988) reviewed the relevance of wind pressure as a driving mechanism. A multiflow path simulation model was developed and used to illustrate the effects of wind on air change rate.

Average wind speeds may be lower in summer than in winter; directional frequency is also a function of season. Natural ventilation systems are often designed for wind speeds of one-half the seasonal average. Equation (49) shows the rate of air forced through ventilation inlet openings by wind or can be rearranged to determine the size of openings to produce a given target airflow rate:

(49)

where

Q = airflow rate, cfm
Cv = effectiveness of openings (Cv is assumed to be 0.5 to 0.6 for perpendicular winds and 0.25 to 0.35 for diagonal winds)
A = free area of inlet openings, ft2
U = wind speed, mph
88.0 = unit conversion factor

Air intakes should be placed in exterior high-pressure regions, and air reliefs should be placed in exterior low-pressure regions, but because of variations associated with wind directionality, these static locations will, at times, not be optimal. Other considerations include flow control when wind speed is high, and security. Air intakes should face directly into the prevailing wind. If they are not advantageously placed, flow will be less than that predicted by Equation (49); if intakes are unusually well placed, flow will be slightly more. Desirable air relief locations are (1) on the leeward side of the building directly opposite the intake; (2) on the roof, in the low-pressure area caused by flow separation; (3) on a side perpendicular to the windward face, where low-pressure areas occur; (4) in a dormer on the leeward side; (5) in roof ventilators; or (6) by stacks. Chapter 24 gives a general description of the wind pressure distribution on a building, but transient computational modeling will likely be required. Clearly, intakes should be located on parts of a building that are not exposed to contaminants from the surroundings or location exhausts.

 Flow Caused by Thermal Forces Only

If building internal resistance is not significant, flow caused by stack effect can be expressed by

(50)

where

Q = airflow rate, cfm
CD = discharge coefficient for opening
ΔHNPL = height from midpoint of lower opening to NPL, ft
Ti = absolute indoor temperature, °R
To = absolute outdoor temperature, °R

Equation (50) applies when Ti > To. If Ti < To, replace Ti in the denominator with To, and replace (Ti – To) in the numerator with (To – Ti). If there is thermal stratification, use an average temperature for Ti. The discharge coefficient CD accounts for all viscous effects such as surface drag and interfacial mixing.

Estimating ΔHNPL is difficult for naturally ventilated buildings. It is really the area-weighted height of all the openings (Simmonds and Phillips 2021). To be more complete, the calculation should include the network of flow resistances on each floor between the exterior and the vertical shaft(s). However, the area-weighted height is adequate as a first cut. If the areas of the openings on each floor are the same size, then the NPL is at the midheight of the building. A large opening at the top can draw the NPL upward, while a large opening at the bottom can draw the NPL down. If one window or door represents a large fraction (approximately 90%) of the total opening area in the envelope, then the NPL is at the mid-height of that aperture, and ΔHNPL equals one-half the height of the aperture. For this condition, flow through the opening is bidirectional (i.e., air from the warmer side flows through the top of the opening, and air from the colder side flows through the bottom). Interfacial mixing occurs across the counterflow interface, and the orifice coefficient can be calculated by Equation (51) (Kiel and Wilson 1986):

(51)

If enough other openings are available and the NPL does not pass through an opening, airflow through the opening will be unidirectional, and mixing cannot occur. A discharge coefficient of CD = 0.65 should then be used. Additional information on stack-driven airflows for natural ventilation can be found in Foster and Down (1987).

The greatest flow per unit area of openings is obtained when the intake and relief areas are equal; Equation (50) is based on this equality. Increasing the relief area over intake area (or vice versa) increases airflow but not in proportion to the added area. When openings are unequal, use the smaller area in Equation (50).

In reality, natural ventilation is a dynamic phenomenon and the primary mechanisms by which outdoor air change occurs in naturally ventilated buildings are often unsteady and include pumping action and simultaneous wind-driven flow in and out of a single side of a building. Complete models for these phenomena are not yet available.

 Natural Ventilation Guidelines

Several general guidelines should be observed in designing for natural ventilation, including ASHRAE’s (2021) Design Guide for Natural Ventilation. Some of these may conflict with other climate-responsive strategies such as using orientation and shading devices to minimize solar gain, with building codes that encourage compartmentalization to restrict fire and smoke movement, or with other design considerations.

System selection

  • In hot, humid climates, use mechanical cooling. If mechanical cooling is not available, air velocities should be maximized in the occupied zones of rooms to the extent that increased air speeds continue to increase thermal comfort and not cause other problems.

  • In hot, arid climates, consider evaporative cooling. Airflow throughout the building should be maximized for structural cooling, particularly at night when the outdoor air temperature is low and night purging of heat can help. Note, however, that any internal cooling will reduce the overall flow rates if it is driven by stack forces alone. This is because cooling will reduce the temperature difference, thus reducing the density difference.

  • For commercial and institutional buildings, internal thermal loads should be minimized to allow for their removal by the ventilation flow rates that are achievable with natural ventilation. This can be achieved through optimization of solar geometry and shading and reduction of solar loads, and use of efficient lighting and equipment.

Building and surroundings characteristics

  • Topography, landscaping, and surrounding buildings should be used to redirect airflow and give maximum exposure to breezes. Vegetation can funnel breezes and avoid wind dams, which reduce the driving pressure differential around the building. Site objects should not obstruct air intakes’ openings.

  • The building should be shaped to expose maximum shell openings to breezes.

  • Architectural elements such as wing walls, parapets, and overhangs should be used to promote airflow into the building interior.

  • Window opening types should be selected carefully so that they contribute to, not detract from, the desirable local opening pressure.

  • The long façade of the building and the majority of door and window openings should be oriented with respect to prevailing summer breezes. If there is no prevailing direction, openings should be sufficient to provide ventilation regardless of wind direction.

  • In general, buildings should be narrow in plan in order to ensure sufficient distribution throughout the occupied space.

  • Floor-to-ceiling heights should be increased if possible to induce larger stack-driven flow rates.

  • Increasing thermal capacitance of the building by adding mass extends the outdoor temperature range in which natural ventilation is viable as a thermal control strategy.

Opening locations

  • Windows should be located in opposing pressure zones. Two openings on opposite sides of a space increase ventilation flow. Openings on perpendicular sides of the building force air to change direction, providing ventilation to a greater area. The benefits of the window arrangement depend on the air relief location relative to the direction of the intake’s airstream.

  • If a room has only one exterior wall, better airflow is achieved with two widely spaced windows.

  • If openings are at the same level and near the ceiling, much of the flow may bypass the occupied portion of a room and be less effective in removing contaminants from there.

  • Vertical distance between openings is required to take advantage of stack effect; the greater the vertical distance, the greater the ventilation rate.

  • Openings near the NPL are least effective for thermally induced natural ventilation. If the building has only one large opening, the NPL tends to move to that level, which reduces pressure across the opening.

Opening characteristics

  • Greatest airflow per unit area of total opening is obtained by having openings of nearly equal areas. An inlet window smaller than the outlet creates higher inlet velocities. An outlet smaller than the inlet creates lower but more uniform airspeeds through the room.

  • Openings with areas much larger than calculated are sometimes desirable when anticipating increased occupancy, very hot weather, or when stack-driven natural ventilation is likely to dominate as a driving mechanism.

  • In one room, horizontally separated windows are generally better than vertically separated windows. They produce more airflow over a wider range of wind directions and are most beneficial in locations where prevailing wind patterns shift.

  • Window openings should be accessible to and operable by occupants, unless fully automated. For secondary fire egress, operable windows may be required.

  • Intake and exhaust openings should not be obstructed by draperies, furniture, or nearby indoor partitions, for example. Partitions can be placed to split and redirect airflow but should not restrict flow between the building’s inlets and outlets. Vertical airshafts or open staircases, where allowable by fire code, can be used to increase and take advantage of stack effects. Enclosed staircases intended for evacuation or safe haven during a fire must not be used for ventilation.

Methods and tools have been developed in recent years to move the art of designing natural ventilation systems beyond the application of simple rules of thumb to engineered design (Axley et al. 2002; CIBSE 2005; Emmerich et al. 2012).

 Hybrid Ventilation

Successful application of purely natural ventilation systems for cooling may be very limited in hot or humid climates, by thermal comfort issues and the need for reliability. However, hybrid (or mixed-mode) ventilation systems or operational strategies offer the possibility of saving energy in a greater number of buildings and climates by combining natural ventilation systems with mechanical equipment (Emmerich 2006). The air-side economizer is one form of hybrid ventilation control scheme, and enjoys wide use in commercial, industrial, and institutional buildings in appropriate climates. The report of the International Energy Agency’s (IEA) Annex 35 describes the principles of hybrid ventilation technologies, control strategies, design and analysis methods, and case studies (Heiselberg 2002). Integrated multizone airflow and thermal modeling is recommended when designing natural and hybrid ventilation systems (Axley 2001a; Dols et al. 2014; Li and Heiselberg 2003).

11. VENTILATION EFFECTS ON THERMAL LOADS

Outdoor air introduced into a building constitutes a large part of the total space-conditioning load for mechanical systems, which is one reason to limit air change rates to the minimum required. Outdoor air ventilation typically represents 20 to 50% of a modern, ventilation-code-compliant building’s thermal load in nontemperate climates. The effect on heating loads tends to be much larger than on cooling loads (McDowell et al. 2003). Chapters 17 and 18 address thermal loads in more detail.

Outdoor air ventilation increases a building’s thermal load in several ways. First, incoming air must be heated or cooled from the outdoor air temperature to the indoor or supply air temperature. The rate of energy consumption by this sensible heating or cooling is

(52)

where

qs = sensible heat load, Btu/h
Q = airflow rate, cfm
ρ = air density, lbm/ft3 (about 0.075 at or near sea level)
cp = specific heat of air, Btu/lbm · °F (about 0.24)
ΔT = temperature difference between indoors and outdoors, °F

and at or near sea-level air density, with an adjustment for typical room air humidity, this equation is commonly presented for design use as

(53)

Equations (52) and (53) are known as the sensible heat equation. HVAC designers typically assume sea-level air pressure for locations with altitudes of 2000 ft or lower. A method to adjust for elevation is provided in Chapter 18.

Outdoor air ventilation also modifies the moisture content of the air in a building. The rate of energy consumption associated with these latent loads, to add or remove water from the air and neglecting the energy associated with any condensate, is

(54)

where

ql = latent heat load, Btu/h
ΔW = humidity ratio difference between indoors and outdoors, lbm water/lbm dry air
T = average of indoor and outdoor temperatures, °F

Equation (54) is known as the latent heat equation. When at or near sea level, and for common comfort air temperatures, the right-hand side of Equation (54) is approximately 4840QΔW

Example 7.

A makeup air unit (MAU) is to condition 5000 cfm of outdoor air in the winter for a building in Atlanta, Georgia. If the air is to be delivered directly to the occupied spaces at 75°F and 30% rh, how much sensible and latent heat must be added to this ventilation air at winter design conditions?

Solution: From the weather data tables provided on the CD included with this volume, Atlanta is at an elevation of about 1000 ft. Because this is below the rule-of-thumb cutoff of 2000 ft for assuming sea-level conditions, air density is assumed to be 0.075 lbm/ft3. Also from the Atlanta data table, the winter 99% design dry-bulb (db) temperature is 26.4°F, but a mean coincident wet bulb is not provided. However, for humidification design, a dew-point temperature of 9.1°F is given along with its 32.2°F mean coincident dry bulb (MCDB). Using these data, a 1°F dew point is assumed as the 99% mean coincident dew point.

From ASHRAE’s sea-level psychrometric chart and the winter design conditions, the desired humidity ratio W of the 75°F, 30% rh makeup air is about 0.0056 lbmw/lbmda. For the very dry outdoor air, with a dew point of 1°F, a problem occurs: the standard sea-level psychrometric chart does not extend below 32°F. Designers often assume that air below this temperature has W = 0, and this assumption gives conservative results. However, both high- and low-temperature psychrometric charts are available from ASHRAE, as is a table of moist air properties at standard conditions in Chapter 1. From this table, saturated air at 1°F, which is also its dew point, has a humidity ratio of 0.0008298 lbmw/lbmda. With 5000 cfm of outdoor air to be conditioned, and using the sensible and latent heat equations for sea level, the energy needed to condition this outdoor air is

and

Thus, the MAU’s heating coil and humidifier, neglecting fan heat, need to be sized to provide at least a net 267,300 Btu/h of sensible heat, and 115,000 Btu/h of latent heat. Humidification can be provided by cold water, warm water, or steam, so a more precise psychrometric analysis is needed to size the heating coil correctly after the humidification method is selected and it is decided whether the humidifier will be placed before or after the heating coil.


As Example 7 shows, ventilation loads can be substantial. They are often 50% or more of the total space conditioning loads in modern, well-insulated, high-occupancy commercial buildings in less temperate climates. When cooling outdoor air, substantial moisture usually must be removed from the ventilation air; reheat or regenerative heat recovery may be required in all but dry climates.

 Effect on Envelope Insulation

Airflow also can affect a building’s thermal load by altering performance of the envelope insulation system. Airflow through insulation can decrease the thermal load through heat exchange between infiltrating or exfiltrating air and the insulation. Conversely, air moving in and out of the insulation from the outdoors can increase the thermal load. Experimental and numerical studies demonstrate that significant thermal coupling can occur between air leakage and insulation layers, thereby modifying the heat transmission in building envelopes. In particular, research (Bankvall 1987; Berlad et al. 1978; Lecompte 1987; Wolf 1966) shows that convective airflow through air-permeable insulation in an envelope assembly may degrade its effective thermal resistance. This R-value degradation occurs when outdoor air moves through and/or around the insulation within the wall cavity and returns to the outdoors without reaching the conditioned space. A literature review by Powell et al. (1989) summarized the findings about air movement effects on the effective thermal resistance of porous insulation under various conditions. The effect of such airflow on insulation system performance is difficult to quantify, but should be considered. Airflow within the insulation system can also decrease the system’s performance because of moisture condensation in and on the insulation.

Even if air flows only through cracks instead of through the insulation, the actual heating/cooling load from the combined effect of conduction and airflow heat transfer can be lower than the heating/cooling load calculated by Equation (33). This reduction in total heating/cooling load is a consequence of the thermal coupling between conduction and convection heat transfer and is called infiltration heat recovery (IHR). Using a computer simulation, Kohonen et al. (1987) found that the conduction/infiltration thermal interaction reduced total heating load by 15%. Several experimental studies (e.g., Claridge and Bhattacharyya 1990; Claridge et al. 1988; Liu and Claridge 1992a, 1992b, 1992c, 1995; Timusk et al. 1992), using a test cell under both steady-state and dynamic conditions, found that the actual energy attributed to air infiltration can be 20 to 80% of the values given by Equation (35). Judkoff et al. (1997) measured heat recovery in a mobile home under steady-state conditions, and found that up to 40% of heat recovery occurs during exfiltration through the envelope. Buchanan and Sherman (2000) performed two- and three-dimensional CFD simulations to study the fundamental physics of the IHR process and developed a simple macro-scale mathematical model based on the steady-state one-dimensional convection-diffusion equation to predict a heat recovery factor. Their results show that the traditional method may overpredict the infiltration energy load. Using physical experiments, ASHRAE research project RP-1169 (Ackerman et al. 2006) showed that thermal resistances are affected by infiltration and exfiltration, but, on a net basis, the IHR effect can be neglected.

 Infiltration Degree-Days

Heating and cooling degree-days (HDDs and CDDs) are a simple way to characterize the severity of a particular climate. Heating and cooling degree-day values are based on sensible temperature data, but infiltration loads are both sensible and latent. Infiltration degree days (IDDs) more fully describe a climate and can be used to estimate heat loss or gain from infiltration in residences (Sherman 1986). Total infiltration degree-days is the sum of the heating and cooling infiltration degree-days and is calculated from hour-by-hour weather data and base conditions using weather weighted by infiltration rate. The selection of base conditions is an important part of the calculation of the IDDs. ASHRAE Standard 119 lists IDDs for many locations with a particular set of base conditions.

12. DYNAMIC CONTROL OF VENTILATION

Codes and standards such as ASHRAE Standards 62.1 and 62.2 often specify constant ventilation rates as a baseline means of providing acceptable IAQ. These specifications are usually given in terms of the addition of an area-based rate for displacing contaminants generated by building materials, furnishings, etc., and a person-based rate for displacing occupant-generated contaminants. However, the design occupancy rate may only be experienced for a fraction of the life of the building, resulting in overly conservative and inefficient designs. Furthermore, these prescriptions make no allowance for time-shifting of ventilation in response to, for example, outdoor temperature.

 Occupancy-Based Demand-Controlled Ventilation

An energy-saving strategy for the constant-rate scenario is occupancy-based control of ventilation. When spaces are operated below design occupancy or when no people are present during scheduled occupied periods, the people outdoor air rate RP may be reduced to be consistent with current occupancy. This is a form of dynamic reset and is often called demand-controlled ventilation (DCV). The controls are usually based on determining occupancy through direct measurement or people of estimating through a tracer gas technique such as CO2 or humidity measurements, and modulating ventilation systems proportionally to measured, estimated, or scheduled occupancy. Note: in spaces with large volumes or high ceilings, and in low-occupancy spaces, there is significant lag to achieving tracer gas steady-state conditions, which may falsely indicate higher ventilation. Quicker measurement or estimation methods and the use of multiple sensors for determining occupancy may be desirable. Many new technologies offer occupant tracking and space utilization information that can be used to determine current occupancy rates. Some examples include air sampling, thermal counting, cameras, acoustic devices, access control and ID badges, smart phones and wearables, point-of-sale, or other scheduling systems.

ASHRAE Standard 90.1 requires DCV for spaces based on climate zone, occupant outdoor airflow rate, and a floor area threshold when served by either an air-side economizer or an air handling unit with automatic modulating control of the outdoor air damper; or a design outdoor airflow greater than 3000 cfm. Exceptions are made for spaces with high exhaust or transfer air rates and other specific spaces.

Spaces in which DCV is implemented should have low contaminant emissions from nonoccupant sources and should be ventilated at all times at least at the rates required by ASHRAE Standard 62.1 for area-based emissions. Care should be taken to account for the impact sensor uncertainty (measurement repeatability, drift, hysteresis, and linearity) can have on ventilation system performance as it relates to both energy consumption and IAQ (Berquist and Banister 2020), as well as the effect of sensor lag time and the location of sensors relative to occupants.

The cost effectiveness of DCV systems is greatest in spaces with highly variable occupancy patterns especially if they have high design occupancy density (e.g., theaters, lecture halls) and are in cold climates. Emmerich and Persily (2001) suggest DCV is effective in buildings and climates where heating or cooling is required for most of the year. In 2010, Hong and Fisk concluded that DCV is only cost effective in offices in California with ventilation rates much greater than those prescribed in current standards, with colder climates showing relatively greater potential. In the cold climate of Minnesota, Seventhwave (2015) found DCV savings saved a median of 34% of air-handling unit energy consumption while maintaining acceptable IAQ.

To reduce misunderstanding or misuse of CO2 relative to an indication of IAQ or for DCV, ASHRAE created a position document on indoor carbon dioxide, ventilation, and indoor air quality (ASHRAE 2022, www.ashrae.org/filelibrary/about/positiondocuments/pd_indoorcarbondioxide_2022.pdf.). A new examination of CO2 generation rates of building occupants (Persily and de Jong 2017), the position document, and other recent research led to ASHRAE Standard 62.1 incorporating specific CO2 DCV requirements that include limits, design occupancy adjustments, control methods, and sensor function, accuracy, and location requirements. Addendum ab to 62.1-2022 provides specific requirements for how to use CO2 concentration in DCV controls, with CO2 setpoint requirements for different space types. Note: CO2 values in the standard and CO2 sensor operation are based on standard density conditions. Use of CO2 DCV in areas of high altitude requires adjustments. It is important not to use CO2 DCV in spaces with nonhuman sources of CO2 or with air-cleaning systems that may absorb CO2, because this breaks the mass balance equation. Additionally, DCV is intended to be used with the VRP and not the IAQP. Note: space CO2 levels will be higher when the IAQP is used.

 Implementation in VAV Systems

ASHRAE research projects 1547 and 1747 developed control sequences for implementing such DCV strategies in buildings with variable-air-volume systems (Lau et al. 2014; O’Neill et al. 2020). Simulation showed savings of 7% to 44% source energy compared to the simplified ASHRAE Standard 62.1 approach with implementation across the United States. They recommend the control logic shown in Figure 12 for zones with CO2 sensors and Figure 13 for zones with occupancy sensors.

As ASHRAE Standard 90.1 has evolved, energy-saving strategies that affect fan speed operation have a direct impact to ventilation intake into an air-handling system and to the delivery of ventilation to the zone. Consideration for these dynamic changes should be made in sequences of operation because they may be in direct conflict with DCV and may cause over or under ventilation. As an example, reduced occupancy initiates DCV sequence to reduce an outdoor air damper position, thereby increasing pressure drop across the outdoor damper and reducing ventilation. At the same time, the space load is reduced requiring supply fan speed reduction reducing available static pressure and further reducing ventilation flow. ASHRAE Standard 62.1 requires controls to maintain not less than outdoor intake flow Vot under all load conditions and dynamic reset conditions including variable primary air systems. Airflow measuring devices may be incorporated as part of the non-steady-state DCV sequence (Mumma 2004) or be used to set limits or to validate rates per person. Airflow measuring is recommended to maintain ventilation due to dynamic changes in the ASHRAE DOAS Design Guide (2022d) and Indoor Air Quality Guide (free download with registration at iaq.ashrae.org/). Specific attention should be given to zone or building pressurization requirements when incorporating dynamic reset strategies to ensure desired pressurization differentials are maintained.

 Averaging Time-Varying Ventilation Rates

When assessing time-varying ventilation in terms of controlling IAQ, the quantity of interest is often the temporal average rather than the peak. The concept of effective ventilation (Sherman and Wilson 1986; Yuill 1986, 1991) describes one ventilation rate averaging process. In this concept, the average (effective) rate is the steady-state rate that yields the same average contaminant concentration over the period of interest in the occupied space as does the actual sequence of time-varying discrete ventilation rates over the same period and in the same space. This effective rate is only equal to the simple arithmetic average rate when the discrete ventilation rates are constant over the period of interest and the contaminant concentration has reached its steady-state value. Simple arithmetic averaging of instantaneous ventilation rates or concentrations cannot generally be used to determine these averages because of the nonlinear response of indoor concentrations to ventilation rate variations.

Flow Chart for Zone with CO2 Sensors

Figure 12. Flow Chart for Zone with CO2 Sensors


An important constraint in the effective ventilation concept is that the contaminant source strength F must be constant over the period of interest or must be uncorrelated with the ventilation rate. These conditions are satisfied in many residential and commercial buildings because the emission rates of many contaminants that are controlled by whole-building ventilation systems vary slowly. Sherman and Wilson (1986) describe how to deal with contaminants that have stepped but otherwise constant emission rates. Contaminants such as carbon monoxide, radon, and formaldehyde, whose emission rates can be affected by ventilation, cannot be properly characterized with this concept and require more analyses. For constant-source-strength contaminants, the relationship between effective air change rate, effective ventilation rate, volumetric flow, source strength, average concentration, and time-averaged effective turnover time is given by

Flow Chart for Zone with Occupancy Sensors

Figure 13. Flow Chart for Zone with Occupancy Sensors


(55)

The time-averaged effective turnover time represents the characteristic time for the concentration in the occupied space to approach steady state over the period of interest. It can be determined from a sequence of discrete, instantaneous ventilation air change rates Ii using the following (Sherman and Wilson 1986):

(56)

(57)

(58)

where

Δt = length of each discrete time period
= time-averaged effective turnover time
= instantaneous turnover time in period i
= instantaneous turnover time in previous period

ASHRAE Standard 62.2 provides a set of factors to help calculate the annual effective air exchange rate.

 Continuous Modulation-Equivalent Ventilation or “Smart” Ventilation

In their review of CO2-based DCV, Emmerich and Persily (2001) underline the limitations inherent in using CO2 because of its inadequacy as an overall indicator of IAQ, especially for contaminant emission from sources other than occupants, such as building materials and furnishings. A more sophisticated strategy might ensure occupants the same exposure to a generic indoor contaminant generated by the building (not occupants) as a continuously operating fan compliant with ventilation standards (an approach known as equivalency [Sherman et al. 2011]). Equivalence is required of time-varying ventilation patterns that comply with the ASHRAE Standard 62.2 ventilation standard.

If these constraints are satisfied, dynamic ventilation patterns that are “equivalent” to baseline constant ventilation rate scenarios can be devised. This is done by leveraging the concept of “relative exposure” to a generic contaminant that is assumed to be emitted at a constant rate over the period of interest (Sherman et al. 2011). This process is codified in ASHRAE Standard 62.2. Equivalence can then be ensured by using the average relative exposure is equal to or less than one over the period of interest, and relative exposure never exceeds a factor of five at any time. This process only requires knowledge of the time series of ventilation rates over the period of interest and no individual contaminant concentrations are calculated. Relative exposure is given by Equation (59):

(59)

where

Ri = relative exposure for time-step i
Ri–1 = relative exposure for previous time-step i–1
Qtot = baseline constant ventilation rate, m3/s
Qoa = ventilation rate from the current time-step, m3/s
Δt = time-step, s
V = volume of the space, m3

In cases where there is no ventilation, then Equation (60) is used:

(60)

This method is an acceptable means of ventilating homes, as per Appendix C of ASHRAE Standard 62.2.

Leveraging this method, “smart” ventilation strategies can be designed that shift ventilation in time continuously in response to occupancy, outdoor temperature, indoor and outdoor air quality, electricity grid signals, or operation of other air moving and air cleaning systems. Guyot et al. (2017) provided a review of such strategies and their implementation in North American and European homes. These smart strategies can in principle maintain or improve acceptable IAQ and/or comfort while reducing energy consumption, utility bills, and peak power consumption.

Such strategies have been analyzed and tested for auxiliary fan sensing and timer-based temperature controls (Walker et al. 2012), temperature-based control strategies (Less et al. 2014), humidity control in hot and warm-humid climates (Less and Walker 2016), and others. Studies in U.S. homes showed that occupancy-based ventilation in residences results in small savings with the possible exception of very hot and humid climates (Clark et al. 2019), while temperature-based smart ventilation proved more effective and can reduce annual energy consumption attributable to ventilation loads by as much as half in the state of California (Less et al. 2019). Field implementation of similar strategies (Martin et al. 2018) has shown similar patterns.

13. EXTREME CASES

 Protection from Extraordinary Events

The design, operation and maintenance of a building’s ventilation system and envelope, as well as other factors, can significantly affect the building’s potential vulnerability to extraordinary threats, which range from intentional releases of chemical or biological agents inside or outside a building, to releases of chemicals in industrial or transportation accidents, to wildfires and other natural disasters. ASHRAE (2003) addresses several key steps to manage risk from extraordinary incidents, including

  • Evaluate the risk to a facility of an extraordinary incident

  • Assess the building’s vulnerability

  • Determine the degree of acceptable vulnerability

  • Consider protective measures or options in relation to new, renovated, and existing buildings

Persily (2004) details how ventilation affects buildings’ vulnerability to airborne chemical and biological releases, as well as some strategies for using ventilation, particularly involving airtightness and pressurizing the building interior to protect against outdoor releases, to increase the level of building protection against such incidents. Persily et al. (2007) evaluated retrofit options for protecting buildings from airborne threats; approaches considered included enhanced particle filtration, sorbent-based gaseous air cleaning, ventilation system recommissioning, building envelope airtightening, building pressurization, relocation of outdoor air intakes, shelter-in-place (SIP), isolation of vulnerable spaces such as lobbies, and system shutdown and purge cycles. The filtration and air cleaning options have the advantage of always being operational as long as the systems are properly designed, installed, and maintained. However, the lack of standard test methods is a critical issue in application of some air-cleaning technologies. Further, while filtration might be able to reduce the threat from a particulate release, it will not be able to address a chemical one. Hence, an awareness of the limitations of different technologies is important to ensure overconfidence does not lead to lack of preparedness.

Building envelope air sealing and pressurization can be quite effective in protecting against outdoor sources as long as effective filtration is also in place. Protection provided by operational changes such as system shutdown and purging depends heavily on timing; if timing is inappropriate, occupant exposure may be increased. Isolating vulnerable zones and other system-related modifications depend on building layout and system design, and careful implementation is necessary for effectiveness under the range of conditions that exist in buildings. Finally, many retrofits can also increase energy efficiency and improve IAQ, which should be included in a life-cycle cost comparison of different options to the degree possible. Chapter 60 of the 2023 ASHRAE Handbook—HVAC Applications addresses extraordinary events further.

In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, ASHRAE’s Epidemic Task Force (ETF) produced several guidance documents for reducing the risk of airborne disease transmission in buildings, including core recommendations, one-page summaries and frequently asked questions that are available at the ASHAE website (www.ashrae.org/technical-resources/resources). That guidance laid the groundwork for the development of an enforceable minimum standard. With encouragement from the White House COVID-19 Response Team, ASHRAE published Standard 241-2023, Control of Infectious Aerosols, in under 6 months. It includes a number of new concepts like infection risk management mode, equivalent clean airflow rates for infection control, building readiness plans, and air cleaner safety and effectiveness test requirements.

 Shelter in Place

The most fundamental function of a building is to provide shelter from outdoor conditions. A first response to poor outdoor air quality is to go indoors. Closing windows and other air intakes and turning off exhaust fans reduces outdoor air ventilation, decreasing the immediate intrusion of outdoor air into the building. However, because no building is perfectly airtight, closing doors and windows does not eliminate intrusion, and reducing outdoor air ventilation will elevate levels of indoor-generated contaminants. Because all indoor air ultimately comes from outdoors, IAQ eventually comes to dynamic equilibrium with outdoor conditions in an idealized, unoccupied building. The tighter the building, the longer the time needed to come to equilibrium. The delay time (the time it takes to completely change the air in a building) is determined by the ventilation rate. The effectiveness of sheltering within the home thus depends on envelope tightness. For a home with 0.35 air changes per hour, the delay time is roughly 3 h. For a very tight house without mechanical ventilation, the delay time can easily be twice as long. Most houses in the United States are leakier and thus could have a delay time of about one hour (Sherman and Matson 1997).

Reactive gases in outdoor air, such as ozone, can be decreased to some degree by the building envelope. For other outdoor contaminants, the building envelope serves to delay, not reduce, their introduction into the indoor environment. Such a delay is not very helpful at reducing exposures to outdoor contaminants that persist over days, but can be an effective strategy for short-duration (e.g., less than a few hours) sources. In houses without indoor sources, ozone levels tend to be higher in houses that do not have air conditioners than in those with air conditioners; ozone levels also are higher when windows are open than when they are closed (Weschler 2000). For outdoor exposure times shorter than the delay time, the house serves as a reservoir of cleaner air of that particular contaminant. After the outdoor contaminant is gone, windows can be opened to flush out contaminants that entered or were internally generated during the exposure period.

Recent increases in the number of incidents and severity of wildfires have led to an increase in the use of air cleaning when sheltering in place. Air cleaning is required because the duration of wildfires is too long to rely on the building not being in equilibrium with outdoor air. The Centers for Disease Control has published summaries of air cleaning strategies for reducing wildfire smoke health impacts (CDC 2020). Typical approaches use either central air-handling systems or stand-alone air cleaners to remove particles from wildfires by filtration though the use of MERV 13 or better filters. Guidance is available that is specific to wildfires for residential applications (Harriman et al. 2019). ASHRAE also developed new Guideline 44-2024, Protecting Building Occupants from Smoke During Wildfire and Prescribed Burn Events, and published a wildfire smoke planning framework that advocates for the development of smoke readiness plans (ASHRAE 2023d).

Wildfires have also given rise to a greater interest in particle monitoring, particularly indoors. The availability of relatively low-cost particle sensors had led to particle monitors being readily available at the consumer level and being integrated into HVAC controls. Technical evaluation of these low-cost sensors is available from the South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD 2024). Care should be taken when selecting particulate matter sensors, as size-resolved accuracies can vary significantly.

 Safe Havens

Simply going indoors may not be sufficient for highly unusual but potentially lethal events or those that extend over multiple days. Chemical spills or fires, explosions, bioterrorism, or similar toxic air contaminant releases can temporarily create dangerous outdoor conditions that render other (indoor) air quality issues insignificant. With sufficient warning, occupants should leave the vicinity, but the unexpected nature of these events means that the only viable alternative may be to shelter in place.

This strategy may work for short-term releases of airborne toxins. Homes are often too leaky to provide the protection needed for longer-duration events, but individual rooms can be temporarily sealed to become safe havens. A safe haven should be chosen to have as little contact as possible with outer walls, and preferably be on the side of the house farthest downwind from the source. Impermeable tape can be used to seal leaks, cracks, seams, register grilles, and doors, with thick plastic sheeting used to span larger gaps (Sorensen and Vogt 2001). If such a shelter has an air change rate of 0.15 h–1 with the house, it can take 4 to 6 h for contaminated outdoor air to significantly affect the safe haven. With very well-sealed, occupied spaces, the air quality inside degrades because of the occupants and materials within, especially rapidly for smaller spaces with higher occupant density. Suffocation is theoretically possible (albeit improbable), but thermal stress and odor accumulation are more typical.

Where emergencies are somewhat more likely, engineered safe rooms with adequate HVAC systems are needed. In such cases, a safe haven can be designed in advance with thermal conditioning and a highly efficient particle/gas-phase filtration system capable of providing several hours, days, or weeks of protection (Ormerod 1983). A short-term safe haven might be effectively combined with another emergency shelter (e.g., tornado, hurricane, civil defense) to reduce cost.

14. SYMBOLS

ach = air changes per hour, h–1
A = area, ft2 or in2
c = flow coefficient, cfm/(in. of water)n
cp = specific heat, Btu/lbm·°F
C = concentration, ppm
= time averaged concentration, ppm
CA = airflow coefficient for automatic doors, cfm/ft2 · in. of water0.5
CD = discharge coefficient
Cp = pressure coefficient
Cpi = internal pressure coefficient
Cs = stack coefficient, cfm2/in4 · °F or (in. of water/°F)n
Cv = effectiveness of openings
Cw = wind coefficient, cfm2/in4 · mph2 or (in. of water/mph2)n
E = system efficiency
ELA = effective leakage area, ft2
F = tracer gas injection rate, cfm
= time-averaged contaminant source strength, cfm
f = fractional on-time
g = gravitational acceleration, ft/s2
G = wind speed multiplier, Table 7
H = height, ft
i = hour of year
I = air change rate, 1/time
Ii = instantaneous air change rate, 1/time
L = leakage area, ft2 or in2
L(t) = rate at which contaminant is removed within building by deposition, filtration, air cleaning, and/or chemical reaction
n = pressure exponent
N = number of discrete time periods in period of interest
NL = normalized leakage
p = pressure, in. of water
P = parameter, or number of people, or dimensionless parameter that accounts for loss of contaminant entering building due to particle filtration, gaseous air cleaning, and losses on surfaces
q = heat rate, Btu/h
Q = volumetric flow rate, cfm
= effective volumetric flow rate, cfm
R = outdoor airflow rate required per floor area or per person, cfm; relative exposure
s = shelter factor
S = source strength, cfm
t = time
T = temperature, °F or °R
U = wind speed, mph
V = volume, ft3, or ventilation airflow rate, cfm
W = humidity ratio, lbm water/lbm dry air
X = air fraction
Zp = primary outdoor air fraction
εC = capture efficiency
εI = air change effectiveness
θage = age of air, s, min, or h
ρ = air density, lbm/ft3
τ = time constant, s, min, or h

Subscripts

a = area
bal = balanced
bz = breathing zone
comb = combined
da = dry air
depress = depressurization
e = effective
ea = exhaust air
floor = floor, floor area, ft2
i = indoor or time counter for summation (instantaneous)
I = balancing pressure
inf = infiltration
H = building height, eaves or roof, effective
ka = makeup air
l = latent
L = leakage or local
m = average (mean)
ma = mixed air
met = meteorological station location
n = normalized
N = nominal
NPL = neutral pressure level
o = outdoor, initial condition, or reference
oa = outdoor air
ot = adjusted outdoor air
ou = uncorrected outdoor air
oz = zone outdoor
press = pressurization
pz = peak design
r = reference, representative
s = sensible or stack
sa = supply air
S = space or source
tot = total
U = wind
unbal = unbalanced
v = ventilation
w = wind or water
z = zone

REFERENCES

ASHRAE members can access ASHRAE Journal articles and ASHRAE research project final reports at technologyportal.ashrae.org. Articles and reports are also available for purchase by nonmembers in the online ASHRAE Bookstore at www.ashrae.org/bookstore.

ANSI. 2019. Standard for testing airtightness of building, dwelling unit, and sleeping unit enclosures; airtightness of heating and cooling air distribution systems; and airflow of mechanical ventilation systems. ANSI/RESNET/ICC Standard 380-2019.

ASHRAE. 2023. Control of infectious aerosols. Standard 241-2023.

ASHRAE. 2002. Measuring air-change effectiveness. ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 129-97 (RA 2002).

ASHRAE. 2003. Risk management guidance for health, safety and environmental security under extraordinary incidents. Report, Presidential Ad Hoc Committee for Building Health and Safety Under Extraordinary Incidents.

ASHRAE. 2004. Air leakage performance for detached single-family residential building. ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 119-1988 (RA 2004) (withdrawn).

ASHRAE. 2015. Ventilation and IAQ in low-rise residential buildings. ASHRAE Guideline 24-2015.

ASHRAE. 2017. Ventilation of health care facilities. ANSI/ASHRAE/ASHE Standard 170-2017.

ASHRAE. 2018. Energy-efficient design of low-rise residential buildings. ANSI/ASHRAE/IES Standard 90.2-2018.

ASHRAE. 2019a. Standard 62.1-2019 user’s manual.

ASHRAE. 2019b. Standard 62.2-2019 user’s manual.

ASHRAE. 2021. Design guide for natural ventilation.

ASHRAE. 2022a. Ventilation for acceptable indoor air quality. ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 62.1-2022.

ASHRAE. 2022b. Ventilation and acceptable indoor air quality in residential buildings. ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 62.2-2022.

ASHRAE. 2022c. Energy standard for buildings except low-rise residential buildings. ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 90.1-2022.

ASHRAE. 2022d. ASHRAE design guide for dedicated outdoor air systems, 2nd ed.

ASHRAE. 2022e. ASHRAE position document on indoor carbon dioxide. www.ashrae.org/filelibrary/about/positiondocuments/pd_indoorcarbondioxide_2022.pdf.

ASHRAE. 2023a. Thermal environmental conditions for human occupancy. ASHRAE Standard 55-2023.

ASHRAE. 2023b. Standard for the design of high-performance green buildings. ANSI/ASHRAE/IES/USGBC Standard 189.1-2023.

ASHRAE. 2023c. Control of infectious aerosols. ASHRAE Standard 241-2023.

ASHRAE. 2023d. Planning framework for protecting commercial building occupants from smoke during wildfire events. www.ashrae.org/filelibrary/technicalresources/covid-19/guidance-for-commercial-building-occupants-from-smoke-during-wildfire-events.pdf.

ACGIH. 2016. Industrial ventilation: A manual of recommended practice, 29th ed. American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, Cincinnati, OH.

Ackerman, M.Y., J.D. Dale, and D.J. Wilson. 2006. Infiltration heat recovery, part 1: Field studies in an instrumented test building (RP-1169). ASHRAE Transactions 112(2):597-608. Paper QC-06-056.

Allard, F., and M. Herrlin. 1989. Wind-induced ventilation. ASHRAE Transactions 95(2):722-728. Paper VA-89-10-2.

Anis, W. 2001. The impact of airtightness on system design. ASHRAE Journal 43(12):31-35.

Anis, W., and T. Brennan. 2014. Measuring airtightness of mid and high-rise non-residential buildings. ASHRAE Research Project RP-1478, Final Report.

ASCE. 2022. Minimum design loads and associated criteria for buildings and other structures. ASCE/SEI Standard 7-22.

Ask, A. 2003. Ventilation and air leakage. ASHRAE Journal 45(11):28-36.

ASTM. 2017a. Test method for determining air change in a single zone by means of a tracer gas dilution. Standard E741-11(2017). American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

ASTM. 2017b. Test methods for determining airtightness of buildings using an orifice blower door. Standard E1827-11(2017). American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

ASTM. 2018a. Guide for assessing depressurization-induced backdrafting and spillage from vented combustion appliances. Standard E1998-11(2018). American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

ASTM. 2018b. Standard test method for measuring the air leakage rate of a large or multizone building. Standard E3158-2018. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

ASTM. 2018c. Test method for field measurement of air leakage through installed exterior windows and doors. Standard E783-02(2018). American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

ASTM. 2019a. Test method for determining air leakage rate by fan pressurization. Standard E779-19. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

ASTM. 2019b. Test method for determining rate of air leakage through exterior windows, curtain walls, and doors under specified pressure differences across the specimen. Standard E283-19. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

ASTM. 2022a. Practices for air leakage site detection in building envelopes and air barrier systems. Standard E1186-2022. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

ASTM. 2022b. Standard Test Method for Capture and Containment Performance of Commercial Kitchen Exhaust Ventilation Systems. Standard F1704-12(2022). American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Axley, J.W. 2001a. Application of natural ventilation for U.S. commercial buildings—Climate suitability, design strategies and methods, modeling studies. GCR-01-820, National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD.

Axley, J.W. 2001b. Residential passive ventilation systems: Evaluation and design. Technical Note 54. International Energy Agency Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Sint-Stevens-Woluwe, Belgium.

Axley, J., S. Emmerich, S. Dols, and G. Walton. 2002. An approach to the design of natural and hybrid ventilation systems for cooling buildings. Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on IAQ and Climate, Monterey, CA. www.nist.gov/manuscript-publication-search.cfm?pub_id=860870.

Bankvall, C.G. 1987. Air movements and thermal performance of the building envelope. In Thermal insulation: Materials and systems, pp. 124-131. F.J. Powell and S.L. Mathews, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Batterman, S. 2017. Review and extension of CO2-based methods to determine ventilation rates with application to school classrooms. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 14(2):145.

Batterman, S., G. Hatzivasilis, and C. Jia. 2006. Concentrations and emissions of gasoline and other vapors from residential vehicle garages. Atmospheric Environment 40:1828-1844.

BC Housing. 2017. Illustrated guide: Achieving airtight buildings. research-library.bchousing.org/Home/ResearchItemDetails/1765.

Berg-Munch, B., G. Clausen, and P.O. Fanger. 1986. Ventilation requirements for the control of body odor in spaces occupied by women. Environmental International 12(1-4):195.

Berlad, A.L., N. Tutu, Y. Yeh, R. Jaung, R. Krajewski, R. Hoppe and F. Salzano. 1978. Air intrusion effects on the performance of permeable insulation systems. In Thermal insulation performance, STP 718, pp. 181-194. D. McElroy and R. Tye, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Berquist, J. and Banister, C., 2020. Feasibility of Low-Cost CO2 Sensors for demand-controlled ventilation—Laboratory chamber testing. ASHRAE Transactions 126(2).

Berquist, J., A. Wills, I. Macdonald, C. Banister, M. Bartko, and M. Vuotari. 2020. The effects of leakage location on building air change rate in a pressurized building. ASHRAE Transactions 126:409-418.

Berquist, J., N. Cassidy, M.F. Touchie, W. O’Brien, and J.P. Fine. 2022. High-rise residential building ventilation in cold climates: A review of ventilation system types and their impact on measured building performance. Indoor Air 32(11):e13158.

Berquist, J., Z. Xiong, B. Gunay, and M. Vuotari. 2023. Investigation of the accuracy of BAS-grade CO2 sensors for measuring infiltration rates. Journal of Building Engineering 80:108064.

Blomsterberg, A.K., and D.T. Harrje. 1979. Approaches to evaluation of air infiltration energy losses in buildings. ASHRAE Transactions 85(1):797. Paper PH-79-10-1.

Bohac, D.L., D.T. Harrje, and L.K. Norford. 1985. Constant concentration infiltration measurement technique: An analysis of its accuracy and field measurements, 176. Proceedings of the ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC Conference on the Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Buildings III, Clearwater Beach, FL.

Bohac, D.L., D.T. Harrje, and G.S. Horner. 1987. Field study comparisons of constant concentration and PFT infiltration measurements. Proceedings of the 8th IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Überlingen, Germany, pp. 47-62.

Bohac, D. L., M.J. Hewett, J. Fitzgerald, and D. Grimsrud. 2007. Measured change in multifamily unit air leakage and airflow due to air sealing and ventilation treatments. Buildings X: Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Whole Buildings, 1-13.

Bohac, D. L., M.J. Hewett, S.K. Hammond, and D. Grimsrud. 2011. Secondhard smoke transfer and reductions by air sealing and ventilation in multiunit buildings: PFT and nicotine verification. Indoor Air, 21:36-44.

Bohac, D.L.B. Schoenbauer, J. Fitzgerald, C. Harrington, J. Garcia, and M. Modera. 2016. Using an aerosol sealant to reduce multifamily envelope leakage. ACEEE Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings, 1–16.

Bohac, D.L., L. Sweeney, R. Davis, C. Olson, and G. Nelson. 2020. Energy code field studies: Low-rise multifamily air leakage testing. Centre for Energy and Environment.

Bradley, B. 1993. Implementation of the AIM-2 infiltration model in HOT-2000. Report, for Natural Resources Canada.

Buchanan, C.R., and M.H. Sherman. 2000. A mathematical model for infiltration heat recovery. Proceedings of the 21st IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, The Hague, Netherlands. Report LBNL-44294. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Cain, W.S., B. Leaderer, R. Isseroff, L. Berglund, R. Huey, and E. Lipsitt. 1983. Ventilation requirements in buildings—I. Control of occupancy odor and tobacco smoke odor. Atmospheric Environment 17(6):1183-1197.

CDC. 2020. Evidence on the use of indoor air filtration as an intervention for wildfire smoke pollutant exposure: a summary for health departments.

CGSB. 2005. Depressurization test. CAN/CGSB Standard 51.71-2005. Canadian General Standards Board, Ottawa, ON.

CGSB. 1996. Determination of the overall envelope airtightness of buildings by the fan pressurization method using the building’s air handling systems. Standard 149.15-96. Canadian General Standards Board, Ottawa, ON.

CGSB. 2019. Determination of the airtightness of building envelopes by the fan depressurization method. Standard 149.10-M86(2019). Canadian General Standards Board, Ottawa, ON.

Chan, W.R., W.W. Nazaroff. P.N. Price, M.D. Sohn, and A.J. Gadgil. 2005. Analyzing a database of residential air leakage in the United States. Atmospheric Environment 39(19):3445-3455.

Charlesworth, P.S. 1988. Measurement of air exchange rates. Chapter 2 in Air exchange rate and airtightness measurement techniques—An applications guide. International Energy Agency Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Sint-Stevens-Woluwe, Belgium.

Chastain, J.P. 1987. Pressure gradients and the location of the neutral pressure axis for low-rise structures under pure stack conditions. Unpublished M.S. thesis. University of Kentucky, Lexington.

Chastain, J.P., and D.G. Colliver. 1989. Influence of temperature stratification on pressure differences resulting from the infiltration stack effect. ASHRAE Transactions 95(1):256-268. Paper 3230.

Chastain, J.P., D.G. Colliver, and P.W. Winner, Jr. 1987. Computation of discharge coefficients for laminar flow in rectangular and circular openings. ASHRAE Transactions 93(2):2259-2283. Paper NT-87-27-1.

CHBA. 1994. HOT2000 technical manual. Canadian Home Builders Association, Ottawa, ON.

CIBSE. 2000. Testing buildings for air leakage. Standard TM-23. Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers, London.

CIBSE. 2005. Natural ventilation in non-domestic buildings. Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers, London.

Claridge, D.E., and S. Bhattacharyya. 1990. The measured impact of infiltration in a test cell. ASME Journal of Solar Energy Engineering 112: 123-126.

Claridge, D.E., M. Krarti, and S. Bhattacharyya. 1988. Preliminary measurements of the energy impact of infiltration in a test cell. Proceedings of the Fifth Annual Symposium on Improving Building Energy Efficiency in Hot and Humid Climates, pp. 308-317.

Clark, J., B. Less, S. Dutton, I.Walker, and M. Sherman. 2019. Efficacy of occupancy-based smart ventilation control in residences in California and the United States. Building and Environment (156):253-267.

Clark, J., I. Walker, and G. Rojas. 2018a. Measured pollutant removal performance of range-integrated downdraft exhaust kitchen ventilation device. Proceedings of Indoor Air 2018, Philadelphia, PA. International Society for IAQ.

Clark, J., G. Rojas, and I. Walker. 2018b. Towards the development of a standardized testing protocol for overhead island kitchen exhaust devices: Procedures, measurements and paths forward. Building and Environment 142:301-311.

Claude-Alain, R., and F. Foradini. 2002. Simple and cheap air change rate measurement using CO2 concentration decays. International Journal of Ventilation 1(1):39-44.

CMHC. 2021. HRV and ERV guide for multi-unit residential buildings. Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation. assets.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/sf/project/cmhc/pdfs/content/en/hrv-erv-guide-multi-unit-residential-buildings.pdf.

Cole, J.T., T.S. Zawacki, R.H. Elkins, J.W. Zimmer, and R.A. Macriss. 1980. Application of a generalized model of air infiltration to existing homes. ASHRAE Transactions 86(2):765. Paper DV-80-09-2.

Collet, P.F. 1981. Continuous measurements of air infiltration in occupied dwellings. Proceedings of the 2nd IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration Centre, Stockholm, p. 147.

Colliver, D., W. Murphy, and W. Sun. 1994. Development of a building component air leakage data base. ASHRAE RP-438. ASHRAE Transactions (100):292-305.

CSA. 2023. Residential mechanical ventilation systems. CAN/CSA-F326-M91 (R2023). Canadian Standards Association, Toronto.

Cummings, J.B., and J.J. Tooley, Jr. 1989. Infiltration and pressure differences induced by forced air systems in Florida residences. ASHRAE Transactions 96(20):551-560. Paper VA-89-05-4.

Cummings, J.B., J.J. Tooley, Jr., and R. Dunsmore. 1990. Impacts of duct leakage on infiltration rates, space conditioning energy use and peak electrical demand in Florida homes. Proceedings of the ACEEE Summer Study, Pacific Grove, CA. American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, Washington, D.C.

Cutter. 1987. Air-to-air heat exchangers. In Energy design update. Cutter Information Corporation, Arlington, MA.

Daish, N.C., G.Carrilho da Graca, P.F. Linden, and D. Banks. 2016. Impact of aperture separation on wind-driven single-sided natural ventilation. Building and Environment 108:122-134.

Delp, W.W. and B.C. Singer. 2012. Performance of U.S. cooking exhaust hoods. Environmental Science and Technology 46(11):6167-6176.

Diamond, R.C., J.B. Dickinson, R.D. Lipschutz, B. O’Regan, and B. Shohl. 1982. The house doctor’s manual. Report PUB-3017. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Diamond, R.C., M.P. Modera, and H.E. Feustel. 1986. Ventilation and occupant behaviour in two apartment buildings. Proceedings of the 7th IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Stratford-upon-Avon, U.K. Report LBL-21862. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Dickerhoff, D.J., D.T. Grimsrud, and R.D. Lipschutz. 1982. Component leakage testing in residential buildings. Proceedings of the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, 1982 Summer Study, Santa Cruz, CA. Report LBL 14735. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Dietz, R.N., R.W. Goodrich, E.A. Cote, and R.F. Wieser. 1986. Detailed description and performance of a passive perfluorocarbon tracer system for building ventilation and air exchange measurement. In Measured air leakage of buildings, STP 904, p. 203. H.R. Trechsel and P.L. Lagus, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Dols, W., and Polidoro, B. 2020. CONTAM User Guide and Program Documentation Version 3.4, Technical Note (NIST TN), National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD. doi.org/10.6028/NIST .TN.1887r1.

Dols, W. S., L. Wang, S. J. Emmerich, and B. J. Polidoro. 2014. Development and application of an updated whole-building coupled thermal, airflow and contaminant transport simulation program (TRNSYS/CONTAM). Journal of Building Performance Simulation: 1-21.

D’Ottavio, T.W., G.I. Senum, and R.N. Dietz. 1988. Error analysis techniques for perfluorocarbon tracer derived multizone ventilation rates. Building and Environment 23(40).

Elmroth, A., and P. Levin. 1983. Air infiltration control in housing. International Energy Agency Air Infiltration Centre, Sint-Stevens-Woluwe, Belgium.

Emmerich, S.J. 2006. Simulated performance of natural and hybrid ventilation systems in an office building. HVAC&R Research (now Science and Technology for the Built Environment) 12(4):975-1004.

Emmerich, S.J., and A.K Persily. 2001. State-of-the-art review of CO2 demand controlled ventilation technology and application. NISTIR Report 6729. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Washington, D.C.

Emmerich, S.J., J.E. Gorfain, and C. Howard-Reed. 2003. Air and pollutant transport from attached garages to residential living spaces—Literature review and field test. International Journal of Ventilation 2(3):265-276.

Emmerich, S.J., and A.K. Persily. 2005. Airtightness of commercial buildings in the U.S. Proceedings of the 26th IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Brussels, pp 65-70.

Emmerich, S.J., W. S. Dols, and B. Polidoro. 2012. Application of a natural ventilation system design tool to a school building. Proceeding of SimBuild 2012, pp. 185-192. tsapps.nist.gov/publication/get_pdf.cfm?pub_id=911004.

Emmerich, S.J., and A.K. Persily. 2014. Analysis of US commercial building envelope air leakage database to support sustainable building design. International Journal of Ventilation 12(4):331-344. www.nist.gov/manuscript-publication-search.cfm?pub_id=914293.

Enai, M., C.Y. Shaw, and J.T. Reardon. 1990. On the multiple tracer gas techniques for measuring interzonal airflows in buildings. Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre 4(3370).

Energy Resource Center. 1982. How to house doctor. University of Illinois, Chicago.

EnergyStar. 2015. EnergyStar multifamily high-rise program: Testing and verification protocols, v1.0. www.energystar.gov/partner_resources/residential_new/program_reqs/mfhr/guidance.

EPA. 2003. A standardized EPA protocol for characterizing IAQ in large office buildings. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, D.C. www.epa.gov/sites/default/files/2016-04/documents/standardized_iaq_base_protocol_for_characterizing_iaq_in_large_buildings-pdf.pdf.

Etheridge, D.W. 1977. Crack flow equations and scale effect. Building and Environment 12:181.

Etheridge, D.W., and D.K. Alexander. 1980. The British gas multi-cell model for calculating ventilation. ASHRAE Transactions 86(2):808. Paper DV-80-09-4.

Etheridge, D.W., and J.A. Nolan. 1979. Ventilation measurements at model scale in a turbulent flow. Building and Environment 14(1):53.

Eyre, D., and D. Jennings. 1983. Air-vapour barriers—A general perspective and guidelines for installation. Energy, Mines, and Resources Canada, Ottawa, ON.

Farrington, R., D. Martin, and R. Anderson. 1990. A comparison of displacement efficiency, decay time constant, and age of air for isothermal flow in an imperfectly mixed enclosure. Proceedings of the ACEEE 1990 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings, pp. 4.35-4.43. American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, Washington, D.C.

Fennell, H.C., and J. Haehnel. 2005. Setting airtightness standards. ASHRAE Journal 47(9):26-31.

Feustel, H.E., and A. Raynor-Hoosen, eds. 1990. Fundamentals of the multizone air flow model—COMIS. Technical Note 29. International Energy Agency Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Sint-Stevens-Woluwe, Belgium.

FGI. 2014. Guidelines for design and construction of hospital and healthcare facilities. American Institute of Architects, Facilities Guidelines Institute, and U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Washington, D.C.

Finch, G. 2007. The performance of rainscreen walls in coastal British Columbia. M.A.Sc. thesis. University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON.

Fine, J.P., C.H. Lozinsky, and M.F. Touchie. 2022. Reducing indirect inter-suite air flow in high-rise multi-unit residential buildings: A parametric study using a CONTAM model. ASHRAE 2022 Annual Conference, Toronto, ON.

Fisk, W.J., R.J. Prill, and O. Steppanen. 1989. A multi-tracer technique for studying rates of ventilation, air distribution patterns and air exchange efficiencies. Proceedings of Conference on Building Systems—Room Air and Air Contaminant Distribution, pp. 237-240. ASHRAE.

Fortmann, R.C., N.L. Nagda, and H.E. Rector. 1990. Comparison of methods for the measurement of air change rates and interzonal airflows to two test residences. In Air change rate and airtightness in buildings, STP 1067, pp. 104-118. M.H. Sherman, ed. American Society of Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Foster, M.P., and M.J. Down. 1987. Ventilation of livestock buildings by natural convection. Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research 37:1.

Fritz, R. L. 1989. A realistic evaluation of kitchen ventilation hood design. ASHRAE Transactions 95(1).

Fugler, D. 2004. Garage performance testing. CMHC Research Highlights (April). Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation, Ottawa, ON.

Giesbrecht, P., and G. Proskiw. 1986. An evaluation of the effectiveness of air leakage sealing. In Measured air leakage of buildings, STP 904, p. 312. H.R. Trechsel and P.L. Lagus, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Grieve, P.W. 1989. Measuring ventilation using tracer-gases. Brüel and Kjær, Denmark.

Grimsrud, D.T., M.H. Sherman, R.C. Diamond, P.E. Condon, and A.H. Rosenfeld. 1979. Infiltration-pressurization correlations: Detailed measurements in a California house. ASHRAE Transactions 85(1):851. Paper PH-79-10-5.

Grimsrud, J.E., D.T. Sherman, M.H. Janssen, A.N. Pearman, and D.T. Harrje. 1979. An intercomparison of tracer gases used for air infiltration measurements. ASHRAE Transactions 86.

Grot, R.A., and A.K. Persily. 1986. Measured air infiltration and ventilation rates in eight large office buildings. In Measured air leakage of buildings, STP 904, p. 151. H.R. Trechsel and P.L. Lagus, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

GSA. 2021. P100 Facilities standards for the public buildings service. PBS-P100. U.S. General Services Administration, Washington, D.C.

Gulay, B.W., C.D. Stewart, and G.J. Foley. 1993. Field investigation survey of airtightness, air movement and IAQ in high rise apartment buildings Summary Report. Ottawa, ON.

Guyot, G., I.S. Walker, M.H. Sherman, and J.D. Clark. 2017. Residential smart ventilation: A review. LBNL Report 2001056, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Hamlin, T., and W. Pushka. 1994. Predicted and measured air change rates in houses with predictions of occupant IAQ comfort. Proceedings of the 15th IEA Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre Conference, Buxton, U.K., pp. 771-775.

Harriman, L., B. Stephens, and T. Brennan. 2019. New Guidance for Residential Air Cleaners. ASHRAE Journal. September Issue.

Harrje, D.T., and G.J. Born. 1982. Cataloguing air leakage components in houses. Proceedings of the ACEEE 1982 Summer Study, Santa Cruz, CA. American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, Washington, D.C.

Harrje, D.T., and T.A. Mills, Jr. 1980. Air infiltration reduction through retrofitting. In Building air change rate and infiltration measurements. STP 719, p. 89. C.M. Hunt, J.C. King, and H.R. Trechsel, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Harrje, D.T., G.S. Dutt, and J. Beyea. 1979. Locating and eliminating obscure but major energy losses in residential housing. ASHRAE Transactions 85(2):521. Paper DE-79-03-1.

Harrje, D.T., R.A. Grot, and D.T. Grimsrud. 1981. Air infiltration site measurement techniques. Proceedings of the 2nd IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration Centre, p. 113. Stockholm, Sweden.

Harrje, D.T., G.S. Dutt, D.L. Bohac, and K.J. Gadsby. 1985. Documenting air movements and infiltration in multicell buildings using various tracer-gas techniques. ASHRAE Transactions 91(2):2012-2027. Paper HI-85-40-3.

Harrje, D.T., R.N. Dietz, M. Sherman, D.L. Bohac, T.W. D’Ottavio, and D.J. Dickerhoff. 1990. Tracer gas measurement systems compared in a multifamily building. In Air change rate and airtightness in buildings, STP 1067, pp. 5-12. M.H. Sherman, ed. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Heiselberg, P. 2002. Principles of hybrid ventilation. Final Report, International Energy Agency Energy Conservation in Buildings and Community Systems, Annex 35. Hybrid Ventilation Centre, Aalborg University, Denmark.

Herrlin, M.K. 1985. MOVECOMP: A static-multicell-airflow-model. ASHRAE Transactions 91(2B):1989. Paper HI-85-40-1.

Hong, T., and W.J. Fisk. 2010. Assessment of energy savings potential from the use of demand controlled ventilation in general office spaces in California. Building Simulation 3:117-124.

Honma, H. 1975. Ventilation of dwellings and its disturbances. Faibo Grafiska, Stockholm, Sweden.

Hopkins, L.P., and B. Hansford. 1974. Air flow through cracks. Building Service Engineer 42(September):123.

Hunt, C.M. 1980. Air infiltration: A review of some existing measurement techniques and data. In Building air change rate and infiltration measurements, STP 719, p. 3. C.M. Hunt, J.C. King, and H.R. Trechsel, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Hutcheon, N.B., and Handegord, G.O.P. 1995. Building science for a cold climate. National Research Council of Canada.

ICC. 2021. International energy conservation code® (IECC®). International Code Council, Washington, D.C.

ICC. 2015. ICC/ASHRAE 700-2015 National Green Building Standard. ANSI, NAHB, ASHRAE, International Code Council, Washington, D.C.

ISO. 2015. Thermal performance of buildings—Determination of air permeability of buildings—Fan pressurization method. Standard 9972-2015. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva.

Iwashita, G., K. Kimura., et al. 1989. Pilot study on addition of olf units for perceived air pollution sources. Proceedings of the SHASE Annual Meeting, pp. 3221-3324. Society of Heating, Air-Conditioning and Sanitary Engineers of Japan, Tokyo.

Jacobson, D.I., G.S. Dutt, and R.H. Socolow. 1986. Pressurization testing, infiltration reduction, and energy savings. In Measured air leakage of buildings, STP 904, p. 265. H.R. Trechsel and P.L. Lagus, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Janu, G.J., J.D. Wegner, and C.G. Nesler. 1995. Outdoor airflow control for VAV systems. ASHRAE Journal 37(4):62-68.

Jo, J.H., J.H. Lim, S.Y. Song, M.S. Yeo, and K.W. Kim. 2007. Characteristics of pressure distribution and solution to the problems caused by stack effect in high-rise residential buildings. Building and Environment. 42:263-277.

Jo J.H., H.T. Seok, M.S. Yeo, and K.W. Kim. 2009. Simplified prediction method of stack-induced pressure distribution in high-rise residential buildings. Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering. 8(1):283-290.

Johnson, T., and T. Long. 2005. Determining the frequency of open windows in residences: A pilot study in Durham, North Carolina during varying temperature conditions. Journal of Exposure Analysis and Environmental Epidemiology 15(4):329-349.

Jones, D. 2022. Testing tales from the Northwest. ABAA Building Enclosure Conference, Reston, VA, May 10 – 11, 2022.

Jones, D., B. Brown, T. Thompson, and G. Finch. 2014. Building enclosure airtightness testing in Washington state—Lessons learned about air barrier systems and large building testing procedures. Presented at ASHRAE Annual Conference.

Judkoff, R., J.D. Balcomb, C.E. Handcock, G. Barker, and K. Subbarao. 1997. Side-by-side thermal tests of modular offices: A validation study of the STEM method. Report. National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO.

Jump, D.A., I.S. Walker, and M.P. Modera. 1996. Field measurements of efficiency and duct retrofit effectiveness in residential forced air distribution systems. Proceedings of the 1996 ACEEE Summer Study, pp. 1.147-1.156. American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy, Washington, D.C.

Kaschuba-Holtgrave, A., A. Rohr, S. Rolfsmeier, and O. Solcher. 2018. Individual unit and guard-zone airtightness tests of apartment buildings. Journal of Building Physics 1-37.

Kelnhofer, J., C.M. Hunt, and D.A. Didion. 1976. Determination of combined air infiltration and ventilation rates in a nine-story office building. AIVC. www.aivc.org/sites/default/files/members_area/medias/pdf/Airbase/airbase_00435.pdf.

Khemet, B. ,and R. Richman. 2018. A univariate and multiple linear regression analysis on a national fan (de)pressurization testing database to predict airtightness in houses. Building and Environment 146:88-97.

Kiel, D.E., and D.J. Wilson. 1986. Gravity driven airflows through open doors, 15.1. Proceedings of the 7th IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Stratford-upon-Avon, U.K.

Klote, J.H., J.A. Milke, P.G. Turnbull, A. Kashef, and M.J. Ferreira. 2012. Handbook of smoke control engineering. ASHRAE.

Kohonen, R., T. Ojanen, and M. Virtanen. 1987. Thermal coupling of leakage flows and heating load of buildings. Proceedings of the 8th IEA Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre Conference, Überlingen, Germany, pp. 10.1-10.22.

Kono, J., J. Gieselman, M.K. McNulty, and B. Abramson. 2022. Increasing ventilation in 1980s high-rise commercial office buildings. ASHRAE Journal 64(11).

Kreith, F., and R. Eisenstadt. 1957. Pressure drop and flow characteristics of short capillary tubes at low Reynolds numbers. ASME Transactions, pp. 1070-1078.

Kronvall, J. 1980. Correlating pressurization and infiltration rate data—Tests of an heuristic model. Lund Institute of Technology, Division of Building Technology, Lund, Sweden.

Kuehn, T.H., J. Ramsey, H. Han, M. Perkovich, and S. Yuossef. 1989. A study of kitchen range exhaust systems. ASHRAE Transactions (95)1: 744-752.

Kumar, R., A.D. Ireson, and H.W. Orr. 1979. An automated air infiltration measuring system using SF6 tracer gas in constant concentration and decay methods. ASHRAE Transactions 85(2):385. Paper DE-2553.

Lagus, P.L. 1989. Tracer measurement instrumentation suitable for infiltration, air leakage, and airflow pattern characterization. Proceedings of the Conference on Building Systems—Room Air and Air Contaminant Distribution, pp. 97-102. ASHRAE.

Lagus, P., and A.K. Persily. 1985. A review of tracer-gas techniques for measuring airflows in buildings. ASHRAE Transactions 91(2B):1075. Paper HI-85-2-1.

Lau, J., X. Lin, and G. Yuill. 2014. CO2-based demand controlled ventilation for multiple zone HVAC systems. ASHRAE RP-1547.

Lecompte, J.G.N. 1987. The influence of natural convection in an insulated cavity on thermal performance of a wall. In Insulation materials, testing, and applications. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Less, B.D. and I.S. Walker. 2016. Smart ventilation control of indoor humidity in high performance homes in humid U.S. climates. Proceedings of ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Buildings Conference XIII, Clearwater Beach, FL. ASHRAE, Atlanta, GA. LBNL 1006980.

Less, B., I. S. Walker, and Y. Tang. 2014. Development of an outdoor temperature-based control algorithm for residential mechanical ventilation control.

LBNL Report 6936E. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory: Berkeley, CA.

Less, B., S. Dutton, I. Walker, M. Sherman, and J. Clark. 2019. Energy savings with outdoor temperature-based smart ventilation control strategies in advanced California homes. Energy and Buildings 194:317-327.

Levin, P. 1988. Air leakage between apartments. 9th AIVC Conference: Air Movement and Ventilation Within Buildings. pg. 251–263.

Li, Y., and A. Delsante. 1996. Derivation of capture efficiency of kitchen range hoods in a confined space. Building and Environment 31(5):461-468.

Li, Y., A. Delsante, and J. Symons. 1997. Residential kitchen range hoods—Buoyancy-capture principle and capture efficiency revisited. Indoor Air 7(3): 151-157.

Li, Y., and P. Heiselberg. 2003. Analysis methods for natural and hybrid ventilation—A critical literature review and recent developments. International Journal of Ventilation 1(4):3-20.

Liddament, M.W. 1988. The calculation of wind effect on ventilation. ASHRAE Transactions 94(2):1645-1660. Paper OT-88-13-1.

Liddament, M., and C. Allen. 1983. The validation and comparison of mathematical models of air infiltration. Technical Note 11. International Energy Agency Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Sint-Stevens-Woluwe, Belgium.

Lim, K., and C. Lee. 2008. A numerical study on the characteristics of flow field, temperature and concentration distribution according to changing the shape of separation plate of kitchen hood system. Energy and Buildings 40(2):175-184.

Liu, M., and D.E. Claridge. 1992a. The measured energy impact of infiltration under dynamic conditions. Proceedings of the 8th Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, Dallas.

Liu, M., and D.E. Claridge. 1992b. The measured energy impact of infiltration in a test cell. Proceedings of the 8th Symposium on Improving Building Systems in Hot and Humid Climates, Dallas.

Liu, M., and D.E. Claridge. 1992c. The energy impact of combined solar radiation/infiltration/conduction effects in walls and attics. Proceedings of the Thermal Performance of Exterior Envelopes of Buildings, 5th ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC Conference, Clearwater Beach, FL.

Liu, M., and D.E. Claridge. 1995. Experimental methods for identifying infiltration heat recovery in building. Proceedings of the Thermal Performance of Exterior Envelopes of Buildings, 6th ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC Conference, Clearwater Beach, FL.

Lo, J., D. Banks, and A. Novoselac. 2013. Combined wind tunnel and CFD analysis for indoor airflow prediction of wind-driven cross ventilation. Building and Environment 60:12-23.

Love, J.A. 1990. Airtightness survey of row houses in Calgary, Alberta. In Air Change Rate and Airtightness in Buildings, ASTM STP 1067, Philadelphia, PA, 194-210.

Lozinsky, C.H. and M.F. Touchie. 2020. Inter-zonal airflow in multi-unit residential buildings: A review of the magnitude and interaction of driving forces, measurement techniques and magnitudes, and its impact on building performance. Indoor Air 30:1083-1108.

Lozinsky, C.H. and M.F. Touchie. 2021. Suite-level air tightness and compartmentalization in multi-unit residential buildings: How do we achieve our intended goals? Building and Environment 192:107600.

Lozinsky, C.H., H. Stopps, H., and M.F Touchie. 2023. In-situ performance of a pressurized corridor ventilation system: a long-term study in a high-rise multi-unit residential building. Journal of Building Engineering, 70(1):106320.

Lozinsky, C.H. and M.F. Touchie. 2023a. Quantifying suite-level airtightness in newly constructed multi-unit residential buildings using guarded suite-level air leakage testing. Building and Environment. 236:110273.

Lozinsky, C.H. and M.F. Touchie. 2024. Size matters (at least for interior air flow pathways): the indoor air quality and energy implications of compartmentalization in multi-unit residential buildings. Building and Environment. 253:111275.

Madsen, U., N. O. Breum, and P. V. Nielsen. 1994. Local exhaust ventilation-a numerical and experimental study of capture efficiency. Building and Environment 29(3):319-323.

Marbek Resource Consultants. 1984. Air sealing homes for energy conservation. Energy, Mines and Resources Canada, Buildings Energy Technology Transfer Program, Ottawa, ON.

Martin, E., D. Parker, and K. Fenaughty. 2018. Energy savings and comfort enhancement potential of a smart residential ventilation control strategy. Proceedings of the ACEEE 2018 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency of Buildings, Pacific Grove, CA.

McDowell, T.P., S. Emmerich, J.W. Thornton, and G. Walton. 2003. Integration of airflow and energy simulation using CONTAM and TRNSYS. ASHRAE Transactions 109(2):757-770. Paper KC-03-10-2.

McNulty, M.K., J. Kono, and B. Abramson. 2022. From guidance to implementation: Applying ASHRAE Epidemic Task Force building readiness strategies in 95 commercial office buildings. ASHRAE Transactions 128(1):393-401.

McWilliams, J., and M. Sherman. 2005. Review of literature related to residential ventilation requirements. Paper LBNL-57236. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Mélois, A. B., B. Moujalled, G. Guyot, and V. Leprince. 2019. Improving building envelope knowledge from analysis of 219,000 certified on-site air leakage measurements in France. Building and Environment. 159:106145.

Merrin, Z., Francisco, P. W., Bohac, D., Quinnell, J. A., & Olson, C. 2018. An evaluation of strategies to reduce transport of pollutants from garages to homes. Science and Technology for the Built Environment 24(2):198-208.

Modera, M.P., R.C. Diamond, and J.T. Brunsell. 1986. Improving diagnostics and energy analysis for multifamily buildings: A case study. Oak Ridge National Laboratory. web.ornl.gov/sci/buildings/conf-archive/1985B3papers/050.pdf.

Modera, M.P. 1989. Residential duct system leakage: Magnitude, impacts, and potential for reduction. ASHRAE Transactions 96(2):561-569. Paper VA-89-05-5.

Modera, M.P., and D.J. Wilson. 1990. The effects of wind on residential building leakage measurements. In Air change rate and airtightness in buildings, STP 1067, pp. 132-145. M.H. Sherman, ed. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA. Report LBL-24195.

Modera, M.P., D. Dickerhoff, R. Jansky, and B. Smith. 1991. Improving the energy efficiency of residential air distribution systems in California. Report LBL-30866. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Mumma, S.A. 2004. Transient occupancy ventilation by monitoring CO2. ASHRAE IAQ Applications, Winter 2004.

Mumma, S.A., and K.M. Shank. 2001. Achieving dry outside air in an energy efficient manner. ASHRAE Transactions 107(1):553-561. Paper AT-01-07-2.

Mumma, S.A., and Y.M. Wong. 1990. Analytical evaluation of outdoor airflow rate variation vs. supply airflow rate variation in VAV systems when the outside air damper position is fixed. ASHRAE Transactions 90(1):1197-1208.

Murphy, W.E., D.G. Colliver, and L.R. Piercy. 1991. Repeatability and reproducibility of fan pressurization devices in measuring building air leakage. ASHRAE Transactions 97(2):885-895. Paper IN-91-12-1.

NRCC. 2020. National Building Code of Canada. National Research Council of Canada, Ottawa, ON.

Nelson, B.D., D.A. Robinson, and G.D. Nelson. 1985. Designing the envelope—Guidelines for buildings (SP-49). Proceedings of the ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC Conference—Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Buildings III, Florida, pp. 1117-1122.

Ng, L.C., A. Musser, A.K. Persily, and S.J. Emmerich. 2012. Airflow and IAQ models of DOE reference commercial buildings. Technical Note 1734. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD.

Ng, L.C., A.K. Persily, and S.J. Emmerich. 2015. Improving infiltration modeling in commercial building energy models. Energy and Buildings 88:316-323.

Ng, L.C., N.O. Quiles, W.S. Dols, and S.J. Emmerich, 2018. Weather correlations to calculate infiltration rates for US commercial building energy models. Building and Environment 127:47-57.

Nylund, P.O. 1980. Infiltration and ventilation. Report D22:1980. Swedish Council for Building Research, Stockholm.

O’Neill, Z.D., Y. Li, H.C. Cheng, X. Zhou, and S.T. Taylor. 2020. Energy savings and ventilation performance from CO2-based demand controlled ventilation: Simulation results from ASHRAE RP-1747. ASHRAE RP-1747, Report.

Orme, M. 1999. Applicable models for air infiltration and ventilation calculations. Technical Note 51. International Energy Agency Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Sint-Stevens-Woluwe, Belgium.

Ormerod, R. 1983. Nuclear shelters: A guide to design. Architectural Press, London.

Palmiter, L., and T. Bond. 1994. Modeled and measured infiltration II—A detailed case study of three homes. Report TR 102511. Electric Power Research Institute, Palo Alto, CA.

Palmiter, L., and I. Brown. 1989. The Northwest residential infiltration survey: Description and summary of results. Proceedings of the ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC/CIBSE Conference—Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Buildings IV, Florida, pp. 445-457.

Pan, W. 2010. Relationships between air-tightness and its influencing factors of post-2006 new-build dwellings in the UK. Building and Environment. 45:2387–2399.

Parekh, A., K. Ruest, and M. Jacobs. 1991. Comparison of airtightness, IAQ and power consumption before and after air-sealing of high-rise residential buildings. Proceedings of the 12th IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Sint-Stevens-Woluwe, Belgium.

Parker, G.B., M. McSorley, and J. Harris. 1990. The Northwest residential infiltration survey: A field study of ventilation in new houses in the Pacific North-west. In Air change rate and airtightness in buildings, STP 1067, pp. 93-103. M.H. Sherman, ed. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Persily, A.K. 1986. Measurements of air infiltration and airtightness in passive solar homes. In Measured air leakage of buildings, STP 904, p. 46. H.R. Trechsel and P.L. Lagus, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Persily, A.K. 1988. Tracer gas techniques for studying building air exchange. Report NBSIR 88-3708. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD.

Persily, A.K. 2004. Building ventilation and pressurization as a security tool. ASHRAE Journal 46 (9):18-24.

Persily, A.K., and J. Axley. 1990. Measuring airflow rates with pulse tracer techniques. In Air change rate and airtightness in buildings, pp. 31-51. STP 1067. M.H. Sherman, ed. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Persily, A.K. and L de Jonge. 2017. Carbon dioxide generation rates for building occupants. Indoor Air 27(5):868-879.

Persily, A.K., and R.A. Grot. 1985a. The airtightness of office building envelopes. Proceedings of the ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC Conference on the Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Buildings III, Clearwater Beach, FL, p. 125.

Persily, A.K., and R.A. Grot. 1985b. Accuracy in pressurization data analysis. ASHRAE Transactions 91(2B):105. Paper HI-85-03-2.

Persily, A.K., and R.A. Grot. 1986. Pressurization testing of federal buildings. In Measured air leakage of buildings, STP 904, p. 184. H.R. Trechsel and P.L. Lagus, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Persily, A.K., and G.T. Linteris. 1983. A comparison of measured and predicted infiltration rates. ASHRAE Transactions 89(2):183. Paper DC-83-04-1. Persily, A.K., J. Gorfain, and G. Brunner. 2005. Ventilation design and performance in U.S. office buildings. ASHRAE Journal 47(4):30-35.

Persily, A.K., R.E. Chapman, S. Emmerich, W.S. Dols, H. Davis, P. Lavappa, and A. Rushing. 2007. Building retrofits for increased protection against airborne chemical and biological releases. NISTIR Report 7379. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD.

Persily, A., and L. de Jonge. 2017. Carbon dioxide generation rates for building occupants. Indoor Air 27(5):868–79.

Powell, F., M. Krarti, and A. Tuluca. 1989. Air movement influence on the effective thermal resistance of porous insulations: A literature survey. Journal of Thermal Insulation 12:239-251.

Price, P.N., and M.H. Sherman. 2006. Ventilation behavior and household characteristics in new California houses. Report LBNL-59620.

Proskiw G., and B. Phillips. 2008. An examination of air pressure and air movement patterns in multi-unit residential buildings. Building Enclosure Science and Technology (BEST) Conference. Minneapolis, MN.

RDH. 2013. Air leakage control in multi-unit residential buildings. Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation.

Reardon, J.T., and C.Y. Shaw. 1997. Evaluation of five simple ventilation strategies suitable for houses without forced-air heating. ASHRAE Transactions 103(1):731-744. Paper PH-97-08-5.

Reeves, G., M.F. McBride, and C.F. Sepsy. 1979. Air infiltration model for residences. ASHRAE Transactions 85(1):667. Paper PH-79-07A-1.

Ricketts, L. 2014. A field study of airflow in a high-rise multi-unit residential building. M.A.Sc. Thesis, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON.

Riley, M. 1990. IAQ and energy conservation: The R-2000 home program experience. Proceedings of Indoor Air ’90: International Conference on IAQ and Climate, Ottawa, vol. 5, p. 143.

Rim, D. H., A. K. Persily, and L. L. Wallace. 2011. Reduction of exposure to ultrafine particles by kitchen exhaust fans of varying flow rates. Presented at 12th International Conference on IAQ and Climate, International Society of IAQ and Climate, Austin, TX.

Rim, D., L. Wallace, S. Nabinger, and A. Persily. 2012. Reduction of exposure to ultrafine particles by kitchen exhaust hoods: The effects of exhaust flow rates, particle size, and burner position. Science of the Total Environment 432:350-356.

Robison, P.E., and L.A. Lambert. 1989. Field investigation of residential infiltration and heating duct leakage. ASHRAE Transactions 95(2):542-550. Paper VA-89-05-3.

Rock, B.A. 1992. Characterization of transient pollutant transport, dilution, and removal for the study of IAQ. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Colorado at Boulder. University Microfilms International.

Rock, B.A. 2005. A user-friendly model and coefficients for slab-on-grade load and energy calculations. ASHRAE Transactions 111(2):122-136. Paper 4795.

Rudd, A.F. 1998. Design/sizing methodology and economic evaluation of central-fan-integrated supply ventilation systems. ACEEE 1998 Summer Study on Energy Efficiency in Buildings. 23-28 August, Pacific Grove, CA. American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy, Washington, D.C.

Russell, M., M. Sherman, and A. Rudd. 2005. Review of residential ventilation technologies. Paper LBNL-576. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Sandberg, M.H. 1981. What is ventilation efficiency? Building and Environment 16:123-135.

Seppanen, O.A., W.J. Fisk and M.J. Mendell. 1999. Association of ventilation rates and CO2 concentrations with health and other responses in commercial and institutional buildings. Indoor Air 9(4):226-252.

Seventhwave. 2015. Energy savings from implementing and energy savings from implementing and commissioning demand control ventilation. mn.gov/commerce-stat/pdfs/card-report-energy-savings-demand-control-ventilation.pdf.

Shaw, C.Y. 1980. Methods for conducting small-scale pressurization tests and air leakage data of multi-storey apartment buildings. ASHRAE Transactions 86(1):241-250.

Shaw, C.Y. 1981. A correlation between air infiltration and air tightness for a house in a developed residential area. ASHRAE Transactions 87(2):333. Paper CI-2655.

Shaw, C.Y., and W.C. Brown. 1982. Effect of a gas furnace chimney on the air leakage characteristic of a two-story detached house. Proceedings of the 3rd IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration Centre, London.

Shaw, C.Y., R.J. Magee, and J. Rousseau. 1991. Overall and component airtightness values of a five-story apartment building. ASHRAE Transactions 97(2):347-353.

Sherman, M.H. 1986. Infiltration degree-days: A statistic for quantifying infiltration-related climate. ASHRAE Transactions 92(2):161-181. Paper 2986. Sherman, M.H. 1987. Estimation of infiltration from leakage and climate indications. Energy and Buildings 10(1):81.

Sherman, M.H. 1989a. Uncertainty in airflow calculations using tracer gas measurements. Building and Environment 24(4):347-354.

Sherman, M.H. 1989b. On the estimation of multizone ventilation rates from tracer gas measurements. Building and Environment 24(4):355-362. Sherman, M.H. 1990. Tracer gas techniques for measuring ventilation in a single zone. Building and Environment 25(4):365-374.

Sherman, M.H. 1991. Single-zone stack-dominated infiltration modeling. Proceedings of the 12th IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Ottawa, ON, pp. 297-314.

Sherman, M.H. 1992a. A power law formulation of laminar flow in short pipes. Journal of Fluids Engineering 114:601-605. Report LBL-29414, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Sherman, M.H. 1992b. Superposition in infiltration modeling. Indoor Air 2:101-114.

Sherman, M.H., and D. Dickerhoff. 1989. Description of the LBL multitracer measurement system. Proceedings of the ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC/CIBSE Conference—Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Buildings IV, pp. 417-432.

Sherman, M.H., and D.T. Grimsrud. 1980. Infiltration-pressurization correlation: Simplified physical modeling. ASHRAE Transactions 86(2): 778. Paper DV-80-09-3.

Sherman, M.H., and N. Matson. 1997. Residential ventilation and energy characteristics. ASHRAE Transactions 103(1):717-730. Paper PH-97-08-4.

Sherman, M.H., and M.P. Modera. 1986. Comparison of measured and predicted infiltration using the LBL infiltration model. In Measured air leakage of buildings, STP 904, p. 325. H.R. Trechsel and P.L. Lagus, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Sherman, M.H., and D.J. Wilson. 1986. Relating actual and effective ventilation in determining IAQ. Building and Environment 21(3/4):135.

Sherman, M.H., D.T. Grimsrud, P.E. Condon, and B.V. Smith. 1980. Air infiltration measurement techniques. Proceedings of the 1st IEA Conference of theAir Infiltration Centre, London. Report LBL-10705. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Sherman, M.H., I.S. Walker, and J.M. Logue. 2011. Equivalence in ventilation and IAQ. HVAC&R Research (now Science and Technology for the Built Environment) 189(4):760-773.

Shin, H.K., and J.H. Jo. 2013. Air leakage characteristics and leakage distribution of dwellings in high-rise residential buildings in Korea. Journal of Asian Architcture and Building Engineering. 12:87–92.

Shin, H.K., K.H. Ji, H. Cho, Y.H. Cho, and J.H. Jo. 2015. Impact of stack-induced infiltration on heating load in the high-rise building. ISHVAC-COBEE 2015: International Conference on Building Energy and Environment. Tianjin, CN.

Simmonds, P., and D. Phillips. 2021. The influence of outdoor conditions on the heating and cooling loads of supertall and mega tall buildings. CIBSE 2021 REV 1, Proceedings of the CIBSE Technical Symposium 2021, Virtual.

Sinden, F.W. 1978. Wind, temperature and natural ventilation—Theoretical considerations. Energy and Buildings 1(3):275.

Singer, B. C., W. W. Delp, and M. G. Apte. 2010. Experimental evaluation of installed cooking exhaust fan performance. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA. indoor.lbl.gov/publications/experimental-evaluation-installed.

Singer, B. C., W. W. Delp, P. N. Price, and M. G. Apte. 2012. Performance of installed cooking exhaust devices. Indoor Air 22(3):224-234.

Sorensen, J.H., and B.M. Vogt. 2001. Will duct tape and plastic really work? Issues related to expedient sheltering-in-place. Report ORNL/TM-2001/154. Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN.

SQCAQMD. 2024. South Coast Air Quality Management District AQ-SPEC Air Quality Sensor Performance Evaluation Center. www.aqmd.gov/aq-spec.

Stathopoulos, T., D. Surry, and A.G. Davenport. 1979. Internal pressure characteristics of low-rise buildings due to wind action. Wind Engineering 1:451-463.

Stratton, J.C., and B.C. Singer. 2014. Addressing kitchen contaminants for healthy, low-energy homes. LBNL Report 6547E.

Tamura, G.T., and C.Y. Shaw. 1976a. Studies on exterior wall air tightness and air infiltration of tall buildings. ASHRAE Transactions 82(1):122. Paper DA- 2388.

Tamura, G.T., and C.Y. Shaw. 1976b. Air leakage data for the design of elevator and stair shaft pressurization system. ASHRAE Transactions 82(2):179. Paper SE-2413.

Tamura, G.T., and A.G. Wilson. 1966. Pressure differences for a nine-story building as a result of chimney effect and ventilation system operation. ASHRAE Transactions 72(1):180-189.

Tamura, G.T., and A.G. Wilson. 1967a. Pressure differences caused by chimney effect in three high buildings. ASHRAE Transactions 73(2):II.1.1.

Tamura, G.T., and A.G. Wilson. 1967b. Building pressures caused by chimney action and mechanical ventilation. ASHRAE Transactions 73(2):II.2.1.

Tian, X., J. Fine, and M.F. Touchie. 2020. Investigating the impact of sweeps and weather stripping on suite door air tightness in multi-family buildings. ASHRAE 2020 Winter Conference.

Timusk, J., A.L. Seskus, and K. Linger. 1992. A systems approach to extend the limit of envelope performance. Proceedings of the 6th ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC Conference—Thermal Performance of Exterior Envelopes of Buildings, Clearwater Beach, FL.

Turk, B.T., D.T. Grimsrud, J.T. Brown, K.L. Geisling-Sobotka, J. Harrison, and R.J. Prill. 1989. Commercial building ventilation rates and particle concentrations. ASHRAE Transactions 95(1):422-433. Paper 3248.

Urquhart, R., R. Richman, and G. Finch. 2015. The effect of an enclosure retrofit on air leakage rates for a multi-unit residential case-study building. Energy and Buildings 86:35-44.

USACE. 2013. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers air leakage test protocol for building envelopes. Air Barrier Association of America, Walpole, MA, and U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

Verschoor, J.D., and J.O. Collins. 1986. Demonstration of air leakage reduction program in navy family housing. In Measured air leakage of buildings, STP 904, p. 294. H.R. Trechsel and P.L. Lagus, eds. American Society for Testing and Materials, West Conshohocken, PA.

Vinha, J., E. Manelius, M. Korpi, K. Salminen, J. Kurnitski, M. Kiviste, and A. Laukkarinen. 2015. Airtightness of residential buildings in Finland. Building and Environment. 93:128-140.

Walker, I.S. 1999. Distribution system leakage impacts on apartment building ventilation rates. ASHRAE Transactions 105(1):943-950. Paper CH-99-14-2.

Walker, I.S., and T.W. Forest. 1995. Field measurements of ventilation rates in attics. Building and Environment 30(3):333-347.

Walker, I.S., and D.J. Wilson. 1993. Evaluating models for superposition of wind and stack effects in air infiltration. Building and Environment 28(2):201-210.

Walker, I.S., D.J. Wilson., and M.H. Sherman. 1997. A comparison of the power law to quadratic formulations for air infiltration calculations. Energy and Buildings 27(3).

Walker, I.S., and D.J. Wilson. 1998. Field validation of algebraic equations for stack and wind driven air infiltration calculations. International Journal of HVAC&R Research (now Science and Technology for the Built Environment) 4(2):119-140.

Walker, I.S., M. Sherman, J. Siegel, D. Wang, C. Buchanan, and M. Modera. 1999. Leakage diagnostics, sealant longevity, sizing and technology transfer in residential thermal distribution systems: Part II. Report LBNL-42691.

Walker, I. S., M. Sherman, and D. Dickerhoff. 2012. Development of a residential integrated ventilation controller. LBNL Report 5554E. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA.

Walker, I.S., J.C. Stratton, W.W. Delp, and M.H. Sherman. 2016. Development of a tracer gas capture efficiency test method for residential kitchen ventilation. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley, CA. indoor.lbl.gov/publications/development-tracer-gas-capture.

Walton, G.N. 1984. A computer algorithm for predicting infiltration and interroom airflows. ASHRAE Transactions 90(1B):601. Paper AT-84-11-3.

Walton, G.N. 1989. Airflow network models for element-based building airflow modeling. ASHRAE Transactions 95(2):611-620. Paper VA-89-06-5.

Warren, P.R., and B.C. Webb. 1980. The relationship between tracer gas and pressurization techniques in dwellings. Proceedings of the 1st IEA Conference of the Air Infiltration Centre, London.

Weidt, J.L., J. Weidt, and S. Selkowitz. 1979. Field air leakage of newly installed residential windows. Proceedings of the ASHRAE/DOE Conference—Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Buildings Orlando, FL, p. 149.

Weschler, C.J. 2000. Ozone in indoor environments: Concentration and chemistry. Indoor Air 10:269-288.

Weschler, C.J., and W.W. Nazaroff. 2008 Semivolatile organic compounds in indoor environments. Atmospheric Environment 42(40):9018-9040.

Wilson, D.J., and I.S. Walker. 1992. Feasibility of passive ventilation by constant area vents to maintain IAQ in houses. Proceedings of IAQ ’92, ASHRAE/ACGIH/AIHA Conference, San Francisco.

Wilson, D.J., and I.S. Walker. 1993. Infiltration data from the Alberta Home Heating Research Facility. Technical Note 41. Air Infiltration and Ventilation Centre, Sint-Stevens-Woluwe, Belgium.

Wolbrink, D. W. and J.R. Sarnosky. 1992. Residential kitchen ventilation-a guide for the specifying engineer. ASHRAE Transactions 98(2):1187-1198.

Wolf, S. 1966. A theory of the effects of convective air flow through fibrous thermal insulation. ASHRAE Transactions 72(1):III 2.1-III 2.9.

Won, D., G. Nong, and S. So. 2021. Development of formaldehyde flux sampler using a commercial DNPH cartridge. Building and Environment, 196, 107795.

Xiong, Z., J. Berquist, H.B. Gunay, and C.A. Cruickshank. 2021. An inquiry into the use of indoor CO2 and humidity ratio trend data with inverse modelling to estimate air infiltration. Building and Environment 206:108365.

Yaglou, C.P., E.C. Riley, and D.I. Coggins. 1936. Ventilation requirements. ASHVE Transactions 42:133.

Yuill, G.K. 1986. The variation of the effective natural ventilation rate with weather conditions. Proceedings of the Solar Energy Society of Canada Renewable Energy Conference ’86, pp. 70-75.

Yuill, G.K. 1991. The development of a method of determining air change rates in detached dwellings for assessing IAQ. ASHRAE Transactions 97(2):896-903. Paper IN-91-12-2.

Yuill, G.K. 1996. Impact of high use automatic doors on infiltration. ASHRAE Research Project RP-763, Final Report.

Yuill, D.P., G.K. Yuill, and A.H. Coward. 2008. Measurement and analysis of vitiation of secondary air in air distribution systems (RP-1276). HVAC&R Research (now Science and Technology for the Built Environment) 14(3):345-357.

Yuill, D.P., G.K. Yuill, and A.H. Coward. 2012. Experimental validation of the multiple-zone system ventilation efficiency equation of ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 62.1 (RP-1276). HVAC&R Research (now Science and Technology for the Built Environment) 18(3).

Zhivov, A. 2013. Air tightness in new and retrofitted US army buildings. Air Barrier Association of America, Walpole, MA.



The preparation of this chapter is assigned to TC 4.3, Ventilation Requirements and Infiltration.